体育规则技术性治理的伦理风险与规制策略OACHSSCD
Ethical Risks and Regulatory Strategies in the Technical Governance of Sports Rules
为揭示体育规则技术性治理的演进逻辑及其伴生的伦理风险,本研究以沙滩排球为典型案例,以2001-2025年国际排球联合会发布的沙滩排球竞赛规则与视频挑战系统规则为研究语料,从技术政治论、共生产理论、程序正义理论与公平技术论4个视角进行考察.研究认为,体育规则技术性治理是以可量化参数、封闭性程序与技术装置管控竞赛不确定性的规范实践,其演进图谱呈现参数化、程序化、证据化的递进特征.在提升比赛管理效率与裁决一致性的同时,该过程引发四重伦理风险:公平实现方式的条件化偏移、裁判主体性与权威来源的结构性重构、程序正义的解释断层与救济真空,以及数据生产的责任边界扩张与权利真空.据此提出以"责任嵌入"为核心的规制策略:在规则制定层将责任分配作为条款设计的前置约束,在技术运行层将人机分工与技术不确定性制度化,在救济监督层构建技术裁决的问责与救济机制,在数据治理层锚定数据责任边界与填补权利真空,使技术治理真正服务于竞技体育的制度目标.
To elucidate the evolutionary logic of sports rules'technical governance and its concomitant ethical risks,this study takes beach volleyball as a paradigmatic case.Drawing on the Beach Volleyball Rules and the Video Challenge System Rules issued by the Fédération Internationale de Volleyball(FIVB)from 2001 to 2025,the analysis integrates theoretical frameworks of techno-politics,co-production,procedural justice,and technological fairness.The study conceptualizes this governance as a normative practice mitigating competitive uncertainty via quantifiable parameters,closed procedures,and technological apparatuses,with an evolutionary trajectory marked by sequential parameterization,proceduralization,and evidentialization.While enhancing managerial efficiency and adjudicative consistency,this paradigm precipitates four ethical perils:conditional deviations in the realization of fairness;structural reconfigurations of arbitral subjectivity and authority;interpretive and remedial gaps in procedural justice;and expanding liability boundaries alongside rights vacuums in data production.Accordingly,regulatory strategies centered on"responsibility embedding"are proposed:at the rule-making level,positioning responsibility allocation as a prerequisite constraint for clause design;at the technological operational level,institutionalizing the human-machine division of labor and technological uncertainty;at the supervisory and remedial level,constructing accountability and relief mechanisms for technical adjudication;at the data governance level,anchoring data responsibility boundaries and filling rights vacuums,thereby ensuring that technical governance genuinely serves the institutional goals of competitive sports.
王太林
中北大学 体育学院,山西 太原 030051
社会科学
体育规则规则技术性治理沙滩排球伦理风险规制策略
sports ruletechnical governance of rulebeach volleyballethical riskregulatory strategy
《沈阳体育学院学报》 2026 (4)
86-92,7
国家社会科学基金一般项目"当代竞技体育的伦理问题及其治理研究"(23BTY046).
评论