"杂草"重塑的景观:城市自生植物研究综述与前沿展望OACHSSCD
Landscapes Remolded from"Weeds":A Systematic Review and Forward Look on Urban Spontaneous Plants
[目的]城市自生植物在生物多样性支撑与低维护景观营建中具有重要价值.笔者立足于自生植物历史脉络,系统梳理全球研究进展,理清自生植物景观营建框架与关键科学问题,分析研究局限、展望未来方向.[方法]采用文献计量(2002-2025年,主题为自生植物/自生植被;1 062篇)与重点精读(178篇)相结合的方法,进行系统分析与综合阐述.[结果]1)从"清除杂草"到"应用自生植物",标志着种植设计从以栽培植物为核心的设计搭配(1.0~3.0范式),拓展至全域多尺度自然与人工协同的景观配置(4.0范式).2)全球研究快速增长,聚焦五大议题:多样性与分布格局(70.2%)、生态功能(15.7%)、公众感知(5.1%)、群落改良(3.4%)与维护管理(1.7%).3)各议题独立性强、景观应用路径不明,故笔者构建了研究议题与"种植设计 4.0"各环节衔接的框架;当自然真正"参与"设计后,景观营建中的前期踏查与科学评估更关键.4)自生植物物种丰富,但存在优势种过度扩张、偶见种受城市化胁迫的问题;自生植物多样性研究聚焦并证实了绿地格局与生境条件影响机制;自生植物的功能已得到初步证实,维护从一律清除转向差异化管理,但公众欣赏度有待提升.[结论]当前仍以多样性调查研究为主,且存在尺度混乱、时空覆盖不足等局限.未来需重视应用导向的设计型验证研究,加强物种资源评估、群落构建机制、设计方法与维护管理措施等科学问题的探索.
[Objective]Urban spontaneous plants colonizing green spaces without intentional human cultivation have long been dismissed as"weeds".Yet,over the past two decades,a growing body of evidence has revealed their substantial ecological value,including supporting urban biodiversity,providing ecosystem services,and enabling low-maintenance landscape construction.As urban greening in China transitions from quantity-driven expansion to quality-oriented improvement,spontaneous plants offer a promising alternative to conventional high-input,high-maintenance planting design.Despite the rapid increase in research attention,several critical bottlenecks persist:conceptual confusion surrounding the definition and boundaries of spontaneous plants,fragmented and inconsistent scale systems that hinder cross-study comparison,and a pronounced disconnection between ecological research and landscape design practice.Against this backdrop,this study traces the historical trajectory of spontaneous plant research and systematically reviews global progress,aiming to clarify the framework for spontaneous plant landscape design,identify key scientific questions,analyze research limitations,and propose future directions. [Methods]This study employs a combination of bibliometric analysis and systematic literature review.The bibliometric analysis included 1,062 publications,covered 163 Chinese papers retrieved from the China National Knowledge Infrastructure database and 899 English papers from the Web of Science Core Collection,supplemented with an additional 289 papers specifically on urban contexts.The analysis was conducted using the bibliometrix package in R(version 4.3.3).For in-depth review,178 high-quality papers(119 in English,59 in Chinese)were selected based on thematic relevance,academic impact,citation frequency,and geographical coverage,with publication dates up to May 2026,including review articles. [Results]The paper clarifies the evolutionary trajectory of planting design paradigms from 1.0 to 4.0,showing a progressive transition from purely ornamental,cultivated-plant-dominated approaches toward designs integrate spontaneous plants as the primary landscape material.While Paradigms 1.0-3.0 all rely on cultivated plants as the principal design material,Paradigm 4.0 is fundamentally different in that it directly incorporates on-site spontaneous communities into the design process,with nature assuming the roles of"designer"and"engineer",while human designers act as evaluators and optimizers.The paper distinguishes spontaneous plants from related concepts,and defines spontaneous plants as those that complete their life cycles without human sowing or planting,relying on natural dispersal or soil seed banks,and capable of self-sustaining populations.This conceptual clarification resolves longstanding terminological confusion and provides a foundation for cross-study comparability.The review reveals that global research has grown rapidly,and heavily concentrated in diversity surveys(70.2%),while ecological functions of spontaneous plants account for 15.7%,public perception 5.1%,community improvement 3.4%,and maintenance management only 1.7%.By synthesizing the five research themes and practical case studies,this study constructs the framework of Planting Design 4.0.Existing approaches to spontaneous plant landscape construction can be categorized into seven types:1)low-maintenance landscapes in conventional green spaces;2)natural wilderness parks dominated by spontaneous plant landscapes;3)post-industrial and cultural heritage landscapes;4)small-scale urban gardens and courtyards;5)informal green spaces and their"landscape development";6)spontaneous plant landscapes in hard-surface habitats(walls,paving gaps,roofs);and 7)cultural and artistic exhibition landscapes.The five major research themes correspond to multiple landscape construction components,each underpinned by distinct theoretical foundations.Findings from previous studies indicate that species composition is characterized by native species dominance,with Asteraceae and Poaceae being the most prevalent families,and a distinct pattern of"dominant species concentrated,rare species abundant",where a few species dominate while numerous low-frequency,locally rare species rely on specific habitats for their persistence.However,diversity research has significant methodological limitations,including inconsistent scale definitions across studies,predominant reliance on α-diversity indices,insufficient spatiotemporal sampling,and weak mechanistic explanations that remain largely correlational.Preliminary evidence confirms that spontaneous plants deliver measurable regulating services,including superior performance in urban heat mitigation,carbon sequestration,soil and water conservation,and phytoremediation of degraded or contaminated soils.Economically,communities incorporating spontaneous vegetation have shown reductions in establishment and maintenance costs.However,public acceptance remains a barrier:although professionals show higher appreciation,public acceptation is generally low.Preference is influenced by vegetation structure,flowering characteristics,and perceived safety,with mid-successional communities being more readily accepted.Maintenance studies remain critically scarce,though existing evidence suggests that reduced mowing frequency and selective removal rather than uniform elimination can enhance biodiversity while reducing costs. [Conclusion]This study constructs a comprehensive"Planting Design 4.0"framework.The framework addresses the critical disconnection between ecological research and landscape application by providing a structured approach for translating ecological principles into design strategies and maintenance measures.Current research primarily focuses on diversity surveys.Future research should prioritize application-oriented design studies and intensify exploration of key scientific questions.The review identifies several priority directions for future research:establishing a unified conceptual and terminological system to enable cross-study comparison,constructing species resource databases and evaluation frameworks tailored to landscape design applications,elucidating community assembly mechanisms that link environmental filtering,interspecific interactions,and functional traits,conducting long-term,multi-scale monitoring to understand community dynamics and stability,quantifying ecological benefits and safety risks,developing evidence-based maintenance guidelines with operational parameters(frequency,intensity,timing,etc.),and integrating public perception studies into design strategies.
李晓鹏;常满;李乐心;李仓拴
西南交通大学建筑学院西南交通大学建筑学院西南交通大学建筑学院西北农林科技大学风景园林艺术学院
建筑与水利
群落生态学生物多样性种植设计自生植物公众感知维护管理计量分析
community ecologybiodiversityplanting designspontaneous plantspublic perceptionmaintenance managementbibliometric analysis
《风景园林》 2026 (10)
73-84,12
国家自然科学基金"成都城区自生植物的分布格局及其对绿地异质性的响应"(编号52108065)国家自然科学基金"园林草本植物群落CSR功能群构成与稳定性关系研究"(编号32401654)成都市风景园林规划设计院公园城市项目(编号R114620H01038)
评论