含黑顺片中药饮片处方的回顾性再评价及用药风险分析OA
Retrospective Re-Evaluation and Medication Risk Analysis of Traditional Chinese Medicine Decoction Prescriptions Containing Heishunpian
目的 以 2025 年版《中国药典》为参照标准,对含黑顺片中药饮片处方进行回顾性再评价,分析需关注的用药风险.方法 回顾性抽取 2024 年 1 月至 2025 年 8 月河南省直第三人民医院门诊含黑顺片中药饮片处方,经筛选后纳入 2 969 张.因上述处方均开具于 2025 年版《中国药典》正式施行前,本研究以该版药典作为统一参照进行回顾性技术评价,结合相关规范及院内审方规则,对黑顺片剂量、特殊煎煮标注、十八反相关潜在不宜同用及方证一致性进行评价,并收集不良反应相关随访资料.结果 2 969张处方中,女性占50.35%,61~70岁患者处方占比最高(20.31%).黑顺片用量为 3~60 g,以 2025 年版《中国药典》推荐剂量上限 15 g 为量化参照,超过该上限(以下简称超过药典推荐剂量上限)者 998 张(33.61%).共检出需关注处方 1 304 张,需关注率为 43.92%;累计发现需关注问题 1 357 例次,其中超过药典推荐剂量上限、特殊煎煮标注不规范及十八反相关潜在不宜同用分别占 73.54%、20.41%和 6.04%.潜在不宜同用处方 82 张,占总处方的 2.76%,其中涉及半夏类饮片 52 张、天花粉 22 张.排除 191 张暂无法评价处方后,2 778 张纳入方证一致性评价,其中方证一致 2 778 张,方证一致率为 100.00%.在完成随访及可获得的不良反应监测资料范围内,未确认因果关系达到"可能有关"及以上级别的黑顺片相关不良反应.结论 以 2025 年版《中国药典》为参照进行回顾性再评价显示,含黑顺片处方需重点关注超过药典推荐剂量上限、特殊煎煮标注不规范及十八反相关潜在不宜同用等问题.鉴于纳入处方均开具于 2025 年版《中国药典》正式施行前,上述结果属于基于新标准的回顾性技术评价,不等同于对原处方临床合理性的否定性认定.系统预警、双签审核、规范特殊煎煮标注、重点配伍审核及药师持续参与可作为后续风险管理的重点措施.
Objective To retrospectively re-evaluate traditional Chinese medicine decoction prescriptions containing Heishunpian with reference to the 2025 edition of the Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China and to analyze medication-related risks requiring attention.Methods Outpatient traditional Chinese medicine decoction prescriptions containing Heishunpian issued at The Third People's Hospital of Henan Province from January 2024 to August 2025 were retrospectively collected,and 2,969 prescriptions were included after screening.Because all prescriptions had been issued before the official implementation of the 2025 edition of the Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China,this edition was used as a unified reference standard for retrospective technical evaluation.In conjunction with relevant regulations and institutional prescription-review rules,the dose of Heishunpian,labeling of special decoction requirements,potentially inappropriate combinations related to the traditional"Eighteen Incompatibilities"and prescription–syndrome consistency were evaluated.Follow-up data related to adverse reactions were also collected.Results Among the 2,969 prescriptions,50.35%were for female patients,and prescriptions for patients aged 61–70 years accounted for the largest proportion(20.31%).The prescribed dose of Heishunpian ranged from 3 to 60 g.Using the upper recommended dose of 15 g specified in the 2025 edition of the Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China as the quantitative reference,998 prescriptions(33.61%)exceeded this upper limit.A total of 1,304 prescriptions required attention,corresponding to a rate of 43.92%,and 1,357 issues requiring attention were identified.Of these,doses exceeding the upper limit recommended by the Pharmacopoeia,nonstandard labeling of special decoction requirements,and potentially inappropriate combinations related to the Eighteen Incompatibilities accounted for 73.54%,20.41%,and 6.04%,respectively.Potentially inappropriate combinations were identified in 82 prescriptions,accounting for 2.76%of all prescriptions;52 involved Pinellia-containing materia medica and 22 involved Trichosanthis Radix.After excluding 191 prescriptions that could not be evaluated,2,778 prescriptions were included in the prescription–syndrome consistency assessment,and all 2,778 were judged to be consistent,yielding a consistency rate of 100.00%.Within the available follow-up and adverse reaction monitoring data,no Heishunpian-related adverse reactions with a causality assessment of"possibly related"or higher were confirmed.Conclusion Retrospective re-evaluation using the 2025 edition of the Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China as the reference standard showed that prescriptions containing Heishunpian require particular attention with regard to doses exceeding the recommended upper limit,nonstandard labeling of special decoction requirements,and potentially inappropriate combinations related to the Eighteen Incompatibilities.Because all included prescriptions were issued before the official implementation of the 2025 edition of the Pharmacopoeia,these findings represent a retrospective technical assessment based on a newer standard and should not be interpreted as a definitive judgment that the original prescriptions were clinically inappropriate.System-based alerts,dual-signature review,standardized labeling of special decoction requirements,focused review of potentially incompatible combinations,and continuous pharmacist involvement may serve as key measures for subsequent risk management.
李蒙蒙;闫红敏
河南省直第三人民医院 药学部,河南 郑州 450000河南省直第三人民医院 药学部,河南 郑州 450000
黑顺片处方再评价用药安全风险控制中药饮片
Heishunpianprescription re-evaluationmedication safetyrisk controltraditional Chinese medicine decoction pieces
《临床研究》 2026 (10)
109-113,5
河南省第三批中医药青苗人才项目{豫卫中医药科教[2024]4号}.
评论