茶之边界、消费分层与茶饮平民化:清代民国四川老鹰茶研究OACHSSCD
The boundaries of tea,stratified consumption,and the popularization of tea drinking:A study of Laoying tea in Sichuan during the Qing Dynasty and the Republican Period
清代至民国时期中国茶叶消费是否实现平民化,是近代茶史研究中的重要问题.相关讨论多将历史文献中的"茶"等同于现代植物学意义上的真茶,较少辨析其在历史语境中的实际所指.清代民国四川老鹰茶的生产、流通与消费,构成重新审视近代茶饮平民化的个案.在当时的认知体系中,"茶"的界定并不主要依据植物亲缘关系,而更多取决于制作方式与饮用功效.老鹰茶虽在现代分类中属于代用茶,却长期以老鹰茶、老人茶、白茶、红茶、红白茶等名称见于地方文献,并在民众观念认知、日常饮用和市场交易中被纳入茶的范畴.随着利用范围扩大、消费需求增长和商品属性增强,老鹰茶逐渐由局部山区的野生采食资源,转化为覆盖四川城乡并延伸至川康边地的日常茶饮商品.近代四川茶饮平民化的实质,并非真茶在社会下层的普遍流行,而是形成了官绅士人饮真茶、普通民众饮老鹰茶的消费分层格局.老鹰茶价格低廉、制法简便、供给充足,又兼具消暑解渴、食疗保健和耐贮藏等实用功能,因而能够适应平民的日常生活需要.其消费场景不仅包括家庭饮用、农事劳作和茶泡饭,也深入城乡茶馆经营之中,成为四川茶馆低成本运转和广泛普及的重要物质基础.精英阶层对老鹰茶的排斥,并不单纯源于口感或品质差异,更与饮食消费中的身份区隔和文化品味有关.在市场流通层面,老鹰茶依托稳定的大众消费、分散而充裕的原料资源以及相对宽松的税制环境,形成了以产地为中心、辐射邻近州县的区域贩运网络,并通过川西、川北进入松潘、西康及藏青市场,参与近代川康边地的物资交换与商业循环.通过老鹰茶的研究可以发现,近代中国茶饮平民化并不意味着真茶消费的下沉,而是代用茶被纳入茶的认知与消费体系后,实现的饮茶习惯普及.由此,茶史研究有必要重视"茶"概念的古今差异、茶饮消费的阶层分化,以及历史文献中茶叶数据的复合属性.
Whether tea consumption in China became popularized among commoners during the Qing Dynasty and the Republican Period is an important question in the study of modern Chinese tea history.Existing scholarship has often equated the term"tea"in historical sources directly with"true tea"in the modern botanical sense,thereby overlooking its actual referent within historical contexts.The production,circulation,and consumption of Laoying tea in Sichuan during the Qing and Republican periods provide a useful case through which to reconsider the popularization of tea drinking in modern China.Within the cognitive framework of the time,the definition of"tea"was not determined primarily by botanical affinity,but rather by methods of preparation and practical effects.Although Laoying tea is classified in modern terms as a substitute tea,it long appeared in local sources under such names as Laoying tea,Laoren tea,white tea,red tea,and red-white tea,and was incorporated into the category of tea in both everyday consumption and market transactions.As its scope of use expanded,consumer demand increased,and its commodity attributes strengthened,Laoying tea gradually transformed from a wild food resource gathered in localized mountain areas into a daily tea-drinking commodity that reached both urban and rural Sichuan and extended further into the Sichuan-Xikang borderlands.The essence of the popularization of tea drinking in modern Sichuan was therefore not the widespread diffusion of true tea among the lower strata of society,but rather the formation of a stratified pattern of consumption in which officials,gentry,and literati tended to drink true tea,while ordinary people more commonly consumed Laoying tea.Owing to its low price,simple processing techniques,abundant supply,and practical functions such as relieving summer heat and thirst,serving as a dietary therapy,promoting health,and withstanding long-term storage,Laoying tea was well suited to the everyday needs of commoner society.Its consumption contexts included not only household drinking,agricultural labor,and tea-soaked rice,but also the operation of urban and rural teahouses,making it an important material basis for the low-cost operation and broad diffusion of Sichuan teahouses.Elite rejection of Laoying tea did not stem merely from differences in taste or quality,but was also closely related to status distinction and cultural taste in food consumption.In terms of market circulation,Laoying tea,supported by stable mass consumption,dispersed yet abundant raw-material resources,and a relatively lenient tax environment,formed regional trade networks centered on its places of production and radiating to neighboring prefectures and counties.Through routes in western and northern Sichuan,it entered Songpan,Xikang,and the Tibetan-Qinghai markets,thereby participating in the material exchange and commercial circulation of the modern Sichuan-Xikang borderlands.The study of Laoying tea reveals that the popularization of tea drinking in modern China did not necessarily mean the downward diffusion of true tea consumption.Rather,it was achieved through the incorporation of substitute teas into the cognitive and consumptive system of tea,which enabled the broader dissemination of tea-drinking practices.Accordingly,tea history research should pay closer attention to the differences between ancient and modern concepts of tea,the class differentiation of consumption practices,and the composite nature of historical data concerning tea.
赵东科;吴轶群
新疆大学 马克思主义学院,新疆 乌鲁木齐 830000新疆大学 历史学院,新疆 乌鲁木齐 830000
社会科学
老鹰茶阶级性茶馆茶饮平民化
Laoying teaclass characterteahousespopularization of tea drinking
《重庆大学学报(社会科学版)》 2026 (4)
174-185,12
新疆维吾尔自治区重大科技专项项目"北庭历史文化挖掘与数字资源构建关键技术研究"(2023A03001-1)
评论