"管理科学与实践脱节"问题与作为参照系的管理哲学OACHSSCD
The Problem of"the Gap Between Management Science and Practice"and Management Philosophy as a Frame of Reference
在独立观、弥合观、冲突观、严谨优先观之外,提出针对"管理科学与实践脱节问题"的"最优匹配观":即在管理学研究中,"科学严谨性与实践相关性"存在一个最优匹配,达到最优匹配之后,继续追求科学的普适严谨性,必然损害实践相关性.因为人性的复杂性以及人类对自身认识永恒的有限性,达到或接近这一最优匹配,即意味着"管理科学与实践脱节问题"的解决.为达到"最优匹配",须引入管理哲学作为管理科学研究的参照系.管理理念是管理哲学的主要研究对象,也是管理实践的"前提",既可以从成功的经验中凝练,更可以从超验的信仰、特定的文化背景或管理者个人的价值偏好中生发.管理哲学就是对不同时代、不同文化、不同环境、不同组织、不同个体中管理理念的形成、变迁及其与管理实践之间的关系进行研究的学科,管理哲学通过确立根本价值、构建认知体系、指引实践路径,成为管理科学研究不可或缺的参照系.管理哲学亦是有限的,在"新管理科学研究"中,管理哲学与管理科学相互参照,理论上可以指引学术研究接近于"严谨与相关"最优匹配点.
In addition to the views of independence,reconciliation,conflict,and rigor-priority,an"op-timal fit view"is proposed regarding the issue of the"disconnect between management science and practice":there exists an optimal fit between the rigor of management science and its practical rel-evance.Once this optimal fit is achieved,further pursuit of universal scientific rigor will inevitably im-pair practical relevance.Given the complexity of human nature and the perpetual limitations of human self-understanding,reaching or approaching this optimal fit signifies the resolution of the"disconnect between management science and practice."To attain such an"optimal fit,"management philosophy must be introduced as a frame of reference for management science research.Management ideas,as the primary subject of management philosophy,serve as the"premise"of management practice.They can be distilled from successful experiences or,more significantly,derived from transcendent beliefs,specific cultural contexts,or the individual value preferences of managers.Management philosophy is the discipline that studies the formation and evolution of management ideas across different eras,cul-tures,environments,organizations,and individuals,as well as their relationship with management practice.By establishing fundamental values,constructing cognitive frameworks,and guiding practi-cal pathways,management philosophy becomes an indispensable frame of reference for management science research.Management philosophy is itself bounded;within the realm of"new management sci-ence research,"management philosophy and management science engage in mutual referencing,theo-retically guiding academic inquiry toward the optimal fit point between rigor and relevance.
吕力
扬州大学 商学院,江苏 扬州 225009
管理科学
管理哲学管理科学参照系科学严谨性实践相关性新管理科学研究
management philosophymanagement scienceframe of referencescientific rigorpracti-cal relevancenew management science research
《上海管理科学》 2026 (5)
42-55,14
国家社会科学基金重大项目"中国传统管理哲学研究"(24&ZD221)
评论