首页|期刊导航|北京中医药大学学报|"体脏合痹"理论视角下干燥病病机演变规律与分层防治研究

"体脏合痹"理论视角下干燥病病机演变规律与分层防治研究OA

Pathomechanistic evolution rule and stratified management of Sjögren's disease from the perspective of"Bi of both body and viscera"

中文摘要英文摘要

目的 基于"体脏合痹"理论,探究干燥病的临床亚型与病机演变规律,为临床防治本病提供客观化依据.方法 收集2023 年6 月1 日—2025 年6 月30 日于中国中医风湿病注册研究信息平台数据库首次登记注册的545 例干燥病患者的一般资料(性别、发病年龄、诊断年龄、病程),中医证候类型,实验室指标,欧洲抗风湿病联盟干燥综合征患者报告指数(ESSPRI),欧洲抗风湿病联盟干燥综合征疾病活动指数(ESSDAI)、疾病活动度及系统受累情况.基于临床意义,预先确定 24 个聚类变量,包括性别,诊断年龄,中医证候类型,ESSPRI 中 3 个域(干燥、疲劳、疼痛)评分,ESSDAI中12 个系统域是否受累,免疫球蛋白 G(IgG)水平分层,补体 C4 是否降低,类风湿因子(RF)水平分层,抗干燥综合征 A(SSA)抗体、抗干燥综合征 B(SSB)抗体及抗着丝点抗体阳性率.采用多重对应分析(MCA)和层次聚类识别干燥病的临床亚型.基于"体脏合痹"理论,结合不同亚型的体窍受累、脏腑受累、证候类型及免疫学特点,阐释其病位层次与病机传变特征,并将其分别命名为体痹型、体脏合痹型和脏痹型;进一步比较不同亚型患者的临床特征、证候分布、ESSPRI、ESSDAI 及实验室指标的差异.根据基线病程将患者分组,比较不同病程各组临床亚型的构成比例.以首次登记日期为起点进行 18 个月随访,记录新增腺外受累事件及其发生时间,采用 Kaplan-Meier 方法分析不同亚型新增腺外受累的无事件生存情况.结果 545 例干燥病患者基于 MCA 和层次聚类分为体痹型(n=150)、体脏合痹型(n=254)和脏痹型(n=141).体痹型以体窍受累为主,表现为ESSPRI 高于体脏合痹型患者,而ESSDAI 低于其他2 种亚型患者(P<0.05),证候以阴虚津亏、燥湿互结为主,且病程相对较短.体脏合痹型表现为体窍损伤和脏腑轻度受累并存,ESSPRI 低于其它2 种亚型患者,而 ESSDAI 高于体痹型、低于脏痹型(P<0.05),并表现出以IgG 升高、RF 高水平为主的B 细胞活化特征,证候以气阴两虚、燥瘀互结及燥湿互结证为主,病程较长.脏痹型以多脏器、多系统受累为主要特征,ESSPRI 疲劳评分和 ESSDAI 均高于其他2 种亚型患者(P<0.05),伴有血沉加快及补体C4 降低(P<0.05),证候以燥瘀互结、阴虚内热为主,病程亦长于体痹型.不同亚型患者在一般资料、中医证候类型分布、ESSPRI、ESSDAI、系统受累及实验室指标方面差异均具有统计学意义(P<0.05).随着病程延长,体痹型比例呈下降趋势,脏痹型比例逐渐升高(P<0.05).不同亚型患者的无新增腺外受累生存率差异存在统计学意义,体脏合痹型患者的无新增腺外受累生存率较低(P<0.05).结论 在"体脏合痹"理论指导下,可将干燥病分为体痹型、体脏合痹型和脏痹型 3 种具有不同病机特征与进展阶段的临床亚型.该分型体现了干燥病由体及脏、由气入血的动态演变规律,有助于从"体-脏"关联视角认识干燥病临床异质性,可作为中西医结合分层防治的重要依据.

Objective To investigate the clinical subtypes and pathomechanistic evolution of Sjögren's disease(SjD)based on the traditional Chinese medicine theory of"Bi of both body and viscera,"and to provide objective evidence for clinical prevention and treatment.Methods Clinical data was collected from 545 patients with SjD who were newly registered in the China Rheumatology Registry Research Information Platform for Chinese Medicine between June 1,2023 and June 30,2025.The collected data included demographic characteristics,namely sex,age at onset,age at diagnosis,and disease duration;traditional Chinese medicine syndrome patterns;laboratory indicators;EULAR Sjögren' s Syndrome Patient Reported Index(ESSPRI);EULAR Sjögren's Syndrome Disease Activity Index(ESSDAI);and systemic involvement.A total of 24 clinically relevant variables were prespecified,including sex,age at diagnosis,traditional Chinese medicine syndrome patterns,the three ESSPRI domain scores for dryness,fatigue,and pain,involvement of the 12 ESSDAI systemic domains,immunoglobulin G(IgG)stratification,decreased C4,rheumatoid factor(RF)stratification,and positivity for anti-Sjögren' s syndrome-related antigen A(SSA)antibody,anti-Sjögren's syndrome-related antigen B(SSB)antibody,and anticentromere antibody.Multiple correspondence analysis(MCA)and hierarchical clustering were used to identify clinical subtypes of SjD.Based on the theory of"Bi of both body and viscera,"and in combination with body-orifice involvement,visceral involvement,syndrome patterns,and immunological characteristics of different subtypes,their disease-location hierarchy and pathomechanistic transmission features were interpreted and named as the body Bi subtype,Bi of both body and viscera subtype,and viscera Bi subtype.Clinical characteristics,syndrome distribution,ESSPRI,ESSDAI,and laboratory indicators were further compared among the subtypes.Patients were grouped according to baseline disease duration to compare the distribution of clinical subtypes across different disease-duration groups.Starting from the date of initial registration,patients were followed up for 18 months.Newly developed extraglandular involvement and time to event were recorded,and the Kaplan-Meier method was used to analyze event-free survival for newly developed extraglandular involvement among different subtypes.Results Based on MCA and hierarchical clustering,545 patients with SjD were classified into three clinical subtypes:body Bi subtype(n=150),Bi of both body and viscera subtype(n=254),and viscera Bi subtype(n=141).The body Bi subtype was mainly characterized by body-orifice involvement,with higher ESSPRI scores but lower ESSDAI scores(P<0.05).The predominant syndrome patterns were yin deficiency with fluid depletion and dryness-dampness interaction,and disease duration was relatively shorter.The Bi of both body and viscera subtype was characterized by the coexistence of body-orifice damage and mild visceral involvement,with lower ESSPRI scores but with ESSDAI scores higher than those of the body Bi subtype and lower than those of the viscera Bi subtype(P<0.05).This subtype also showed features of B-cell activation.The predominant syndrome patterns were dual deficiency of qi and yin,dryness-blood stasis interaction,and dryness-dampness interaction,and the disease duration was relatively longer.The viscera Bi subtype was mainly characterized by multi-organ and multisystem involvement,with higher ESSPRI fatigue domain scores and ESSDAI scores(P<0.05),accompanied by elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate and hypocomplementemia(P<0.05).The predominant syndrome patterns were dryness-blood stasis interaction and yin deficiency with internal heat,and disease duration was also longer than that of the body Bi subtype.Significant differences were observed among the three subtypes in demographic characteristics,distribution of traditional Chinese medicine syndrome patterns,ESSPRI,ESSDAI,systemic involvement,and laboratory indicators(P<0.05).As disease duration increased,the proportion of the body Bi subtype showed a decreasing trend,whereas the proportion of the viscera Bi subtype gradually increased(P<0.05).Event-free survival for newly developed extraglandular involvement differed significantly among the subtypes,with patients in the Bi of both body and viscera subtype showing a relatively lower event-free survival rate(P<0.05).Conclusion Guided by the theory of"Bi of both body and viscera,"SjD can be classified into three clinical subtypes with distinct pathomechanistic features and stages of disease progression:body Bi subtype,Bi of both body and viscera subtype,and viscera Bi subtype.This classification reflects the dynamic evolution of SjD from body involvement to visceral involvement and from the qi level to the blood level.It may help deepen the understanding of the clinical heterogeneity of SjD from the perspective of body-viscera interaction and serve as an important basis for stratified integrative prevention and treatment.

何加乐;周新尧;唐晓颇;姜泉

中国中医科学院广安门医院 北京 100053中国中医科学院广安门医院 北京 100053中国中医科学院广安门医院 北京 100053中国中医科学院广安门医院 北京 100053

医药卫生

干燥病体脏合痹演变规律层次聚类中国中医风湿病注册研究信息平台数据库

Sjögren's diseaseBi of both body and visceraevolution rulehierarchical clusteringChina Rheumatology Registry Research Information Platform for Chinese Medicine

《北京中医药大学学报》 2026 (7)

957-967,11

国家自然科学基金面上项目(No.82374285)中国中医科学院研究生科技创新项目(No.KC2025017)中国中医科学院科技创新工程(No.CI2026A01503,No.CI2021A01502)中央高水平中医医院临床科研业务费项目(No.HLCMHPP2023002) National Natural Science Foundation of China(No.82374285)

10.3969/j.issn.1006-2157.2026.07.009

评论