首页|期刊导航|Matter and Radiation at Extremes|Evidence of inconsistencies between publicly released raw data and published figures for the claimed observation of the Wigner–Huntington transition to metallic hydrogen

Evidence of inconsistencies between publicly released raw data and published figures for the claimed observation of the Wigner–Huntington transition to metallic hydrogenOA

中文摘要

In 2017,Dias and Silvera[Science 355,715–718(2017)]claimed the first laboratory observation of the Wigner–Huntington transition of hydrogen to its metallic phase at 495 GPa.Because this claim relies critically on optical diagnostics and pressure calibration under extreme conditions,reproducibility and full traceability of the underlying datasets are essential.Here,we re-examine the raw data files released alongside the publication.We identify(ⅰ)nonuniform intervals of data points in the released diamond Raman spectrum,consistent with artificial removal or adjustment of data points without corresponding disclosure;(ⅱ)pronounced mismatches between the released infrared transmission spectra and the curves shown in the published supplementary materials;and(ⅲ)a highly limited and editable reflectance dataset that is insufficient for independent verification of the reflectivity-based metallicity claim.These issues not only prevent independent reconstruction of key figures,but also cast doubt on the authenticity of Dias and Silvera''s research findings.We encourage clarification of the provenance of the released files and the provision of complete raw datasets and processing details to enable community-wide verification.

Lin Wang;Hongkai Li;Zhongyan Wu;Guoying Gao;Yongjun Tian

Center for High Pressure Science,State Key Laboratory of Metastable Materials Science and Technology,Yanshan University,Qinhuangdao,Hebei 066004,ChinaCenter for High Pressure Science,State Key Laboratory of Metastable Materials Science and Technology,Yanshan University,Qinhuangdao,Hebei 066004,China Key Laboratory for Microstructural Material Physics of Hebei Province,School of Science,Yanshan University,Qinhuangdao 066004,ChinaCenter for High Pressure Science,State Key Laboratory of Metastable Materials Science and Technology,Yanshan University,Qinhuangdao,Hebei 066004,ChinaCenter for High Pressure Science,State Key Laboratory of Metastable Materials Science and Technology,Yanshan University,Qinhuangdao,Hebei 066004,ChinaCenter for High Pressure Science,State Key Laboratory of Metastable Materials Science and Technology,Yanshan University,Qinhuangdao,Hebei 066004,China

化学化工

raw dataevidencepressure calibrationwigner huntington transitionmetallic phaseoptical diagnosticsdiamond ramaninconsistencies

《Matter and Radiation at Extremes》 2026 (5)

P.93-98,6

supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China(Grant Nos.52288102,52090020,and 52372261)the Natural Science Foundation of Hebei Province(Grant No.E202403045)the S&T Program of Hebei(Grant No.225A1102D)the Ministry of Education Chang Jiang Scholar Professor Program(Grant No.T2022241)。

10.1063/5.0306863

评论