基于软系统方法论的集体林权制度改革政策效果评估OA
Evaluation of the Policy Effects of Collective Forest Tenure System Reform Based on Soft Systems Methodology
集体林权制度改革是中国农村基本经营制度的重大变革,对于保障林农权益、推动乡村振兴和生态文明建设等具有深远意义.改革涉及多元主体、多重利益及多维目标,传统评估方法难以系统量化其多维成效,尤其对林农满意度、政策执行效率等软性因素捕捉不足.为此,文中引入软系统方法论,通过分析问题情境、构建根定义及多层次概念模型,整合"森林蓄积量""林农满意度""林权纠纷调解效率"等硬性与软性指标,构建了一套涵盖经济、生态、社会、制度4 个维度的集体林权制度改革政策效果评估指标体系,并将指标体系与现实改革进行比较,验证了其科学性与可操作性,为全面评估集体林权制度改革的综合成效、持续深化改革提供有力的分析工具.
The collective forest tenure system reform constitutes a major transformation of China's basic rural management system,and is of far-reaching significance for safeguarding forest farmers'legitimate rights and interests,advancing rural revitalization and fostering ecological civilization construction.The reform involves multiple stakeholders,diverse interests and multi-dimensional objectives.Traditional evaluation methods are incapable of systematically quantifying its multi-dimensional effects,and especially fail to fully capture soft factors such as forest farmers'satisfaction and policy implementation efficiency.For this reason,this paper introduces the soft systems methodology.By analyzing problem situations,establishing root definitions and multi-level conceptual models,it integrates hard indicators such as"forest stock volume"and soft indicators including"forest farmers'satisfaction"and"mediation efficiency of forest tenure disputes",and constructs a policy effect evaluation index system for collective forest tenure system reform covering economic,ecological,social and institutional dimensions.By comparing the index system with actual reform practices,this study verifies its scientific validity and operability,providing an powerful analytical tool for comprehensively and multi-dimensionally evaluating the overall effects of collective forest tenure system reform and further deepening the reform.
牛昕;张鋆萍;王烨;张志丹;严茂林
国家林业和草原局管理干部学院 北京 102600国家林业和草原局管理干部学院 北京 102600国家林业和草原局管理干部学院 北京 102600国家林业和草原局管理干部学院 北京 102600国家林业和草原局管理干部学院 北京 102600
管理科学
集体林权制度改革政策效果评估软系统方法论
collective forest tenure system reformpolicy effect evaluationsoft systems methodology
《林草政策研究》 2026 (2)
42-52,11
国家林业和草原局软科学研究项目"深化集体林权制度改革的政策效果评估及对策建议研究"(2024131020)
评论