学校声望、专业回报还是专业适配性OA
School Prestige,Major Return or Major Fit?
高等教育选择是中国学生一生中最重要的选择之一.现有研究主要围绕学校声望和专业回报展开,难以充分解释与区域产业密切联系的高等职业教育的情况.基于2022年"中国职业教育现状调查"数据,运用机器学习算法,建立包含学校声望、专业回报和专业适配性三个维度的高职教育选择模型.研究发现,产业背景是影响高职学生教育选择的重要因素,区域产业发展影响学生对学校和专业的选择,使"专业适配性"成为区别于普通高等教育的重要选择逻辑.进一步分析表明,高职学生的高等教育选择同时受到以下因素的影响:个体特征所对应的角色目标;家庭资本的限制或机会形成的推拉作用;区域产业类型和发展水平提供的就业机会和兴趣所形成的导向作用;关系网络的信息资源和关系期待所构成的关系理性的决策模式.此外,不同区域因产业发展和院校资源分布不同而呈现出明显的选择机制差异.针对高职学生的高等教育选择机制,建议完善高职教育内部资助体系和招生指导体系,进一步深化产教融合,同时构建覆盖全国的职业院校产业协同体系,以更好地帮助学生作出适合自己实际情况的高职教育选择.
Higher education choice is one of the most important decisions in the lives of Chinese students.Existing research has primarily focused on school prestige and major returns,which may not fully explain the distinctive choices involved in higher vocational education,where education is closely connected to regional industries.Using data from the 2022 Survey on the Current Situation of Vocational Education in China,this study employs machine learning algorithms to examine higher vocational students'choices across three dimensions:school prestige,major returns,and major fit.The findings show that regional industrial development is an important factor shaping students'choices of institutions and majors,while major fit emerges as a distinctive choice logic that differentiates higher vocational education from general higher education.Further analysis identifies four factors shaping students'choices:role goals associated with individual characteristics;the constraints and opportunities arising from family capital;employment opportunities and interests associated with regional industrial development;and relational rationality in decision-making based on informational resources and relational expectations embedded in social networks.Significant regional differences in choice mechanisms also emerge due to variations in industrial development and educational resources.Based on the mechanisms underlying higher vocational students'higher education choices,this study recommends improving the internal funding and admissions guidance systems of higher vocational education,further deepening the integration of industry and education,and establishing a nationwide industry-institution collaboration system for vocational colleges,thereby better helping students make higher vocational education choices suited to their individual circumstances.
孙静含
清华大学社会科学学院(北京,100084)
社会科学
高等职业教育学校声望专业回报专业适配性教育选择
higher vocational educationschool prestigemajor returnmajor fiteducational choice
《职业技术教育》 2026 (25)
36-47,12
评论