首页|期刊导航|风景园林|英国非营利组织参与国家公园治理的功能角色与协同行动体系——以湖区国家公园为例

英国非营利组织参与国家公园治理的功能角色与协同行动体系——以湖区国家公园为例OACHSSCD

Functional Roles and Collaborative Action System of British Non-profit Organizations in National Park Governance:A Case Study of the Lake District National Park

中文摘要英文摘要

[目的]非营利组织是促进国家公园全民参与的重要主体,以参与英国湖区国家公园治理的非营利组织为样本,识别非营利组织参与国家公园治理的功能角色与行动体系.[方法]筛选样本并构建输入变量,将探索性因子分析与K-means聚类相结合,识别非营利组织的功能构成与类型差异.[结果]1)湖区国家公园非营利组织的行动可归纳为政策倡导与生态治理、文娱宣教与设施运营、社会福祉建设、资源筹集与应急支持、资助赋能 5个潜在功能维度,并以维度特征聚类得到社区服务型、生态倡导型、全能枢纽型和末端专精型4类角色.2)不同类型组织在协同治理中承担差异化职责,构成了较为稳定的协同行动体系.湖区国家公园伙伴关系构成了协同的平台基础,全能枢纽型组织则在跨尺度资源沟通与议题协调中发挥重要桥接作用.[结论]非营利组织在参与湖区国家公园协同治理中形成了以角色分化为基础、以平台协同和桥接组织为支撑的协同行动体系,其角色分化是英国国家公园在自然保护、公众享用和社区发展的多重目标下维持协同治理体系的必要条件.要强化中国国家公园治理的公众参与环节,应搭建管理机构主导的多元协同平台承担枢纽协调功能,注重多方利益相关者的可持续参与和分工互补,引入成熟社会组织的同时培育在地行动单元并完善联合监管机制.风景园林专业在其中可发挥空间转译与治理协同的中介作用,推动自身由项目设计服务向长期运营合作拓展.

[Objective]Non-profit organizations(NPOs)are important actors in public participation and collaborative governance of national parks.Existing studies often focus on individual organizations or projects and tend to treat NPOs as a homogeneous group,providing limited explanation of their internal functional differences and collaborative relationships.Taking the Lake District National Park in the United Kingdom as a case,this study identifies the functional dimensions and role types of NPOs,examines how differentiated organizations participate in different stages of collaborative governance,and clarifies the collaborative action system formed through their complementary roles. [Methods]NPO samples were first identified from the official website of the Lake District National Park and supplemented by searches of the UK Charity Commission using the keywords"Lake District,""the lakes,"and"Lakeland."Organizations were included when they were formally registered with the Charity Commission,had verifiable activity records within the Lake District National Park,and had recent financial information indicating active operation.A final sample of 51 NPOs was obtained.Based on official organizational websites,Charity Commission records,relevant news reports,and previous studies on nonprofit participation in public services,collaborative governance,and national park management,18 activity categories were developed as input variables.Each organization was binary coded according to whether its publicly available records explicitly demonstrated the corresponding activity within the Lake District.Exploratory factor analysis was conducted in SPSS 26.0 using principal axis factoring.The KMO value was 0.626 and Bartlett's test of sphericity was significant.Considering the binary nature of the variables,an additional factor analysis based on a tetrachoric correlation matrix was performed in Stata 18.0 to test robustness.Factor scores were then used as inputs for clustering.Ward's hierarchical clustering and the natural grouping pattern of the samples were used to determine K=4,followed by K-means clustering to identify role types. [Results]Five latent functional dimensions were identified:F1,policy advocacy and ecological governance;F2,cultural and recreational education and facility operation;F3,social welfare development;F4,resource mobilization and emergency support;and F5,grant-making and capacity empowerment.F5 was relatively independent,suggesting that grant-making and empowerment can either combine with other functions or operate as a specialized function.Based on factor-score combinations,the 51 organizations were grouped into four role types:the community service type(n=19),ecological advocacy type(n=6),all-round hub type(n=3),and specialized terminal support type(n=23).Community service organizations were characterized by strong social-welfare and public-service functions but weak direct involvement in macro-level policy processes.Ecological advocacy organizations concentrated on ecological monitoring,scientific research,restoration,environmental education,and policy advocacy.The three all-round hub organizations—Friends of the Lake District,National Trust,and Action with Communities in Cumbria—showed positive scores across all five functional dimensions and were all members of the Lake District National Park Partnership.Their broad resource bases,institutional embeddedness,and cross-scale connections enable them to integrate issues,translate resources,and coordinate among organizations and stakeholder groups.Specialized terminal support organizations were mostly small and place-based,focusing on cultural and heritage services,emergency rescue,fundraising,grant-making,or other specific tasks,and generally played implementation and professional-support roles.The four types also differed across the governance cycle.Partnership members could directly participate in plan formulation,while other organizations entered indirectly through consultation,evidence submission,community representation,or issue-specific communication.During implementation,specialized terminal support organizations ensured professional delivery,ecological advocacy and community service organizations respectively addressed conservation and community needs,and all-round hub organizations acted as both implementers and bridges.The Love Windermere partnership illustrates such complementarity,with different organizations contributing environmental monitoring,specialized pollution-control actions,land management,and cross-sector coordination.During monitoring and feedback,organizations supplied differentiated evidence,monitoring data,project experience,and public comments that fed into subsequent planning cycles.The Lake District National Park Partnership thus provides an institutional platform for sustained communication,while all-round hub organizations connect national-level resources and agendas with local communities,projects,and conservation needs.Together,role differentiation,platform-based collaboration,and bridging organizations form a relatively stable collaborative action system. [Conclusion]NPOs participating in the Lake District National Park are characterized by clear functional and role differentiation rather than homogeneous participation.Different organizations occupy different positions in the governance process according to their resources,professional capacities,service objectives,and degree of institutional embeddedness,and their complementary roles support the operation of collaborative governance under the multiple objectives of nature conservation,public enjoyment,and community development.For China,improving public participation in national parks requires management-authority-led collaborative platforms,clearer division of responsibilities among diverse actors,the introduction of mature social organizations together with the cultivation of place-based action units,and improved mechanisms for participation and joint supervision.Landscape architecture can serve as a technical intermediary by translating ecological protection objectives,community needs,and recreational demands into spatial strategies,action programs,and evaluation indicators,thereby extending professional practice from project-based design toward long-term governance and operational collaboration.

周健榕;李倞;王应临;钱丽源

北京林业大学园林学院北京林业大学园林学院、国家公园学院、生态与自然保护学院北京林业大学园林学院||北京林业大学园林学院城乡生态环境北京实验室西南交通大学建筑学院

建筑与水利

国家公园协同治理非营利组织因子-聚类分析角色分化公众参与

national parkscollaborative governancenonprofit organizationsfactor-cluster analysisrole differentiationpublic participation

《风景园林》 2026 (10)

45-55,11

国家林业和草原局国家公园(自然保护地)发展中心咨询课题"国家公园入口社区共生发展的综合评估体系研究"(编号2026-HXZX-022)国家林业和草原局国家公园(自然保护地)发展中心业务委托科普服务项目(编号2026-HXFW-033)中央高校基本科研业务费专项(编号PTPY202605)自然资源保护协会(NRDC)国家公园能力建设国际合作联合实验室科研课题(编号2025-HXZX-038)

10.3724/j.fjyl.LA20260197

评论