涉渔"三无"船舶特定违法行为的强制移送义务研究OA
A study on the compulsory transfer obligation for specific illegal acts of"three-none"fishing vessels
新修订的《渔业法》首次在法律层面设置专门条款规制涉渔"三无"船舶,标志着我国涉渔船舶治理工作正式迈入全链条、法治化规制新阶段.然而,立法层面的从严规制能否转化为实务治理实效,关键取决于能否依托强制移送义务实现行政惩戒与刑事追责的顺畅衔接.本文通过回溯我国涉渔"三无"船舶治理规则的制度演进,指出当前涉渔"三无"船舶行刑衔接面临三重结构性困境:一是非法捕捞水产品罪的入罪标准难以涵摄船舶非法状态这一核心违法属性;二是行政证据向刑事证据转化、程序衔接存在阻滞;三是行政处置与刑事追诉存在权限冲突.基于此,提出以下建议:一是完善立法供给,在新修订《渔业法》配套实施细则中明确移送标准与法定情形;二是健全执法机制,建立常态化行刑衔接制度;三是规范程序运行,细化移送流程与证据转化规则;四是强化监督制约,完善责任追究与考核激励机制;五是完善配套保障,统一认定标准与协同处置机制.本文旨在通过强化程序层面的强制移送义务,在不突破刑事实体法框架的前提下弥合行刑规制断层,为我国涉渔"三无"船舶的法治化治理提供可行路径.
The newly revised Fisheries Law has established specific provisions at the statutory level to regulate fishing-related"three-none"vessels,marking the formal entry of relevant governance work into a new stage of law-based regulation characterized by"whole-chain governance,zero tolerance,and heavy penalties".Nevertheless,whether the stringent legislative regulation can be translated into actual deterrent effect in law enforcement depends critically on whether the compulsory transfer obligation can facilitate the smooth linkage between administrative punishment and criminal prosecution.This article,by tracing back the institutional evolution of governance rules for"three-none"vessels involved in fishing,proposes that the current connection between administrative punishment and criminal prosecution in dealing with such vessels faces three major dilemmas as bellows.First,the threshold for prosecution under the crime of illegal fishing of aquatic products fails to adequately encompass the core illegal attribute of the vessel's unl awful status.Second,there are obstacles in the conversion of administrative evidence into criminal evidence.Third,conflicts of authority exist between administrative disposition and criminal prosecution.Based on th ese findings,this paper proposes the following recommendations.First,improve legislative supply by clarifying transfer standards and statutory circumstances in supporting implementation rules.Second,enhance enforcement mechanisms by establishing a normalized administrative-criminal interface system.Third,standardize procedural operations by refining transfer procedures and evidence conversion rules.Fourth,strengthen supervisory constraints by improving accountability mechanisms and incentive-assessment structures.Fifth,improve supporting safeguards by unifying identification standards and collaborative disposition mechanisms.
朱兴华;裴兆斌
大连海洋大学 海洋法律与人文学院,辽宁 大连 116000大连海洋大学 海洋法律与人文学院,辽宁 大连 116000
管理科学
渔业法涉渔"三无"船舶非法捕捞强制移送义务行刑衔接
Fisheries Lawfishing-related"three-none"vesselsillegal fishingcompulsory transfer obligationadministrative-criminal interface
《中国渔业经济》 2026 (10)
30-41,12
本文为辽宁省属本科高校基本科研业务费项目(2024JBPTR001)和中国学位与研究生教育学会农林学科工作委员会2024年研究课题(2024-NLZX-YB140)的阶段性成果.
评论