粤港澳大湾区可信医疗数据空间的协同治理路径:从形式合规到实质等价OA
Collaborative Governance Path of Trusted Medical Data Spaces in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area:From Formal Compliance to Substantive Equivalence
粤港澳大湾区可信医疗数据空间的建设并非单纯的技术工程,而是技术架构与法律秩序相互塑造的社会技术过程.针对目前粤港澳大湾区医疗数据跨境流通的系统性法律研究明显不足问题,区别于传统解释学,将可信医疗数据空间这一新兴的技术与社会产物纳入既有民事法律体系的规制视野,回到再识别风险的可实现性、防护体系的可验证性与风险分布的实质变化这3项要素,兼顾技术事实与法益价值;基于科学技术与社会的功能主义视角,主张以医疗数据不可逆的人格权法益为逻辑起点,对该空间内的民事责任进行场景化重构.本文聚焦三项递进的核心议题:首先,就责任主体而言,鉴于平台技术架构本身已具备规制属性,应以"可支配性-技术控制-收益归属"为轴心,确立与其相称的注意义务;其次,就违法性判断而言,摒弃对匿名化、同意授权及数据出境的形式化门槛审查,全面转向以"功能与风险等价"为核心的实质评价;再次,就救济实现而言,针对受害人与平台间的技术势差,提出辅以宽松的举证责任配置.针对粤港澳大湾区"一国两制三法域"的法律冲突,提出以功能等价的分步认定协调三地共同侵权标准.综上,应对当前的现实需求,应确立"法解释在前探路、立法在后定型"的渐进策略;通过法律规则与技术架构的双向校准,构建起超越单一法域的协同治理框架,以全面释放可信医疗数据空间的技术治理潜能,最终实现粤港澳大湾区医疗数据安全可控与高效融通.
The construction of trusted medical data spaces in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area(GBA)is not merely a technical engineering project,but a socio-technical process in which technical architecture and legal order shape each other.In response to the evident lack of systematic legal research on cross-border medical data circulation in the GBA,this paper—differing from traditional hermeneutics—introduces the emerging technological and social construct of a trustworthy medical data spaces into the regulatory framework of existing civil law.It focuses on three key elements:the feasibility of re-identification risks,the verifiability of protection mechanisms,and substantive changes in risk distribution,while balancing technical realities with legal interests.From a functionalist perspective of the theory of science,technology and society,it argues for taking the irreversible personality rights and interests of medical data as the logical starting point to reconstruct civil liability within this space in a scenario-based manner.It focuses on three progressive core issues:First,regarding the responsible subjects,since the platform's technical architecture already possesses regulatory attributes,the duty of care commensurate with it should be established with"controllability-technical control-benefit attribution"as the axis.Second,regarding the judgment of illegality,the formal threshold review of anonymization,consent authorization,and data export should be abandoned in favor of a comprehensive shift toward a substantive evaluation centered on"functional and risk equivalence."Third,regarding the realization of remedies,it proposes a relatively lenient allocation of the burden of proof.In view of the legal conflicts under the GBA's"one country,two systems,three jurisdictions"principle,it suggests coordinating the joint tort standards across the three regions through a step-by-step determination based on functional equivalence.In summary,to meet current practical needs,a gradual strategy of"legal interpretation to explore the path,followed by legislative finalization"should be established,and then through bidirectional calibration between legal rules and technical architecture,a collaborative governance framework that transcends a single jurisdiction should be constructed,fully unleashing the technological governance potential of trusted medical spaces,and ultimately realizing the secure,controllable,and efficient integration of medical data in the GBA.
陈靖怡;李雪松
澳门大学法学院,澳门 999078日本明治大学比较法研究所,东京1018301
管理科学
可信医疗数据空间数据安全数据出境科学技术与社会粤港澳大湾区
trusted medical data spacesdata securitydata exportscience,technology,and societylegal hermeneuticsGuangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area
《科技创新发展战略研究》 2026 (4)
78-90,13
澳门大学博士资助计划项目(YC372192)
评论