大理州红花大金元种植适宜性评价方法研究OA
Evaluation methods for planting suitability of Honghuadajinyuan in Dali Prefecture
[目的]比较最大熵(Maximum entropy,MaxEnt)模型与机器学习(Machine learning,ML)算法在预测大理州红花大金元烟草的潜在适宜种植区中的表现,以揭示不同建模策略的适用性与优势.[方法]基于309 个实地采集的红花大金元分布点及大理州气候、土壤和地形等环境协变量,对比分析 MaxEnt 模型和机器学习算法对预测大理州红花大金元潜在分布区的差异.[结果]MaxEnt 模型整体预测效果较优,训练集 AUC 为0.941,测试集 AUC 为0.873;机器学习模型中,Bagging-MLP 在适宜类型判别表现较好,训练集 AUC 为0.937、测试集 AUC 为0.852,但在适宜级别划分中测试集 AUC 降至0.703,泛化能力减弱;RF 在不适宜级别判别中最优,训练集 AUC 为0.992、测试集AUC 为0.846;两种方法预测的环境变量重要性结果有所差异,MaxEnt 模型结果显示影响红花大金元潜在分布的主要因子顺序是坡度、高程、归一化植被指数、速效钾、成熟期降水量、水溶性氯、土壤电导率、坡向、全氮含量、有效磷,机器学习算法输出的主要环境变量是土壤养分和植被指数的综合作用;两种方法模拟的红花大金元潜在分布结果有着很大的重合度,主要集中于巍山彝族回族自治县东北部、洱源县东北部、弥渡县西北部等地区.[结论]机器学习算法在大理州红花大金元种植适宜性评价中的准确性优于 MaxEnt 模型,其预测结果更具连续性和稳定性,可为大理州特色烟叶适宜性规划提供科学参考.
[Objective]The study aims to compare the performance of the Maximum Entropy(MaxEnt)model and machine learning(ML)algorithms in predicting the potential suitable planting areas for Honghuadajinyuan tobacco in Dali Prefecture,so as to reveal the applicability and advantages of different modeling strategies.[Method]Using 309 field-surveyed occurrence records and environmental covariates related to climate,soil and topography,the differences in potential distribution patterns generated by the two approaches were assessed.[Result]The MaxEnt model showed strong overall predictive performance,with an AUC of 0.941 for the training set and 0.873 for the test set.Among the machine learning models,Bagging-MLP performed well in suitability type classification,with an AUC of 0.937 for the training set and 0.852 for the test set.However,in suitability level classification,the test set AUC decreased to 0.703,indicating reduced generalization ability.The RF model performed best in unsuitable level classification,achieving an AUC of 0.992 for the training set and 0.846 for the test set.Variable importance rankings differed across methods,with MaxEnt highlighting topographic and climatic factors,while ML emphasized the combined influence of soil nutrients and vegetation indices.Both approaches revealed a high degree of spatial overlap in predicted suitable areas,prima-rily located in northeastern Weishan,northeastern Eryuan and northwestern Midu.[Conclusion]Machine-learning algorithms outperform MaxEnt in assessing the suitability of Honghuadajinyuan tobacco cultivation in Dali Prefecture,delivering more continuous and stable predic-tions that can scientifically guide regional planning for this characteristic crop.
苑钰珂;翁倩文;李娟;张炳峰;史宏志;马月红;陈伟强
河南农业大学资源与环境学院,郑州 450046河南农业大学资源与环境学院,郑州 450046云南省烟草公司大理州公司,云南 大理 671000云南中烟工业有限责任公司原料中心,昆明 650231河南农业大学烟草学院,郑州 450046河南农业大学资源与环境学院,郑州 450046河南农业大学资源与环境学院,郑州 450046
农业科技
最大熵模型机器学习算法红花大金元适宜性评价大理州
Maximum entropyMachine learningHonghuadajinyuanSuitability evaluationDali Prefecture
《西南农业学报》 2026 (7)
1503-1512,10
国家重点研发计划项目(2021YFD1700900)中国烟草总公司云南省公司科技项目(30802431)
评论