首页|期刊导航|Journal of Meteorological Research|Ground Clutter Impacts on S-and X-Band Weather Radars across Three Chinese Megacities:A 75-Radar Census of Sources,Transmitter-Dependent Discrepancies,and Network Mitigation

Ground Clutter Impacts on S-and X-Band Weather Radars across Three Chinese Megacities:A 75-Radar Census of Sources,Transmitter-Dependent Discrepancies,and Network MitigationOA

中文摘要

The operational utility of S-band weather radars—the backbone of the China New Generation Weather Radar(CINRAD)network—is severely compromised by ground clutter from dense high-rise buildings and surrounding mountainous terrain in megacities.Although over 170 units have been upgraded to dual-polarization,the extent to which such clutter systematically degrades data quality,hydrometeor classification,and quantitative precipitation estimation(QPE)has not been quantified across diverse urban environments.Meanwhile,X-band radars are being deployed extensively as gap-fillers,yet a systematic comparison of their clutter susceptibility relative to S-band systems—and whether dense X-band networking can actively compensate for S-band observational deficits—remains absent.Addressing this knowledge gap is critical for optimizing multi-band collaborative observation strategies and improving severe weather nowcasting in densely populated metropolitan areas.In this study,observations from 25 Sband and 50 X-band radars during the 2024 flood season in Beijing,Hangzhou,and Guangzhou are analyzed.A longterm statistical averaging method is applied to accumulated data from large-scale precipitation events to isolate systematic clutter signatures from random precipitation variability.The study systematically compares the ground clutter impact characteristics between S-band and X-band radars deployed across three Chinese megacities,and quantitatively evaluates the mitigation efficacy of dense X-band radar networking in clutter-affected regions of S-band radars.It is found that for S-band radars,dual-polarization anomalies at low elevations account for 35%-68%,decreasing to 6%-18%aloft,while beam blockage remains below 10%at low elevations.In contrast,X-band radars exhibit only 1%-25%low-elevation anomalies and are nearly clutter-free at high elevations.Source attribution reveals that S-band clutter originates predominantly from buildings,whereas X-band clutter sources are environment-dependent—mountains dominate when mean beam blockage is high,and buildings dominate in densely populated areas.Notably,for solid-state X-band radars,pulse-compression sidelobe effects expand the correlation coefficient(ρHV)impacted area far beyond that of the texture parameter of differential phase[SD(ΦDP)]—a discrepancy absent in klystron-based systems.After strategic X-band networking,the combined mainlobe and sidelobe clutter proportion at 0.5 km altitude drops from 66%-94%to 5%-25%,light-to-moderate rain classification accuracy exceeds 95%,and all QPE algorithms show improved correlation with rain gauges.In conclusion,X-band radars exhibit substantially lower ground clutter susceptibility than S-band radars,and dense X-band networks effectively compensate for S-band observational gaps in complex megacity environments.These findings provide a quantitative foundation for optimizing multi-band radar network deployment and data quality control in China.

Yutong LUO;Chong WU;Liping LIU;Lei WU;Ruiyi LI

State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081 Jinjiang Electronic System Engineering Co.Ltd.,Chengdu 610500State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081Meteorological Observation Centre,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081Meteorological Observation Centre,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081

天文与地球科学

dual polarization weather radarsground clutter impactquality controlstatistical studyquantitative inversion

《Journal of Meteorological Research》 2026 (4)

P.1286-1303,18

Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China(42305156)National Key Research and Development Program of China(2023YFC3007501)Self-Initiated Research Project of the State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(2025QZA05)Sichuan Science and Technology Program(2025YFN0006)Stable Support Research Funding of the National Institute of Electromagnetic Wave Propagation(A250200510)。

10.1007/s13351-026-6035-3

评论