两种激光粒度仪测定黑土颗粒组成的比较与转换OA
Comparison and conversion of particle size distribution measurements for black soil using two types of laser particle sizers
为揭示Malvern MS3000与Beckman Coulter LS13320两种激光粒度仪在黑土颗粒组成测定中的系统差异及其与吸管法的关系,并实现仪器间及与吸管法数据的转换,文章基于 33 个东北黑土区的样品构建转换公式,另对114个鹤北小流域样品进行了转换验证,将转换后数据分别用于国际制与美国制土壤质地分类.结果表明,吸管法测得的土壤黏粒含量高于两种激光粒度仪法,砂粒含量则介于二者之间,但吸管法与两种粒度仪数据均呈极显著相关.经所建公式校正后,两种激光粒度仪间的数据差异明显缩小,转换后数据在国际制质地分类中的一致率达 93.0%,而美国制仅为58.8%.上述结果说明,两种激光粒度仪的原始数据不可直接比较,但所建转换关系可有效校正系统偏差,转换后数据适用于国际制质地分类,对美国制分类的适用性则有限.研究结果为黑土不同激光粒度仪历史数据的整合与再分析提供了可行的校准途径.
[Objective]Particle size data for black soil,measured using a Malvern laser particle size analyzer,were compared with those obtained using a Beckman laser particle size analyzer,and both results were benchmarked against data obtained using the pipette method.The study aimed to establish formulas for interconverting laser diffraction data to those from the pipette method,and for interconverting data obtained using the two laser particle size analyzers.[Methods]A total of 147 black soil samples were tested.Among them,33 surface soil samples collected from different regions of the black soil area were analyzed using the laser particle size analyzers and the pipette method to establish formulas for interconversion of the data from the laser diffraction and pipette methods and for interconversion of the data from the two laser particle size analyzers.Another 114 black soil samples collected from the Hebei small watershed were only tested using the two laser particle size analyzers.The effectiveness of the formulas for interconversion of the data measured using the two particle size analyzers was evaluated.The data from the two laser particle size analyzers for the 114 samples from the small watershed were converted to align with those from the pipette method using the aforementioned conversion formulas for soil texture classification.[Results]For the 33 samples from the black soil area,the clay content(<0.002 mm)measured by the pipette method was significantly higher than that measured by the laser diffraction method,but there was a significant correlation between the two methods(p<0.01).The sand content measured by the pipette method was higher than that measured using the Beckman particle size analyzer but lower than that measured using the Malvern particle size analyzer.However,corresponding conversion formulas could also be derived for each method(p<0.01).For the black soil samples from the small watershed evaluated using the two laser particle size analyzers,the difference in the clay content was relatively small,with an average absolute error of 2.5%.However,the absolute average errors in the silt and sand content were>10%.After conversion,the difference decreased,with an average absolute error of 1.8%for the clay content,3.9%and 6.3%for the silt content in the International System and the American System,respectively,and 5.1%and 7.4%for the sand content in the International System and the American System,respectively.After converting the data from the two laser particle size analyzers to align with those from the pipette method,the values could be consistently used for soil texture classification of the small watershed samples,with a consistency rate of 93.0%for the International System.However,for texture classification using the American System,the consistency rate was only 58.8%.[Conclusions]Therefore,there are significant differences in the raw values obtained with the two particle size analyzers,making the data unsuitable for direct comparison.However,there is a highly significant correlation between the two(p<0.01).The conversion formulas established using samples from black soil regions can considerably reduce the differences,providing a better basis for soil texture classification in the international system for black soil.
高晓飞;魏欣;刘瑛娜;龚吉蕊
北京师范大学 地理科学学部 地表过程与水土风沙灾害风险防控全国重点实验室,北京 100875北京师范大学 地理科学学部 地表过程与水土风沙灾害风险防控全国重点实验室,北京 100875北京师范大学 地理科学学部 地表过程与水土风沙灾害风险防控全国重点实验室,北京 100875北京师范大学 地理科学学部 地表过程与水土风沙灾害风险防控全国重点实验室,北京 100875
农业科技
黑土土壤颗粒土壤质地吸管法激光粒度仪法转换公式
black soilsoil particlesoil texturepipette methodlaser diffraction methodconversion formulas
《实验技术与管理》 2026 (10)
8-13,6
国家重点研发计划项目资助(2021YFD1500704)
评论