从即时掌握到长期保持:结构化同伴评价在心肺复苏技能强化训练中的实证研究OA
From immediate mastery to long-term retention:an empirical study on structured peer assessment in cardiopulmonary resuscitation skill training
目的 探讨在心肺复苏(CPR)技能强化训练中引入结构化同伴评价对医学生技能掌握度及长期保持效果的影响,并分析其潜在的认知机制.方法 选取武汉大学第二临床学院2018级临床医学专业本科生为研究对象,随机分为常规组(按照"示范-模仿-单向考核"模式开展教学)和干预组(在练习环节嵌入结构化同伴评价).采用理论测试评估认知技能,标准化操作考核评估操作技能,分别于课程前、课程后(即时)及课后3个月(延时)3个时间点进行测评,比较2组学生的理论成绩、即时/延时操作成绩的变化幅度及技能保持差异.结果 共纳入168名研究对象,干预组和常规组各84例.2组学生CPR理论成绩的提升幅度差异无统计学意义(P=0.664);但课程结束后3个月的延时操作技能考核,干预组与常规组成绩中位变化幅度分别为1.00(0.00,1.00)和-2.00(-5.00,-0.25),差异有统计学意义(P<0.001),表明干预组的技能长期保持效果优于常规组.结论 在CPR技能强化训练中引入结构化同伴评价,未显著改变短期理论习得效果,但能有效抑制操作技能遗忘,促进操作技能的长期保持与深度内化.结构化同伴评价的核心机制在于通过角色转换,激发学生深度思考与元认知监控.该模式为优化临床技能教学模式、解决操作技能随时间衰退的难题提供了实证支持和路径.
Objective To investigate the effects of incorporating structured peer assessment into cardiopulmonary resuscitation(CPR)skill enhancement training on medical students'proficiency and long-term retention,and to explore the underlying cognitive mechanisms.Methods Undergraduate students majoring in clinical medicine,Class of 2018,from the Second Clinical College of Wuhan University were enrolled and randomly divided into a control group(receiving teaching"demonstration-imitation-unidirectional assessment"instruction)and an intervention group(receiving structured peer assessment during practice sessions).Cognitive skills were evaluated using theoretical tests,and operational skills were assessed using standardized performance examinations.Measurements were conducted at three time points:baseline,immediately post-course,and 3 months post-course.The 2 groups were compared regarding magnitude of change in theoretical scores,immediate and delayed operational scores,and skill retention.Results A total of 168 participants were enrolled,with 84 in each group.No statistically significant difference was observed between the 2 groups in CPR theoretical score improvement(P=0.664).However,at the 3 months delayed operational skills assessment,the median changes from baseline in the intervention and control groups were 1.00(0.00,1.00)and-2.00(-5.00,-0.25),respectively,showing a statistically significant difference(P<0.001),indicating that the intervention group demonstrated superior long-term skill retention.Conclusion Integrating structured peer assessment into CPR skill enhancement training did not significantly affect short-term theoretical acquisition,but effectively mitigated skill decay and facilitated long-term retention and deep internalization of operational skills.The core mechanism of this approach lies in role reversal,which stimulates students'deep thinking and activates metacognitive monitoring.This model provides empirical evidence and a practical pathway for optimizing clinical skills teaching and addressing the challenge of skill attrition over time.
陈玲;卢爱佳;王贝贝;徐敏
武汉大学中南医院老年医学科(武汉 430071)武汉大学中南医院老年医学科(武汉 430071)武汉大学中南医院老年医学科(武汉 430071)武汉大学中南医院老年医学科(武汉 430071)
社会科学
同伴评价心肺复苏技能教学医学教育技能保持
Peer assessmentCardiopulmonary resuscitationSkill teachingMedical educationSkill retention
《医学新知》 2026 (9)
1068-1073,6
武汉大学本科教育质量建设综合改革项目(2025YB31)湖北省高等教育学会教育科研项目(2024XC075)
评论