酶学清创后不同敷料对深二度烧伤创面远期瘢痕质量的影响OA
Effects of different dressings on long-term scar quality of deep second-degree burn wounds after enzymatic debridement
目的 系统比较酶学清创后四种不同类型敷料对深二度烧伤创面远期瘢痕质量的影响.方法 回顾性纳入2019-01 至2024-12 于空军特色医学中心烧伤科住院的深二度烧伤患者125 例,根据酶学清创后敷料类型分为四组:Suprathel组(A 组 32 例)、Mepilex Ag 组(B 组28 例)、Mepitel 组(C 组35 例)和Jelonet 组(D 组30 例).主要结局指标为12 个月时瘢痕弹性 R2,次要指标包括经皮水分丢失(TEWL)、黑色素指数、瘢痕厚度、创面愈合时间、疼痛评分、温哥华瘢痕量表(VSS)、患者与观察者瘢痕评估量表(POSAS)及 SF-36 生活质量评分.结果 12 个月时,A 组瘢痕弹性 R2 为(0.79±0.09),优于 D 组的(0.69±0.11),差异有统计学意义(P=0.009).A 组 TEWL[(10.8±2.8)g/(m2·h)]、黑色素指数(165.2±24.5)及瘢痕厚度[(1.35±0.28)mm]均低于 D 组的(14.2±3.5)g/(m2·h)、(185.6±29.1)、(1.72±0.36)mm,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).创面愈合时间[(13.2±3.1)d]、敷料更换次数[(2.5±1.0)次]及疼痛评分[(3.0±1.0)分],均优于 D 组的(15.8±3.9)d、(11.5±2.6)次、(4.8±1.5)分,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).12 个月时,A 组 VSS 总分为 2.0(1.0,4.0)分,POSAS 患者总分为 12.0(9.0,15.0)分,SF-36 躯体健康总评为(78.5±8.2)分,均优于 D 组的 4.0(3.0,6.0)分、18.0(14.0,21.0)分、(71.5±9.6)分,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).B、C 组优于 D 组,但差异无统计学意义.结论 酶学清创后深二度烧伤创面应用合成膜类敷料 Suprathel,在改善远期瘢痕质量方面可能优于其他类型敷料.
Objective To systematically compare the effects of four types of dressings on long-term scar quality of deep sec-ond-degree burn wounds after enzymatic debridement.Methods A total of 125 patients with deep second-degree burns who were hos-pitalized in the Burn Department of Characteristics Medical Center of PLA Air Force from January 2019 to December 2024 were retro-spectively included and divided into four groups according to the dressing type used after enzymatic debridement:Suprathel group(group A,32 cases),MepilexAg group(group B,28 cases),Mepitel group(group C,35 cases),and Jelonet group(group D,30 cases).The primary outcome measure was scar elasticity(R2)at 12 months,and secondary indicators included transepidermal wa-ter loss(TEWL),melanin index,scar thickness,wound healing time,pain score,Vancouver Scar Scale(VSS),Patient and Observ-er Scar Assessment Scale(POSAS),and SF-36 quality of life score.Results At 12 months,the scar elasticity R2 in group A(0.79±0.09)was significantly superior to that in group D(0.69±0.11),and the difference was statistically significant(P=0.009).The TEWL[(10.8±2.8)g/(m2·h)],melanin index(165.2±24.5)and scar thickness(1.35±0.28)mm in group A were lower than those in group D(14.2±3.5)g/(m2·h),(185.6±29.1),(1.72±0.36)mm,and the differences were statistically significant(P<0.05).The wound healing time[(13.2±3.1)d],number of dressing changes[(2.5±1.0)times]and pain score[(3.0±1.0)points]were also superior to those in group D(15.8±3.9 days,11.5±2.6 times,4.8±1.5 points),and the differences were statisti-cally significant(P<0.05).At 12 months,group A showed significantly better VSS total score 2.0(1.0,4.0),POSAS patient total score 12.0(9.0,15.0)and SF-36 PCS(78.5±8.2)com-pared with the group D 4.0(3.0,6.0),18.0(14.0,21.0),(71.5±9.6),and the differences were statistically significant(P<0.05).Groups B and C were better than Group D,but the differences were not statistically significant.Conclusions After enzymatic debridement,the application of synthetic membrane dressings Suprathel in deep second-degree burn wounds may be superior to other types of dressings in improving long-term scar quality.
张筱伟;曹卫华;邹晓防;张政;张文娟;李斌;于东平;李佳珂;张全喜;白海良;杨舒絮
100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,解放军总医院第四医学中心干部诊疗科100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,空军特色医学中心烧伤整形科100048 北京,解放军总医院第四医学中心干部诊疗科100048 北京,解放军总医院第四医学中心干部诊疗科100048 北京,解放军总医院第四医学中心干部诊疗科
医药卫生
酶学清创深二度烧伤敷料瘢痕质量Suprathel
enzymatic debridementdeep second-degree burndressingsscar qualitySuprathel
《武警医学》 2026 (9)
778-784,7
评论