雇佣关系与承揽关系的司法区分标准及责任承担分析OA
An Analysis of Judicial Distinction Criteria and Liability Bearing for Employment Relationships and Contract-for-Work Relationships
准确区分雇佣关系(即个人之间的劳务关系)与承揽关系,不仅关系到个案中当事人的切身权益,也关系到民事权利义务体系的科学构建与司法裁判的统一.实践中,法院通常不会仅依据当事人陈述或协议名称进行判断,而是结合从属性程度、工具提供、报酬支付、工作性质等多重因素进行实质性审查.本文以李某与刘某纠纷案为切入点,系统剖析雇佣关系与承揽关系的学理差异与司法认定标准,并对相关责任划分规则进行阐释,以期为类案处理提供清晰的法律理论框架.
The precise distinction between an employment relationship(i.e.,a labor service relationship between individuals)and an independent contractor relationship is of paramount importance.It not only affects the substantive rights and interests of the litigants in individual cases but also carries significant implications for the coherent structuring of the civil legal system and the uniformity of judicial adjudication.In practice,courts generally do not base their determinations exclusively on the parties'own characterizations or the formal labels assigned to their agreements.Instead,they conduct a fact-intensive substantive review that comprehensively takes into account multiple factors,including the degree of subordination,the provision of working tools,the structure of remuneration,and the nature of the work performed.Taking the dispute between Li and Liu as an analytical entry point,this paper systematically examines the doctrinal divergences and judicial criteria for differentiating these two types of relationships.It further elucidates the applicable rules for liability allocation,with a view to establishing a well-defined legal theoretical framework to guide the adjudication of analogous cases.
张怡萍;冯澍
太原市中级人民法院 案件质效监督管理办公室,太原 030000国家开发银行山西省分行 客户五处,太原 030006
社会科学
雇佣关系承揽关系司法区分
employment relationshipindependent contractor relationshipjudicial distinction
《苏州工学院学报》 2026 (5)
75-81,91,8
评论