角色化多智能体支持议题式学习的模式构建与效果检验OA
Construction and Effect Test of a Role-Based Multi-Agent Supported Issue-Based Learning Model—A Quasi-Experimental Study Based on the Primary School"Morality and the Rule of Law"Curriculum
在价值多元时代,培养具有健全人格与责任意识的未来公民已成为教育的重要使命.议题式学习以具有两难性、冲突性和公共性的真实议题为载体,通过价值辨析与理性论证促进学科知识学习,引导学生在多元价值碰撞中形成正确价值判断,其学习过程具有"议题牵引—问题驱动—理性审议—社会参与"的特征.针对传统技术支持存在流程过度预设、论证反馈滞后以及多源技术协同不足等局限,本研究引入大模型驱动的多智能体技术,构建"议想天开"多智能体系统,设置议题溯源者、辩理建模师、视域挑战者和审议领航员四类角色的智能体,并据此设计多智能体支持的议题式学习模式,推动课堂迈向师生机多元协同的新样态.依托小学道德与法治课程开展准实验研究,研究发现,多智能体支持的核心价值在于提升人机互动质量,即通过角色分工与功能分化增强认知支持与学生认知需求的匹配,并借助多角色观点异质性形成认知张力,促使学生开展视角采纳、质疑反驳和审慎决策等高阶认知活动.在小组论证层面,多智能体通过优化主张、证据、推理与反驳之间的结构关系,促进论证对话质量提升.在学习表现层面,其促进作用主要体现在论证脚本、方案设计等高阶认知要求较高的任务中;在批判性思维倾向方面,其影响具有维度差异,主要表现为对反思性怀疑的促进.
In an era of value pluralism,cultivating future citizens with sound personality and a sense of responsibility has be-come an important mission of education.Issue-based learning adopts authentic dilemmatic,conflicting and public issues as carriers.It promotes disciplinary knowledge learning through value clarification and rational argumentation and guides students to form sound val-ue judgments amid clashes of diverse values.Its learning process is characterized by"issue orientation-problem driving-rational de-liberation-social participation".However,conventional technological support suffers from limitations such as over-prescribed proce-dures,delayed feedback on argumentation,and insufficient coordination of multiple technical resources.To address these limitations,this study introduces large language model-driven multi-agent technology,constructs the"Yixiang Tiankai"multi-agent system,and defines four types of agents:Issue Tracer,Argumentation Modeler,Perspective Challenger,and Deliberation Navigator.Drawing on this system,this study designs an issue-based learning model supported by multi-agents,advancing classrooms toward a new form of mul-ti-agent collaboration among teachers,students and machines.A quasi-experimental study was carried out within primary school Ethics and the Rule of Law courses.The findings reveal that the core value of multi-agent support lies in improving the quality of hu-man-AI interaction.Specifically,role differentiation and functional specialization improve the matching between cognitive support and students' cognitive needs.The heterogeneous perspectives of multiple agents generate productive cognitive tension and stimulate higher-order cognitive activities including perspective taking,critical rebuttal,and deliberative decision-making.At the group argu-mentation level,multi-agent support optimizes the structural relations among claims,evidence,reasoning and rebuttals and thereby improves the quality of argumentative dialogue.Regarding learning performance,its benefits are more salient in tasks requiring high cognitive demands such as argumentation scripting and solution design.Its effects on critical thinking dispositions differ across di-mensions,with the most prominent promotion observed in reflective skepticism.
王小雨;赵晓伟;余钰祺;吴宁;沈书生
南京师范大学教育科学学院(江苏南京210097)南京师范大学教育科学学院(江苏南京210097)||江苏省高校哲学社会科学实验室——南京师范大学青少年教育与智能实验室(江苏南京210097)南京师范大学教育科学学院(江苏南京210097)南京师范大学教育科学学院(江苏南京210097)南京师范大学教育科学学院(江苏南京210097)||江苏省高校哲学社会科学实验室——南京师范大学青少年教育与智能实验室(江苏南京210097)
社会科学
议题式学习多智能体教学智能体人机协同学习
Issue-based learningMulti-agent systemsPedagogical agentHuman-AI collaborative learning
《远程教育杂志》 2026 (5)
79-91,13
国家社会科学基金教育学2024年度青年项目"AIGC支持认识发生的数智苏格拉底对话式学习研究"(项目编号:CCA240256).
评论