临时性使用的概念谱系、理论转向与研究议程OACHSSCD
The Conceptual Pedigree,Theoretical Shifts,and Research Agenda of Temporary Use
在存量更新与精细化治理背景下,临时性使用因其低成本、可逆性与实验性特征,逐渐成为城市有机更新的重要实践方式.综合采用系统综述、概念比较分析与CiteSpace文献计量辅助验证等方法,对临时性使用研究的核心概念谱系与理论演进进行系统性梳理.研究发现,该领域经历了三个相互关联的理论转向,即从"城市问题"到"城市触媒"的价值重估,从"自发实践"到"战术实验"的方法论化,以及从"局部介入"到"战略治理"的制度化.基于"实践背景—概念涌现—理论转向"的分析逻辑,构建"时间取向、治理取向、行动逻辑"的三维术语定位框架,并识别出"临时与永久""自下而上与自上而下""空间激活与绅士化"三组结构性张力.认为临时性使用研究亟须从类型归纳和经验描述转向机制解释,重点揭示其触媒效应的生成路径、作用条件与制度边界,从而为城市存量更新中的弹性治理提供更具解释力的理论框架.
Against the backdrop of regenerating existing urban fabrics and improving governance,temporary use has emerged as an important approach to urban organic regeneration due to its low-cost,reversibility,and experimental nature.This paper adopts an integrated methodology combining a systematic literature review,compara-tive conceptual analysis,and CiteSpace-assisted bibliometric validation to examine the conceptual genealogy and theoretical evolution of research on temporary use.The findings indicate that this field has undergone three interrelated theoretical shifts:a reassessment of temporary use from an"urban problem"to an"urban cata-lyst";a methodological transition from"spontaneous practice"to"tactical experi-ment";and an institutional shift from"local intervention"to"strategic governance".Following the analytical framework of"practical context-conceptual emergence-theoretical evolution",the paper develops a three-dimensional terminological system organized around temporal orientation,governance orientation,and action logic.It fur-ther identifies three sets of structural tensions:temporary versus permanent,bottom-up versus top-down,and spatial activation versus gentrification.This paper argues that research on temporary use should move beyond typological classification and de-scriptive case studies toward mechanism-based explanation,with particular attention to revealing the formation pathways,operating conditions,and institutional boundar-ies of its catalytic effects.In doing so,it provides a better explanatory theoretical framework for understanding flexible governance in urban organic regeneration.
马宏;伍江
同济大学建筑与城市规划学院||上海市城市规划设计研究院同济大学建筑与城市规划学院||法国建筑科学院||同济大学超大城市精细化治理研究院
建筑与水利
临时性使用概念谱系理论转向城市有机更新研究议程
temporary useconceptual Pedigreetheoretical Shifturban or-ganic renewalresearch agenda
《城市规划学刊》 2026 (3)
63-71,9
评论