开源AI治理与数据标准话语权:困境、路径与学科视角OA
Open-source AI governance and discursive power in data standard-setting:Dilemmas,paths,and disciplinary perspectives
开源人工智能(AI)治理中的标准话语权失衡,使中国开源模型的事实优势难以转化为制度话语权.本文以标准话语权为分析对象,考察其失衡的表现与成因:开源促进会(Open Source Initiative,OSI)董事会无亚洲代表,其开源AI定义(Open Source AI Definition,OSAID)因不要求公开训练数据而受到多方批评,欧盟AI法案的开源豁免在高风险场景下亦不适用;与此同时,中国开源AI模型已形成事实标准,Qwen衍生模型超过11.3万个,DeepSeek在HuggingFace平台关注度居首,而制度话语权与事实贡献之间仍存在明显落差.本文分析标准竞争背后的权力逻辑,梳理数据跨境治理的制度困境,提出依托AI物料清单(AI Bill of Materials,AIBOM)标准化、可信数据空间建设和区域性合规互认等路径构建自主标准生态的方案,并从数据学科建设的视角论述标准构建的知识基础和人才支撑.
The imbalance of standard discursive power in open-source AI governance hinders the transformation of China's de facto advantages in open-source models into institutional discourse power.Taking standard discourse power as its analytical object,this paper examines the manifestations and causes of this imbalance:the board of the Open Source Initiative(OSI)has no Asian representatives,its open source AI definition(OSAID)has been widely criticized for not requiring the disclosure of training data,and the open-source exemptions of the EU AI Act are not applicable to high-risk scenarios.Meanwhile,Chinese open-source AI models have become de facto standards,with Qwen generating over 113 000 derivative models and DeepSeek ranking first in attention on HuggingFace,yet there remains an evident gap between institutional discourse power and actual contributions.This paper analyzes the power dynamics behind standard competition,examines the institutional dilemmas of cross-border data governance,proposes pathways for building an autonomous standard ecosystem through AI bill of materials(AIBOM)standardization,trusted data spaces,and regional compliance mutual recognition,and discusses the knowledge foundation and talent support for standard building from the perspective of data discipline construction.
韩威如;贺雯忆;金逸胜;王伟;段莫名
华东师范大学数据科学与工程学院,上海 200062华东师范大学数据科学与工程学院,上海 200062华东师范大学数据科学与工程学院,上海 200062华东师范大学数据科学与工程学院,上海 200062华东师范大学数据科学与工程学院,上海 200062
信息技术与安全科学
开源AI治理标准话语权数据跨境流动AI物料清单数据科学
open source AI governancestandard discourse powercross-border data flowAI bill of materialsdata science
《华东师范大学学报(自然科学版)》 2026 (5)
145-152,8
上海市白玉兰人才计划浦江项目(25PJA029)
评论