石菖蒲与其混淆品山柰菖蒲的"表型-化学-分子"多技术融合鉴别研究OA
Multi-technique integrated identification of Shichangpu(Acori Tatarinowii Rhizoma)and its adulterant Shannaichangpu(Acorus shannai C.L.Long&Z.Cheng)using a"phenotype-chemistry-molecular"approach
目的 建立石菖蒲与其近缘混淆品山柰菖蒲(茴香菖蒲)"表型-化学-分子"多技术融合鉴别方法,突破传统性状鉴别的局限性.方法 收集两种性状特征相似的石菖蒲饮片样品(颜色稍浅、气芳香者,以及颜色稍红、气茴香样特异者),依次开展表型层次(性状鉴别、显微鉴别)、化学层次(薄层色谱、水分、总灰分、浸出物、挥发油、特征图谱及含量测定)与分子层次(DNA条形码,ITS2 序列)的系统研究,建立逐层递进的融合鉴别流程.结果 在表型层次中,两者在直径、断面颜色、气味、淀粉粒类型及草酸钙方晶大小等方面存在差异,但难以作为确证性依据.在化学层次中,两者化学成分图谱差异显著:石菖蒲样品以β-细辛醚(0.70%~1.25%)为主,草蒿脑含量极低(<0.01%);山柰菖蒲样品则以草蒿脑(0.30%~0.60%)为主要成分,β-细辛醚含量极低.在分子层次中,DNA条形码鉴定确认石菖蒲样品为石菖蒲(Acorus tatarinowii Schott),山柰菖蒲样品为山柰菖蒲(Acorus shannai C.L.Long&Z.Cheng).结论 所建立的"表型-化学-分子"多技术融合法可准确鉴别石菖蒲及其混淆品山柰菖蒲,其流程为表型初筛、化学比值(草蒿脑/β-细辛醚)判别、分子确证,逐层递进.建议企业采购验收时采用此流程,以保障基原准确与质量安全.
Objective To establish a"phenotype-chemistry-molecular"multi-technique integrated identification method for distinguishing Shichangpu(Acori Tatarinowii Rhizoma)from its closely related adulterant Shannaichangpu(Acorus shannai C.L.Long&Z.Cheng,also known as Huixiangchangpu),thereby overcoming the limitations of traditional macroscopic identification.Methods Two types of Shichangpu(Acori Tatarinowii Rhizoma)decoction piece samples with similar macroscopic characteristics were collected:Type I(slightly lighter in color,with an aromatic odor)and Type II(slightly reddish in color,with a fennel-like distinctive odor).A systematic study was conducted sequentially across three levels—phenotypic(macroscopic and microscopic identification),chemical(thin-layer chromatography,moisture content,total ash,extractives,volatile oil content,characteristic chromatographic profiles,and quantitative determination),and molecular(DNA barcoding using the ITS2 sequence)—to establish a progressive,multi-technique integrated identification procedure.Results At the phenotypic level,differences were observed between the two groups of samples in diameter,cross-section color,odor,starch grain type,and the size of calcium oxalate prisms;however,these characteristics were insufficient for definitive identification.At the chemical level,significant differences were found in the chemical constituent profiles:Type I samples contained β-asarone as the predominant constituent(0.70%~1.25%),with extremely low estragole content(<0.01%);Type II samples,in contrast,contained estragole as the predominant constituent(0.30%~0.60%),with extremely low β-asarone content.At the molecular level,DNA barcoding confirmed that Type I samples originated from Shichangpu(Acori Tatarinowii Rhizoma),while Type II samples originated from Shannaichangpu(Acorus shannai C.L.Long&Z.Cheng).Conclusion The established"phenotype-chemistry-molecular"multi-technique integrated identification method can accurately distinguish Shichangpu(Acori Tatarinowii Rhizoma)from its adulterant Shannaichangpu(Acorus shannai C.L.Long&Z.Cheng).The procedure progresses sequentially from preliminary phenotypic screening to discrimination based on the estragole/β-asarone ratio and finally to molecular confirmation.Enterprises are advised to adopt this procedure during procurement and acceptance inspection to ensure the authenticity of the botanical origin and the quality and safety of the medicinal material.
石凤姣;刘丰;王冰;艾钰;景雨纯
国药集团中联药业有限公司,湖北 武汉 430000国药集团广东环球制药有限公司,广东 佛山 528300||中国中药控股有限公司,广东 佛山 528000国药集团中联药业有限公司,湖北 武汉 430000国药集团中联药业有限公司,湖北 武汉 430000国药集团中联药业有限公司,湖北 武汉 430000
医药卫生
石菖蒲山柰菖蒲多技术融合DNA条形码
Shichangpu(Acori Tatarinowii Rhizoma)Shannaichangpu(Acorus shannai C.L.Long&Z.Cheng)multi-technique integrated identificationDNA barcoding
《药食同源杂志》 2026 (8)
721-728,8
评论