三种细胞形态学性别鉴定方法的比较研究OA
Comparison of Three Cytomorphological Methods for Sex Identification
比较鼓槌体、巴氏小体及染色体核型3种细胞形态学结构检测在性别鉴定中的差异,为细胞形态学教学、临床应用和法医学研究提供参考.经知情同意,随机抽选正常健康男女各10名,分别采集外周血细胞及口腔黏膜细胞,通过改良3种与X染色质有关的形态特征结构的制片方法,观察并获取典型特征图谱,分析三者在性别鉴定中的差异.显微观察结果显示:鼓槌体、巴氏小体及染色体核型的典型特征图谱清晰可见.鼓槌体计数结果显示:正常女性的鼓槌体检出率为1.3%~2.0%,平均值为1.69%;正常男性的鼓槌体检出率为0.1%~0.7%,平均值为0.36%,两性检出差异显著(P<0.001).巴氏小体计数结果显示:正常女性的检出率为16.5%~24.5%,平均值为19.75%;正常男性的检出率为0~0.5%,两性检出差异显著(P<0.001).染色体核型分析显示:正常女性为46,XX;正常男性为46,XY,性别鉴定准确率100%.可见,鼓槌体、巴氏小体及染色体核型3种细胞形态学结构检测方法在性别鉴定中均具有可行性,但鼓槌体所需计数统计量大、经验依赖性强,且准确度有待提升;巴氏小体则在制片和判定等方面有取材方便、快速准确的优势,可为临床性别快速鉴定提供便利;染色体核型分析虽然能准确判断个体性别,但制片、识别和分析等耗时长,且技术难度高、程序复杂.
This study aims to compare the differences of three cytomorphological structure(drumsticks,Barr bodies,and chromosome karyotypes)detection in sex identification,so as to offer references for cytomorpho-logy teaching,clinical application,and forensic research.With informed consent,10 healthy males and 10 healthy females were randomly selected,respectively.Peripheral blood cells and buccal mucosal cells were collected.Three modified slide preparation methods for morphological features associated with X chromatin were adopted.Typical characteristic images were observed and obtained,and the differences among the three methods in sex determination were analyzed.Microscopic observation results showed that the typical charac-teristic images of drumsticks,Barr bodies,and chromosome karyotypes were clearly visible.Drumstick test showed that the drumstick detection rate was 1.3%~2.0%in healthy females(mean:1.69%)and 0.1%~0.7%in healthy males(mean:0.36%),with a significant intersexual difference(P<0.001).Barr body test showed that the Barr body detection rate was 16.5%~24.5%in healthy females(mean:19.75%)and 0~0.5%in healthy males,with a significant intersexual difference(P<0.001).Chromosome karyotype analysis revealed a karyotype of 46,XX in healthy females and 46,XY in healthy males,with a sex determination accuracy of 100%.It is evident that the three cytomorphological detection methods are feasible for sex identification.However,the drumstick test requires extensive cell counting,strongly depends on examiners' experience,and its accuracy needs to be improved.The Barr body test offers advantages such as convenient sampling,rapidity,and accu-racy in slide preparation and interpretation,facilitating rapid clinical sex determination.Chromosome karyo-type analysis can accurately determine an individual's sex,but it is time-consuming in slide preparation,cell identification and analysis,technically demanding,and procedurally complex.
谢文美;刘丽琼;魏晋萍;何勤;包丽娟;景时裕;吴亚萍;杨贝贝;吕逸斐
甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000甘肃医学院基础医学院生物学教研室,中国甘肃平凉 744000
生物科学
细胞形态学鼓槌体巴氏小体染色体核型性别鉴定
cell morphologydrumstickBarr bodychromosome karyotypesex identification
《生命科学研究》 2026 (4)
283-289,7
甘肃省高等学校创新基金项目(2023A-189)甘肃省高等教育教学改革研究项目(2025-GJJGB377)甘肃医学院教学质量提高工程建设项目(GYJG2024C0001,GYJG2025Y0001,GYJG2025S0013)
评论