劳动场景下个人信息处理规则的适用困境与重构OACHSSCD
Application dilemma and reconstruction of personal information processing rules in workplace context
数智化时代,劳动者个人信息保护面临严峻挑战.现行《个人信息保护法》在劳动场景中存在适用困境.分析这些规则在劳动领域适用时面临的具体障碍,并探索制度完善路径.研究发现,由于劳资地位不平等,同意在劳动场景中易流于形式,"实施人力资源管理所必需"条款因缺乏客观界定,异化为近乎无限的概括性授权.面对上述问题,需要基于劳动法倾斜保护原则与个人信息保护法理,通过法律解释或增设劳动法规范的方式对现有规则进行重构.首先,调整合法性基础的适用顺位,将同意定位为例外事由,并建立分层告知机制;其次,需对"实施人力资源管理所必需"条款进行限缩解释,引入程序与实体的双重审查标准;最后,重新分配举证责任并构建无不利后果的司法救济机制.现行个人信息处理规则的制度设计具有合理性,但在劳动场景中的适用效果与立法预期存在落差.应在坚持现有法律框架的前提下,回归劳动法倾斜保护的法理核心,进行有针对性的调适与完善,以实现劳动者权益保护与用人单位正当管理需求之间的动态平衡.主要创新之处在于立足劳动法倾斜保护视角,深入剖析一般性个人信息保护规则在劳动领域适用的结构性障碍,提出系统性规则重构方案,为矫正数智化时代劳资权利失衡、防范算法与管理权滥用提供参考.
In the era of digital intelligence,the protection of laborers'personal information is facing severe challenges.The current Personal Information Protection Law has difficulties in application in the workplace context.This paper analyzes the specific obstacles faced by the application of these rules in the labor field and explores the path to institutional improvement.This paper finds that due to the unequal status of employers and laborers,consent is easy to become a mere formality in the workplace context,and the clause of"being necessary for human resources management"is transformed into almost unlimited general authorization due to the lack of an objective definition.Facing the above problems,it is necessary to reconstruct the existing rules through legal interpretation or supplementary provisions in labor law based on the principle of preferential protection of labor law and the legal principle of personal information protection.First,it is essential to adjust the application order of the legitimacy basis,position consent as an exception,and establish a tiered notification mechanism.Second,the clause of"being necessary for human resources management"should be narrowly interpreted,with the introduction of dual procedural and substantive review standards.Finally,the burden of proof should be reallocated,and a judicial relief mechanism without adverse consequences should be established.The institutional design of the current personal information processing rules is reasonable,but there is a gap between the application effect in the workplace context and the legislative expectation.Under the premise of adhering to the existing legal framework,it is necessary to return to the core legal principle of the preferential protection of labor law and make targeted adjustments and improvements,so as to achieve a dynamic balance between the protection of laborers'rights and interests and the legitimate management needs of employers.The main innovation of this paper lies in the deep analysis of the structural barriers to the application of general personal information protection rules in the labor field from the perspective of preferential protection of labor law,and the proposal of systematic rule reconstruction,which provides references for correcting the imbalance of rights between employers and laborers and preventing the abuse of algorithms and management rights in the era of digital intelligence.
张岩;刘小萌
辽宁社会科学院 哲学研究所,辽宁 沈阳 110021辽宁大学 法学院,辽宁 沈阳 110036
社会科学
劳动者个人信息保护倾斜保护告知同意算法治理
laborerspersonal information protectionpreferential protectioninformed consentalgorithmic governance
《沈阳工业大学学报(社会科学版)》 2026 (4)
92-100,9
辽宁社会科学院重点项目(Lnsky26ZDB05)全国党校(行政学院)系统社科规划青年项目(2025DXXTQN065).
评论