基于行为与神经生理证据支持的经颅直流电刺激与计算机认知训练协同增强孤独症谱系障碍疗效的随机对照OA
Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Combined with Computerized Cognitive Training Synergistically Enhances Efficacy in Autism Spectrum Disorder:A Randomized Controlled Trial Based on Behavioral and Neurophysiological Evidence
目的 探讨经颅直流电刺激(transcranial direct current stimulation,tDCS)联合计算机认知训练(computerized cognitive training,CCT)治疗孤独症谱系障碍(autism spectrum disorder,ASD)的疗效.方法 选取2021年1月至2024年8月深圳市龙岗区妇幼保健院收治的208例ASD患儿,按照随机数表法分为CCT组(n=52)、tDCS组(n=52)、研究组(n=52)、假刺激组(n=52).4组均给予常规康复治疗措施,在此基础上,CCT组给予CCT,tDCS组给予tDCS,研究组给予tDCS联合CCT,假刺激组给予假tDCS联合CCT.比较4组治疗效果、治疗前后儿童孤独症评定量表(childhood autism rating scale,CARS)、异常行为量表(aberrant behavior checklist,ABC)、相关发育障碍儿童心理教育量表-3(chinese version of the psychoeducational profile,third edition,C-PEP-3)、儿童神经心理行为检查量表评分、脑电图指标[fz、cz导联失匹配负波(mismatch negativity,MMN)潜伏期和波幅、额叶θ相对功率、睡眠期放电指数]以及不良反应发生率.结果 4组治疗有效率整体比较,差异无统计学意义(x2=6.811,P=0.078);治疗3个月后,研究组ABC量表中躯体运动、语言、感觉、交往、生活自理维度评分与CARS总评分低于CCT组、tDCS组、假刺激组,C-PEP-3总评分与儿心量表中语言、社交行为、发育商、智龄、适应能力、大运动、精细动作评分维度评分高于CCT组、tDCS组、假刺激组(F=7.575、14.741、7.616、6.817、6.896、21.804、12.175、13.034、17.661、11.925、12.690、9.691、8.777、13.485,P<0.05),CCT组、tDCS组与假刺激组ABC量表各维度评分、CARS评分、C-PEP-3评分、儿心量表各维度评分比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);治疗3个月后,研究组Fz导联、Cz导联MMN潜伏期、额叶θ相对功率、睡眠期放电指数低于CCT组、tDCS组、假刺激组,Fz导联、Cz导联MMN波幅高于CCT组、tDCS组、假刺激组(F=15.593、12.714、12.072、48.912、6.901、5.723,P<0.05),CCT组、tDCS组与假刺激组 Fz 导联、Cz导联MMN潜伏期和波幅、额叶θ相对功率、睡眠期放电指数比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);4组不良反应总发生率比较,差异无统计学意义(P=0.123).结论 tDCS联合CCT治疗ASD疗效显著,可能改善患儿认知、社交功能及异常行为,改善其脑电活动.
Objective To investigate the efficacy of transcranial direct current stimulation(tDCS)combined with computerized cognitive training(CCT)in treating autism spectrum disorder(ASD).Methods A total of 208 children with ASD admitted to Longgang District Maternal and Child Health Hospital,Shenzhen from January 2021 to August 2024 were selected,and randomly divided into four groups using a random number table:CCT group(n=52),tDCS group(n=52),combination group(n=52),and sham stimulation group(n=52).All four groups received standard rehabilitation treatment.Additionally,the CCT group received CCT,the tDCS group received tDCS,the combination group received tDCS combined with CCT,and the sham stimulation group received sham tDCS combined with CCT.Therapeutic efficacy,Childhood Autism Rating Scale(CARS),Aberrant Behavior Checklist(ABC),Chinese Version of Psychoeducational Profile-3(C-PEP-3),and Children's Neuro-psychological Behavioral Scale(abbreviated as China Children Development Scale)scores,electroence-phalographic parameters[latency and amplitude of mismatch negativity(MMN)at Fz and Cz leads,frontal lobe relative θ power,sleep discharge index]before and after treatment,and the incidence of adverse reactions were compared among the four groups.Results The overall therapeutic efficacy rate showed no significant difference among the four groups(x2=6.811,P=0.078).After 3 months of treatment,the combination group showed significantly lower scores on ABC scale dimensions(somatic motor,language,sensory,social interaction,self-care)and CARS total scores compared with the CCT,tDCS,and sham stimulation groups,and significantly higher C-PEP-3 total scores and Child Neuropsychological Behavior Examination Scale scores in language,social behavior,developmental quotient,mental age,adaptive ability,gross motor,and fine motor dimensions compared with the other three groups(F=7.575,14.741,7.616,6.817,6.896,21.804,12.175,13.034,17.661,11.925,12.690,9.691,8.777,13.485,P<0.05).No significant differences were found among the CCT,tDCS,and sham stimulation groups in ABC dimensions,CARS scores,C-PEP-3 scores,or Child Neuropsychological Behavior Examination Scale dimensions(P>0.05).After 3 months of treatment,the combination group showed significantly lower MMN latency in Fz and Cz leads,relative frontal theta power,and sleep discharge index,and significantly higher MMN amplitude in Fz and Cz leads compared with the other three groups(F=15.593,12.714,12.072,48.912,6.901,5.723,P<0.05).No significant differences were found among the CCT,tDCS,and sham stimulation groups in these EEG parameters(P>0.05).The overall incidence of adverse reactions showed no significant difference among the four groups(P=0.123).Conclusion tDCS combined with CCT demonstrates significant therapeutic efficacy in treating ASD,potentially improving cognitive and social functioning,reducing aberrant behaviors,and improving cerebral electrical activity in affected children.
杨顺波;赖燕媚;李庆红;杨金狄;吕智海
深圳市龙岗区妇幼保健院儿童康复科,广东 深圳 518000深圳市龙岗区妇幼保健院儿童康复科,广东 深圳 518000深圳市龙岗区妇幼保健院儿童康复科,广东 深圳 518000深圳市龙岗区妇幼保健院儿童康复科,广东 深圳 518000深圳市龙岗区妇幼保健院儿童康复科,广东 深圳 518000
医药卫生
经颅直流电刺激计算机认知训练孤独症谱系障碍脑电图失匹配负波
Transcranial direct current stimulationComputerized cognitive trainingAutism spectrum disorderElectroencephalogramMismatched negative waves
《昆明医科大学学报》 2026 (8)
137-145,9
广东省医学科研基金(A20210353)
评论