论马克思和恩格斯自然观的协同关系OA
On Synergistic Relationship Between Marx's and Engels's Views of Nature:A Three-Dimensional Examination of Natural History,Metabolism,and Ecological Critique
斋藤幸平将马克思与恩格斯的自然观解释为根本性的对立.本文从自然史、物质变换与生态批判三个维度考察马克思和恩格斯自然观的关系.虽然马克思主要从政治经济学批判出发考察自然的历史性,恩格斯更多从自然科学理论本身考察自然的演变过程和客观物质基础,但二人在基本理论立场上不存在根本分歧.在自然史理解上,马克思和恩格斯共同坚持自然的社会历史性与非目的论立场.在物质变换概念阐释上,马克思和恩格斯均从自然科学经验内容出发进入社会历史分析,反对把人类劳动还原为纯粹自然属性.在生态批判及其解决方案上,马克思和恩格斯都突出社会生产方式与调节机制变革的重要性.马克思和恩格斯自然观的关系是协同的,体现了历史唯物主义理论关于自然物质客观性与社会历史规定性的统一,为重新认识当代生态危机的成因及其解决路径提供了重要启示.
Kohei Saito interprets Marx's and Engels's views of nature as fundamentally opposed to each other.This article examines the relationship between Marx's and Engels's views of nature from three dimensions:natural history,metabolism,and ecological critique.Although Marx primarily examined the historical character of nature through his critique of political economy,while Engels focused more on the evolutionary process of nature and its objective material foundations from the perspective of the natural sciences themselves,the two thinkers did not differ fundamentally in their basic theoretical positions.With regard to their understanding of natural history,Marx and Engels jointly upheld the social-historical character of nature and a non-teleological position.In their interpretations of the concept of metabolism,both proceeded from the empirical findings of the natural sciences to an analysis of social history,while rejecting any reduction of human labor to a purely natural attribute.With regard to ecological critique and possible solutions,both Marx and Engels emphasized the importance of transforming the mode of social production and its mechanisms of regulation.The relationship between Marx's and Engels's views of nature is one of theoretical synergy,reflecting historical materialism's unity of the objective materiality of nature and its social-historical determination.This perspective offers important insights into rethinking the causes of contemporary ecological crises and the pathways toward their resolution.
刘诗昭
复旦大学哲学学院
自然观自然史物质变换生态批判自然报复论
view of naturenatural historymetabolismecological critiquethe theory of nature's revenge
《南京林业大学学报(人文社会科学版)》 2026 (4)
26-38,13
国家社会科学基金重大项目"马克思哲学方法论与现代人文社会科学方法论变革"(24&ZD322).
评论