降雨输入误差对新安江模型径流模拟影响研究OA
Impact of Rainfall Input Errors on Runoff Simulation Using the Xin'anjiang Model
降雨是水文模型的重要输入,其数据质量直接影响径流模拟的精度和可靠性.研究降雨输入误差对径流模拟的影响有助于掌握水文模拟误差来源,提高水文模拟精度.基于新安江模型,结合可解释机器学习的方法,系统分析了多类型降雨误差对新安江模型径流模拟的综合影响.选取12场典型洪水,设计了包括系统性偏差、强度偏差、时空分布误差等在内的多维度降雨误差扰动,提取12项降雨误差特征,通过XGBoost挖掘降雨误差与径流模拟的关系,构建新安江模型径流模拟精度(纳什效率系数NSE及径流相对误差RE)预测模型,并结合SHAP值定量解析降雨误差特征对径流模拟精度的影响机制,定量评估各降雨误差特征的全局重要性、影响方向及交互作用.结果表明:XGBoost模型能较好预测径流模拟精度(NSE及RE),测试集平均决定系数(R²)高于0.96;降雨相对偏差(RB)是影响径流模拟精度的主导因素,大雨偏差和均方根误差也是重要影响因素;RB与RE呈高度线性关系,而与NSE则呈非线性关系,且存在阈值效应:RB超过15%后NSE显著下降,同时高估降雨比低估降雨对NSE的影响更为显著;降雨均方根误差超过0.2 mm/h时会与RB共同加剧径流模拟不确定性.研究结果可为控制径流模拟中的降雨输入误差、提升洪水预报的精度提供新的分析框架和定量依据.
Rainfall is a critical input to hydrological models,and its data quality directly impacts the accuracy and reliability of runoff simulation.Investigating the influence of rainfall input errors on runoff simulation is essential for identifying the sources of hydrological simulation errors and improving simulation precision.This study systematically analyzes the comprehensive impact of multiple types of rainfall errors on runoff simulation using the Xin'anjiang(XAJ)model,integrated with explainable machine learning methods.A total of 12 typical flood events were selected,and a multi-dimensional rainfall error perturbation scheme—including systematic bias,intensity bias,and spatiotemporal distribution errors—was designed.Twelve rainfall error features were extracted,and XGBoost was applied to explore the relationship between rainfall errors and runoff simulation,thereby constructing a predictive model for the simulation accuracy(Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency,NSE,and Relative Error,RE)of the XAJ model.SHAP values were further used to quantitatively analyze the influence mechanisms of rainfall error features on runoff simulation accuracy,and to evaluate the global importance,directional effects,and interactions of each rainfall error feature.The results show that:The XGBoost model effectively predicts runoff simulation accuracy(NSE and RE),with an average coefficient of determination(R²)exceeding 0.96 on the test set.Relative Bias(RB)of rainfall is the dominant factor affecting runoff simulation accuracy,with heavy rainfall bias and Root Mean Square Error(RMSE)also being important influencing factors.RB exhibits a strong linear relationship with RE,but a nonlinear relationship with NSE,accompanied by a threshold effect:when RB exceeds 15%,NSE decreases significantly,and overestimated rainfall has a more pronounced impact on NSE than underestimated rainfall;When the rainfall RMSE exceeds 0.2 mm/h,it interacts with RB to jointly intensify runoff simulation uncertainty.The findings provide a new analytical framework and quantitative basis for controlling rainfall input errors in runoff simulation and improving the accuracy of flood forecasting.
杨春前;张晓皓;方园皓;张行南;吴碧琼
河海大学水文水资源学院,江苏 南京 210098河海大学水文水资源学院,江苏 南京 210098河海大学水文水资源学院,江苏 南京 210098||中国长江电力股份有限公司,湖北 宜昌 443002河海大学水文水资源学院,江苏 南京 210098中国长江三峡集团有限公司,湖北 宜昌 443133||智慧长江与水电科学湖北省重点实验室(中国长江电力股份有限公司),湖北 宜昌 443000
建筑与水利
新安江模型径流模拟降雨误差机器学习SHAP
Xin'anjiang(XAJ)modelrunoff simulationrainfall errormachine learningSHAP
《中国农村水利水电》 2026 (9)
32-40,9
中国长江电力股份有限公司科研项目(Z242302054)国家自然科学基金项目(U2240216)江苏省水利科技项目(2024006).
评论