首页|期刊导航|创新科技|原始创新的多维测度:概念辨析、方法演进与综合框架

原始创新的多维测度:概念辨析、方法演进与综合框架OA

Multidimensional Measurement of Original Innovation:Concep-tual Clarification,Methodological Evolution,and an Integrative Framework

中文摘要英文摘要

原始创新是科学研究、技术开发与工程实践中具有开创性和高创新强度的一类重大创新成果.其评价既涉及原始性科学创新、原始性技术创新和原始性工程创新等成果类型差异,也涉及首创性、突破性、颠覆性和引领性等属性的区分和综合.现有量化研究围绕原创性与新颖性、激进性与突破性、颠覆性与影响力等相邻构念,逐步形成知识组合分析、文本语义挖掘、知识单元识别、引文网络解析与机器学习等测度方法.但相关研究在概念层面仍存在构念边界交叉等问题,在方法层面则存在观测证据与评价属性对应关系不清、不同成熟阶段证据混用等问题.本文依托"科学—技术—工程"原始创新分类体系,严格区分成果类型与评价属性,系统梳理论文、专利载体下4项属性的主要测度方法及其演进脉络,并对KI、CD/DI、LOF、激进发明指标及机器学习综合得分等跨属性方法进行分量拆解与重新归类.据此,形成以构念区分、分类观测、复合指标拆解和动态更新为核心的综合测度框架:将论文和专利分别作为科学类、技术类原始创新的主要可操作载体,在统一四维构念下配置差异化指标,并依据成果成熟阶段逐步补充后续演化证据;进一步适配大规模计量场景,探讨论文与专利的原始创新指数测度方式,并初步纳入工程化、产业化实现程度,提出分层聚合的原始创新综合指数构建思路.本文通过厘清相邻构念、重构方法谱系和规范综合评价规则,为原始创新的识别、测度与分类评价提供坚实的理论支撑与方法依据.

Original innovation refers to highly innovative achievements that make founda-tional and pioneering contributions in scientific research,technological development,or engi-neering practice.As differentiated research evaluation becomes increasingly important,a key methodological challenge is how to translate this concept into a measurement system that is inter-pretable,comparable,and capable of evolving with the maturity and form of research outputs.Ex-isting studies have developed a wide range of approaches around related constructs such as origi-nality,novelty,radicalness,breakthrough,disruptiveness,and impact,using knowledge combina-tions,textual semantics,knowledge units,citation networks,and machine learning.Yet the boundaries among these constructs often overlap,the correspondence between observable evi-dence and evaluative attributes remains unclear,and evidence emerging at different stages of ma-turity is frequently conflated.Building on the science-technology-engineering classification of original innovation,this study distinguishes types of innovation outputs from evaluative attri-butes.Through a systematic review of bibliometric approaches to papers and patents,it organizes original innovation along two dimensions,comparison reference and stage of evidence emer-gence,and identifies four evaluative attributes:originality,breakthrough,disruptiveness,and leading influence.The findings are as follows:Originality concerns first creation relative to the historical stock of knowledge or technology and is best assessed primarily through the historical first appearance of substantive content,supplemented by atypical combinations and semantic novelty.Breakthrough captures substantive advances beyond the contemporary knowledge fron-tier,technological trajectory,or performance boundary;structural shifts and cross-community bridging are useful for candidate identification,while the resolution of major problems,gains in explanatory power,and critical performance leaps provide stronger substantive evidence.Disrup-tiveness concerns the weakening or restructuring of dependence on established knowledge or technological paths after an innovation appears and can be assessed mainly through CD/DI to-gether with subsequent evidence from citation context and topic trajectories.Leading influence refers to the formation,expansion,and sustained development of new knowledge or technological paths and therefore requires joint consideration of impact scale,the emergence of new directions,diffusion breadth,and persistence.On this basis,the study proposes a"decompose-reclassify-aggregate"framework for cross-attribute indicators,reinterpreting measures such as KI,CD/DI,LOF,radical invention indicators,and machine-learning composite scores to reduce construct mixing and double counting.Papers and patents are treated as the currently most mature large-sample observation carriers for scientific and technological original innovation,with differenti-ated indicators applied under a common four-dimensional framework and calibrated by field,year,output type,and maturity stage.To address differences in when evidence becomes observ-able,the framework further introduces staged dynamic updating of four-dimensional profiles and composite scores.It also discusses originality indices for papers and patents and an overall origi-nal innovation index in which engineering and industrialization outcomes enter as realization gains on top of the underlying level of originality.By integrating conceptual clarification,method-ological trajectories,type-specific observation,and dynamic measurement,the framework pro-vides a theoretical and methodological basis for identifying,measuring,tracking,and differen-tially evaluating original innovation.

肖轶群;陈劲

清华大学经济管理学院,北京 100084||清华大学技术创新研究中心,北京 100084||北京清华前沿交叉创新研究院,北京 102202清华大学经济管理学院,北京 100084||清华大学技术创新研究中心,北京 100084

管理科学

原始创新概念分类首创性突破性颠覆性引领性综合测度动态追踪

original innovationconceptual classificationoriginalitybreakthroughdisrup-tivenessleading influencemultidimensional measurementdynamic tracing

《创新科技》 2026 (9)

1-15,15

10.19345/j.cxkj.1671-0037.2026.9.1

评论