上海市售水产品中砷、镉、铅、汞的污染状况及膳食暴露风险评估OA
Contamination status and dietary exposure risk assessment of arsenic,cadmium,lead and mercury in commercially available aquatic products in Shanghai
[目的]调查上海市售水产品中砷(As)、镉(Cd)、铅(Pb)和汞(Hg)的污染状况及其在不同类别水产品中的分布特征,评估不同年龄段人群经膳食摄入砷、镉、铅和汞的暴露水平及非致癌健康风险,为上海市水产品安全监管和居民膳食风险控制提供依据.[方法]于2021年10月至11月,在上海市16个区随机采集海水鱼类、淡水鱼类、淡水虾类、海蟹类、淡水蟹类、软体动物类共90件水产品.预处理方法参照GB 5009.268-2016《食品安全国家标准 食品中多元素的测定》.通过电感耦合等离子体质谱仪(ICP‑MS)测定水产品中的As、Cd、Pb的质量分数;采用直接测汞法测定水产品中的Hg.依据欧洲食品安全局(EFSA)推荐的方法,按总As质量分数的3.5%估算无机砷(iAs).依据GB 2762-2017《食品安全国家标准 食品中污染物限量》评价水产品As、Cd、Pb和Hg的污染水平,并采用点评估和概率评估相结合的评估方法计算不同年龄段人群膳食暴露量及非致癌风险指标——危害商(HQ)和危害指数(HI).[结果]As和Hg在所有样品中的检出率均为100.00%,Cd和Pb分别为74.44%和25.56%.4种元素及估算的iAs质量分数(以湿重计)的xˉ±s:As为(1.432 9±3.736 5)mg·kg-1,iAs为(0.050 2±0.130 8)mg·kg-1,Cd为(0.082 5±0.197 8)mg·kg-1,Pb为(0.006 1±0.005 5)mg·kg-1,Hg为(0.021 9±0.016 7)mg·kg-1.依据相关限量标准进行评价,7件软体动物样品中2件样品iAs超标(28.57%),20件海水鱼类样品中有3件样品iAs超标(15.00%),8件海蟹类中2件样品Cd超标(25.00%).不同年龄人群通过水产品摄入iAs、Cd、Pb和Hg的每日估计摄入量(EDI,μg·kg-1·d-1,按体重计)存在差异,其中3~4岁年龄段儿童的EDI最高,随年龄增加逐渐下降,12~<15岁最低,此后略有回升.点评估结果表明,iAs、Cd、Pb和Hg的HQ范围为0.00~0.25,累积HI范围为0.27~0.48,均小于1,提示总体风险较低.概率评估结果显示,在设定高暴露水平(P97.5)下,3~9岁年龄段儿童的iAs与Cd的HQ超过1(iAs为1.101~1.281;Cd为1.175~1.366),提示可能存在潜在健康风险;而Pb与Hg的HQ均低于1,风险相对较低.[结论]上海市售水产品中Hg、As普遍检出,Cd、Pb检出率相对较低.总体非致癌风险处于可接受水平,但3~9岁儿童在高百分位暴露水平下可能存在iAs和Cd的潜在健康风险.建议加强海水鱼类、软体动物类和海蟹类等重点水产品的重金属监测,并针对儿童等敏感人群开展膳食风险管理.
[Objective]To investigate the contamination status of arsenic(As),cadmium(Cd),lead(Pb),and mercury(Hg)in commercially available aquatic products in Shanghai and their distribution characteristics among different categories of aquatic products,and to assess the dietary exposure levels and non‑carcinogenic health risks of As,Cd,Pb,and Hg through aquatic product consumption among different age groups,so as to provide a scientific basis for food safety surveillance of aquatic products and dietary risk management for residents in Shanghai.[Methods]From October to November 2021,a total of 90 aquatic product samples,including marine fish,freshwater fish,freshwater shrimp,marine crab,freshwater crab,and mollusks,were randomly collected from 16 districts of Shanghai.Sample pretreatment was performed according to GB 5009.268-2016(National Food Safety Standard—Determination of Multi‑elements in Foods).The concentrations of As,Cd,and Pb in aquatic products were determined by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry(ICP‑MS),and Hg was determined by direct mercury analyzer.Inorganic arsenic(iAs)was estimated as 3.5%of total As according to the method recommended by the European Food Safety Authority(EFSA).The contamination levels of As,Cd,Pb,and Hg in aquatic products were evaluated according to GB 2762-2017(National Food Safety Standard—Maximum Levels of Contaminants in Foods).A combined approach of point assessment and probabilistic assessment was applied to estimate the estimated daily intake(EDI)and non‑carcinogenic risk indicators—hazard quotient(HQ)and hazard index(HI)—for different age groups.[Results]The detection rates of As and Hg were both 100.00%in all samples,while those of Cd and Pb were 74.44%and 25.56%,respectively.The arithmetic means(wet weight)of the four elements and estimated iAs were:As(1.432 9±3.736 5)mg·kg-1,iAs(0.050 2±0.130 8)mg·kg-1,Cd(0.082 5±0.197 8)mg·kg-1,Pb(0.006 1±0.005 5)mg·kg-1,and Hg(0.021 9±0.016 7)mg·kg-1.According to the relevant maximum residue limits,2 out of 7 mollusk samples(28.57%)and 3 out of 20 marine fish samples(15.00%)exceeded the limit for iAs,and 2 out of 8 marine crab samples(25.00%)exceeded the limit for Cd.The estimated daily intake(EDI,μg·kg-1·d-1,by body weight)of iAs,Cd,Pb,and Hg via aquatic product consumption varied among different age groups,with the highest levels observed in children aged 3-4 years,decreasing gradually with age to the lowest level at 12-<15 years,with a slight rebound thereafter.The point assessment results showed that the HQs of iAs,Cd,Pb,and Hg ranged from 0 to 0.25,and the cumulative HI ranged from 0.27 to 0.48,all below 1,indicating a relatively low overall risk.The probabilistic assessment results revealed that under the high‑exposure scenario(P97.5),the HQs of iAs(1.101-1.281)and Cd(1.175-1.366)exceeded 1 in children aged 3-9 years,suggesting potential health risks,while the HQs of Pb and Hg were all below 1,indicating relatively lower risks.[Conclusion]Hg and As are ubiquitously detected in commercially available aquatic products in Shanghai,while the detection rates of Cd and Pb are relatively low.The overall non-carcinogenic risk is at an acceptable level,but children aged 3-9 years may have potential health risks from iAs and Cd under high-percentile exposure levels.It is recommended to strengthen the monitoring of toxic elements in key aquatic products such as marine fish,mollusks,and marine crabs,and to implement targeted dietary risk management measures for sensitive populations,including children.
施蓉;冒丹丹;陈丽梅;张妍;张慧敏;高宇;田英
上海交通大学公共卫生学院,上海 200025上海交通大学公共卫生学院,上海 200025无锡市疾病预防控制中心环境卫生科,江苏 无锡 214023上海交通大学公共卫生学院,上海 200025上海市疾病预防控制中心化学品毒性检定所,上海 201107上海交通大学公共卫生学院,上海 200025上海交通大学公共卫生学院,上海 200025||上海交通大学医学院附属新华医院环境与儿童健康教育部重点实验室,环境与儿童健康上海市重点实验室,上海 200092||上海交通大学环境科学与工程学院生态环境部新污染物环境健康影响评价重点实验室,上海 200233
医药卫生
水产品重金属膳食暴露非致癌风险儿童
aquatic productheavy metaldietary exposurenon-carcinogenic riskchild
《上海预防医学》 2026 (8)
598-603,609,7
上海市科委自然科学基金项目(22ZR1435600)无锡市第二届"双百"中青年医疗卫生后备拔尖人才项目(HB2023096)
评论