Evaluation of 2-m Air Temperature and Surface Temperature from CMA-RA and ERA5:A Comparison with Buoy Observations in the Arctic during 2001-2024OA
The Arctic is a critical region for global climate change,where temperature variations profoundly influence sea ice dynamics and atmospheric circulation.Harsh conditions limit in-situ observations in the Arctic,making reanalysis datasets indispensable,while the reliability of these reanalysis products requires systematic validation.This study evaluates the performance of the China Meteorological Administration Global Atmospheric Reanalysis(CMA-RA)and the ECMWF Reanalysis v5(ERA5)in representing 2-m air temperature(T_(a))and surface temperature(T_(s))against in-situ observations from a total of 1658 buoys of the International Arctic Buoy Programme(IABP)and Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory of the United States(CRREL)during 2001-2024.The results demonstrate strong consistency between the two reanalysis products and buoy observations,with correlation coefficients(R)of≥0.94 for T_(a) and≥0.88 for T_(s) in reproducing seasonal and interannual variations.For T_(a),CMA-RA outperforms ERA5 under extreme cold conditions but exhibits a cold bias in long-term simulations(-0.30±1.50℃),whereas ERA5 shows a warm bias(1.13±2.28℃).Both CMA-RA and ERA5 yield high correlations with buoy observations across Arctic subregions.For T_(s),both CMA-RA(-4.15±3.55℃)and ERA5(-2.52±3.21℃)display cold biases,with the largest deviations occurring in winter(<-4℃)and the smallest in summer(>-1.6℃).The relatively higher T_(s) observed by buoys reveals consistent cold biases in CMA-RA and ERA5,suggesting that model physics,surface parameterizations,and data assimilation strategies jointly contribute to these systematic discrepancies.This study provides a comprehensive spatial evaluation and a relatively long continuous temporal assessment of the performance of CMA-RA and ERA5 over the Arctic to date.
Yue CUI;Yining YU;Jiechen ZHAO;Xueqin LIU;Jiajia JIA;Xiaowei ZOU;Biao TIAN;Minghu DING
College of Underwater Acoustic Engineering,Harbin Engineering University,Harbin 150001 State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081First Institute of Oceanography,Ministry of Natural Resources,Qingdao 266400College of Underwater Acoustic Engineering,Harbin Engineering University,Harbin 150001State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081 School of Geodesy and Geomatics,Wuhan University,Wuhan 430079State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081State Key Laboratory of Severe Weather Meteorological Science and Technology(LaSW),Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences,China Meteorological Administration,Beijing 100081 Key Laboratory of Polar Atmosphere-Ocean-Ice System for Weather and Climate,Ministry of Education,Shanghai 200438
天文与地球科学
Arcticreanalysis evaluationbuoy observations2-m air temperaturesurface temperatureChina Meteorological Administration Global Atmospheric Reanalysis(CMA-RA)
《Journal of Meteorological Research》 2026 (4)
P.1348-1366,19
Supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China(2022YFC2807204 and 2021YFC2802504)National Natural Science Foundation of China(42122047 and 42105036)Basic Research Fund of Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences(2023Z015,2023Z004,and 2023Z025)。
评论