高质量决策咨询成果的特征、结构及反思OA
Characteristics,Structure and Reflections on High-Quality Decision-Making Consultation Achievements:An Analysis Based on Shanghai Decision-Making Consultation Research Achievement Award
[研究目的]聚焦我国高质量决策咨询成果建设,以 1000 多项上海市决策咨询研究成果奖获奖成果为样本,从定性和定量层面揭示其基本特征,为提升我国决策咨询研究质量提供参考.[研究方法]采用词频统计分析和系统编码分析等混合研究方法,从成果基本特征、内容特征和质量特征三个维度分析上海市决策咨询研究成果奖获奖成果的特征.[研究结论]上海市决策咨询研究成果奖获奖成果以高校和科研机构团队为主要生产主体,获奖成果形成了五大一级研究主题,与国家及上海重大战略高度同步;研究方法经历了从定性主导向多元融合的显著转型,大数据及信息化方法增长态势最为迅猛;高质量成果呈现问题导向与政策转化紧密耦合、跨学科协作日趋普遍、前瞻性与可操作性有机统一等结构特征,功能类型层面以建言型和分析型为主.未来建议通过加强方法论规范、优化学科主题布局、培育政策型学者队伍、构建决策咨询数据库等举措,推动产出更高质量的决策咨询成果.
[Research purpose]Focusing on high-quality decision-making consultation achievements in China,this study takes over 1,000 award-winning entries of the Shanghai Decision-Making Consultation Research Achievement Award as samples to qualitatively and quantitatively reveal their basic characteristics,providing a reference for improving the quality of decision-making consultation research in China.[Research method]Using mixed methods including word-frequency analysis and systematic coding analysis,this study examines the characteristics of the award-winning entries from three dimensions:basic characteristics,content features,and quality features.[Research conclusion]The findings show that teams from universities and research institutions are the main producers of the Shanghai Decision-Making Consultation Research Achievement Award,and the award-winning entries have formed five core research themes highly synchronized with major national and Shanghai strategies.Research methods have undergone a significant shift from qualitative dominance to diversified integration,with big data and informatization methods growing most rapidly.High-quality entries exhibit structural characteristics including close coupling between problem orientation and policy transformation,increasingly prevalent interdisciplinary collaboration,and the organic unity of foresight and operability.In terms of functional types,advisory and analytical types predominate.Future recommendations include strengthening methodological standardization,optimizing disciplinary theme layout,cultivating policy-oriented scholars,and establishing a decision-making consultation database to promote higher-quality decision-making consultation outcomes.
吴文钰;高向东
华东师范大学社会发展学院,上海,200241华东师范大学公共管理学院,上海,200062
管理科学
决策咨询成果上海市决策咨询研究成果奖获奖成果特征多维分析对策建议
decision-making consultation achievementsShanghai Decision-Making Consultation Research Achievement Awardcharacteristics of award-winning entriesmulti-dimensional analysispolicy recommendations
《科技智囊》 2026 (8)
18-27,10
上海市教育科学研究项目"上海哲学社会科学类高层次人才成长规律研究"(C2024223).
评论