从答案裁定到思维建构:小学英语课堂评价的转型阻滞与突破路径OA
From Answer Judgment to Thinking Development:Obstacles and Breakthroughs in the Transformation of Primary English Classroom Assessment
课堂评价影响学生的学习方向与思维品质.在核心素养导向的课程改革背景下,小学英语课堂评价需要从传统的"答案裁定"取向转向对学生思维过程的关注与建构.基于20 节小学英语常态课与公开课的课堂观察及对20 位教师和教研员的深度访谈,采用主题分析法进行三级编码分析,研究发现,"答案裁定"取向表现为教师依据标准化练习通过对错核验组织课堂反馈;"思维建构"取向体现为教师通过精细化追问、针对性点评以及项目式任务的生成性评价引导学生呈现和发展思维过程.当前评价转型面临四重阻滞:认知性阻滞体现为教师理念认同与现实考量的割裂;专业性阻滞体现为评价话语设计与实施能力不足;现实性阻滞体现为课时紧张与学情分化;制度性阻滞体现为"表演性"评价与"生存性"评价的双轨固化.针对上述阻滞,可构建四条协同突破路径:以实证教研推进认知纠偏,以思维引导语料库与评价工具支持专业赋能,以微评价与分层指引实现实践调适,以常态课中思维可见的制度与文化推动制度重塑.
Classroom assessment directly shapes students'learning orientation and thinking quality.Against the backdrop of competence-oriented curriculum reform,primary English classroom assessment needs to shift from the traditional"answer judgment"orientation toward the construction of students'thinking processes.Based on classroom observations of 20 regular and open primary English lessons and in-depth interviews with 20 teachers and researchers,the study employed thematic analysis with a three-level coding procedure.The findings reveal that the"answer judgment"orientation is characterized by teachers'immediate checking of answers based on standardized exercises and providing simple right-or-wrong feedback.In contrast,the"thinking development"orientation is reflected in teachers'detailed questioning of students'thinking processes,targeted comments on the logic of information organization,and formative assessment integrated into project-based learning.The transformation currently faces four interrelated obstacles:the cognitive obstacle manifested as a gap between teachers'conceptual recognition and their practical considerations;the professional obstacle manifested as insufficient competence in designing assessment discourse and implementing higher-order tasks;the practical obstacle manifested as tight class schedules and differentiated student proficiency levels;and the institutional obstacle manifested as the rigid dual coexistence of"performative assessment"in open classes and"survival-oriented assessment"in regular lessons.To address these obstacles,four corresponding breakthrough pathways can be constructed:advancing cognitive correction through practice-oriented teaching research;supporting professional empowerment with thinking-guided language corpora and assessment tools;achieving practical adaptation via micro-assessment strategies and tiered task design;and securing institutional reshaping through a culture and evaluation system that makes thinking visible in regular lessons.
叶蓓蓓;胡玉婷;王跃
广西师范大学教育学部广西师范大学教育学部广西师范大学教育学部(广西 桂林 541004)
社会科学
小学英语课堂评价答案裁定思维建构评价转型
primary Englishclassroom assessmentanswer judgmentthinking develop-mentassessment transformation
《天津市教科院学报》 2026 (3)
65-78,14
中国青少年研究会研究课题"中国式现代化进程中少年儿童精神素养'五育共生'路径研究"(2025B86).
评论