不稳定性心绞痛虚瘀毒证量化诊断专家共识研究OA
Research on Establishing Quantitative Diagnostic Consensus for Deficiency-Stasis-Toxin Syndrome in Unstable Angina
目的 梳理不稳定性心绞痛(UA)虚瘀毒证的证候特点和临床症状,筛选UA虚瘀毒证的核心诊断条目,构建UA虚瘀毒证量化诊断专家共识.方法 通过古今文献研究和专家访谈确立UA虚瘀毒证诊断条目池.通过德尔菲法专家咨询,基于重要性评价对条目池进行筛选,并通过主成分分析对条目进行量化赋权.通过诊断性试验确定诊断阈值,并验证诊断效能.结果 文献研究归纳出条目111条,专家访谈提出条目92条,经归纳整理后,初步构建UA虚瘀毒证诊断条目池90条.通过对两轮专家问卷调查结果的统计分析,筛选出共识条目33条,包括主症14条,次症19条.结合调整后的权重得分,最终形成UA虚瘀毒证量化诊断专家共识.诊断性试验确定诊断阈值为64.6,约登指数最大为0.586.共识的诊断敏感度为82.26%,特异度为76.32%,准确度为80%.共识涵盖疾病相关表现、临床症状、辅助检查指标及舌脉,以病证结合量化诊断形式呈现,即临床需要符合UA的诊断标准,且满足至少1条主症和至少1条次症,得分≥64.6分者,则可诊断为UA虚瘀毒证.结论 UA虚瘀毒证量化诊断专家共识具有良好的诊断效能,能够为临床实践提供有效参考.
Objective To clarify the syndrome characteristics and clinical manifestations of the deficiency-stasis-toxin syndrome in unstable angina(UA),identify core diagnostic criteria for this syndrome,ultimately establish Quantitative Diagnostic Consensus for Deficiency-Stasis-Toxin Syndrome in UA.Methods The diagnostic item pool for UA deficiency-stasis-toxin syndrome was established through the study of ancient and modern literature and expert interviews.The Delphi method was used to screen the item pool based on the evaluation of importance.Principal component analysis was used to determine the initial weight score of each item.Diagnostic trials were conducted to determine diagnostic threshold,and the diagnostic efficacy was verified.Results Totally 111 items were extracted from the literature,and 92 items were proposed by expert interviews.A preliminary diagnostic item pool of 90 entries for deficiency-stasis-toxin syndrome in UA was established after summarization and organization.Through statistical analysis of two rounds of expert questionnaire results,33 consensus items were selected,including 14 primary symptoms and 19 secondary symptoms.Combined with adjusted weight scores,the final Quantitative Diagnostic Consensus for Deficiency-Stasis-Toxin Syndrome in UA was established.The maximum Youden index was 0.586,and the diagnostic threshold was 64.6 by a diagnostic trial.The diagnostic sensitivity of the consensus was 82.26%,specificity was 76.32%,accuracy was 80%.The consensus included disease-related manifestations,clinical symptoms,auxiliary examination indicators and tongue and pulse,and was presented in a disease-syndrome integration quantitative diagnostic format:the diagnostic criteria of UA,at least one main symptom and at least one secondary symptom,and the score ≥ 64.6,the deficiency-stasis-toxin syndrome of UA can be diagnosed.Conclusion Diagnostic Consensus for Deficiency-Stasis-Toxin Syndrome in UA has been validated to demonstrate favorable diagnostic performance,providing effective guidance for clinical practice.
刘昕怡;张晓囡;袁永芳;李晓雅;吴敏;李运伦;李亮;郭家娟;刘龙涛
中国中医科学院西苑医院心血管病中心,国家中医心血管病临床医学研究中心(北京 100091)中国中医科学院西苑医院心血管病中心,国家中医心血管病临床医学研究中心(北京 100091)中国中医科学院西苑医院心血管病中心,国家中医心血管病临床医学研究中心(北京 100091)中国中医科学院广安门医院心血管科(北京 100053)中国中医科学院广安门医院心血管科(北京 100053)山东中医药大学附属医院心病科(济南 250011)广东省中山市中医院老年病科(广东 528401)长春中医药大学附属医院心病一科(长春 130021)中国中医科学院西苑医院心血管病中心,国家中医心血管病临床医学研究中心(北京 100091)||中国中医科学院广安门医院心血管科(北京 100053)
不稳定性心绞痛虚瘀毒证量化诊断德尔菲法诊断标准
unstable anginadeficiency-stasis-toxin syndromequantitative diagnosisDelphi methoddiagnostic criteria
《中国中西医结合杂志》 2026 (8)
901-908,8
中国中医科学院西苑医院提升中医药临床循证证据级别研究专项(No.XYZX0201-09)中国中医科学院科技创新工程项目(No.CI2026A00910)首都卫生发展科研专项(No.首发2024-2-4154)
评论