大学生专业收获目的性的结构及其规范重构OACHSSCD
The Structure of Purposefulness in College Students' Disciplinary Gains and Its Normative Reconstruction
在学习收获成为人才培养核心话语的背景下,大学生在专业学习中收获了什么被频繁量化,却较少追问这些收获究竟是为了什么.如果不触及专业收获背后的目的性结构,再精细的成效评估也难以摆脱单一工具理性的窠臼.在梳理相关研究的基础上,结合比斯塔的教育目的论,将专业收获目的性界定为大学生在专业学习过程中对收获所指向的整体结构与价值位序,并确定其内在结构的基本框架,即工具性目的、发展性目的与公共性目的.在此基础上,首先,勾勒出大学生专业收获目的性的现实图景,揭示工具性目的过度扩张、发展性目的被挤压以及公共性目的边缘化等结构失衡;继而,从教育目的论、成才优先结构以及工具理性扩张与制度话语、学校实践、个体选择的共构机制等方面,分析专业收获目的性失衡的主要原因;最后,提出专业收获目的性的规范重构路径,主张以发展性目的为核心整合工具性目的,以公共性目的作为边界与指引,并通过"制度—教学—个体"的三位一体进路,提升大学生对为何而收获的自觉.
Against the backdrop where learning gains have become a central discourse in talent cultivation,what col-lege students gain from their disciplinary studies is frequently quantified,yet the underlying purposes of these gains are seldom questioned.Without addressing the structure of purposefulness behind disciplinary gains,even the most refined outcome assessments risk remaining confined to a singular instrumental rationality.Drawing on relevant literature and in-formed by Gert Biesta's teleology of education,this study defines the purposefulness of disciplinary gains as the overall structure and value hierarchy that college students attribute to what they gain during their disciplinary learning.It identi-fies three fundamental dimensions within this structure:instrumental purposes,developmental purposes,and public pur-poses.Based on this framework,the study first outlines the current landscape of purposefulness in college students' disci-plinary gains,revealing a structural imbalance characterized by the excessive expansion of instrumental purposes,the com-pression of developmental purposes,and the marginalization of public purposes.It then analyzes the main causes of this imbalance from perspectives including educational teleology,the prevailing success-first mentality,the co-constitutive mechanisms linking instrumental rationality with institutional discourse,school practices,and individual choices.Finally,the study proposes pathways for the normative reconstruction of purposefulness in disciplinary gains.It advocates placing developmental purposes at the core to integrate instrumental purposes,with public purposes serving as both boundary and guide.Through a tripartite approach engaging institutions,teaching practices,and individuals,the aim is to enhance stu-dents' conscious awareness of why they pursue certain gains.
廖智鑫
厦门大学教育研究院 福建厦门 361005
社会科学
大学生选择专业收获目的性结构
choices of college studentsdisciplinary gainsstructure of purposefulness
《教育与教学研究》 2026 (3)
18-33,16
国家自然科学基金"高校学生分类成长规律体系及培养机制研究"(批准号:71964008).
评论