三度归因理论视角下信息弱势群体算法素养影响因素研究OACHSSCD
Research on the Algorithmic Literacy Influencing Factors of Information Vulnerable Groups From the Perspective of Three-Dimensional Attribution Theory
[目的/意义]识别信息弱势群体算法素养影响因素,为评估中国信息弱势群体算法素养现状提供参考,有助于中国提升针对信息弱势群体的信息服务水平,有效缩小算法环境下的数字鸿沟.[方法/过程]以三度归因理论为支撑,通过文献检索和深度访谈获得原始数据,使用扎根理论方法提取信息弱势群体算法素养影响因素指标体系,运用DEMATEL方法识别关键影响因素,并通过ISM方法分析因素之间的内在关系与作用路径.[结果/结论]分析表明,算法使用效能、算法控制能力、算法信任、算法依赖、算法安全担忧是对信息弱势群体算法素养影响最大的因素.隐私保护能力、算法存在感知、算法透明度、算法可解释性、算法易用性、算法复杂性等12个因素为表层因素,对算法素养产生直接影响;设备操作能力、算法风险意识、政策支持环境、算法功能适配性等9个因素为中层因素;算法逻辑理解、信息检索能力、算法控制能力、算法信任4个因素为深层因素,进而从用户主体能动性、算法设计和环境保障3个方面提出对策建议.
[Purpose/Significance]Identifying the influencing factors of algorithm literacy among information disadvan-taged groups provides a reference basis for assessing the current status of algorithm literacy among such groups in China.This is conducive to improving the information service level for information disadvantaged groups in China and effectively narrowing the digital divide in the algorithm environment.[Methods/Process]Based on the three-dimensional attribution theory,this paper obtained raw data through literature retrieval and in-depth interviews.Using the grounded theory,the paper extracted the index system of influencing factors of algorithm literacy among information disadvantaged groups.On this basis,this study employed the DEMATEL method to identify the key influencing factors,and the ISM method to ana-lyze the internal relationships and action paths among the factors.[Result/Conclusion]The analysis shows that algorithm usage efficiency,algorithm control ability,algorithm trust,algorithm dependence,and algorithm security concerns are the factors that have the greatest impact on the algorithm literacy of information disadvantaged groups.Privacy protection abi-lity,algorithm existence perception,algorithm transparency,algorithm explainability,algorithm usability,algorithm com-plexity,and other 12 factors are surface-level factors that have a direct impact on algorithm literacy;device operation abi-lity,algorithm risk awareness,policy support environment,algorithm function adaptability,and other 9 factors are middle-level factors;algorithm logic understanding,information retrieval ability,algorithm control ability,and algorithm trust are 4 deep-level factors.Furthermore,this study proposes countermeasures and suggestions from three aspects:user subject initiative,algorithm design and environmental guarantee.
孟玺;高通;尚硕;李庆霜;王玥;郭亚军
中国人民公安大学国家安全学院,北京 100038中国人民公安大学国家安全学院,北京 100038中国人民公安大学国家安全学院,北京 100038中国人民公安大学国家安全学院,北京 100038中国人民公安大学国家安全学院,北京 100038北京语言大学信息科学学院,北京 100083
社会科学
信息弱势群体算法素养影响因素DEMATEL-ISM扎根理论老年人
information vulnerable groupsalgorithmic literacyinfluencing factorsDEMATEL-ISMgrounded theoryelderly
《现代情报》 2026 (9)
116-128,13
国家社会科学基金重大项目"政务数据赋能数字政府效能提升的机制与路径研究"(项目编号:25&ZD218).
评论