Quality assessment of integrated traditional Chinese and western medicine guidelines for dysmetabolism of glucose and lipid: based on AGREE Ⅱ and RIGHT toolsOA
Objective: To evaluate the methodological and reporting quality of integrated traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) and Western medicine guidelines addressing dysglycemia and dyslipidemia, thereby offering evidence-based recommendations for optimizing clinical decision-making in these conditions.Methods: A comprehensive literature search was conducted to identify clinical practiceguidelines(CPGs) for the management of dysglycemia and dyslipidemia. The search encompassed academic databases and specialized guideline repositories from their inception to December 31, 2024. Three researchers independently assessed the quality of the included CPGs using the AGREE II(Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation Ⅱ) and the RIGHT(Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Healthcare)checklist.Results: Based on the AGREE Ⅱ evaluation, the mean scores across the six domains were as follows: scope and purpose(91.8%),stakeholder involvement(81.7%), rigor of development(66.1%), clarity of presentation(96.0%), applicability(55.4%), and editorial independence(74.1%). Assessment using the RIGHT checklist yielded the following average reporting completeness rates for its seven domains: basic information(83.3%), background(69.3%), evidence(54.2%), recommendations(64.3%), review and quality assurance(39.6%), funding and declaration and management of interests(46.9%), and other aspects(41.7%).Conclusion: This study identified significant deficiencies in existing guidelines, particularly regarding methodological rigor,applicability, transparency of evidence reporting, funding disclosure, and clarification of future research priorities. To better inform clinical practice and improve treatment outcomes and quality of life for patients with dysglycemia and dyslipidemia, future efforts should prioritize developing a dedicated evaluation framework for integrated TCM-Western medicine guidelines, advancing the GRADE-TCM system to improve the translation and grading of TCM evidence, establishing multidisciplinary teams that integrate clinical expertise, evidence-based methodology, and health economics, and integrating cost-effectiveness analyses with patient preference assessments into the recommendation formulation process.
Yuqin Zhang;Yao Yang;Shaohua Wang;Xueliang Chen;Dezhao Kong;Qiuyue Huang;Hui Ye;Weiwei Li;Xuezhi Zhang
Department of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,ChinaDepartment of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University First Hospital,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Peking University,Beijing,China Institute of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,Beijing,China
医药卫生
dysglycemia and dyslipidemiaintegrated traditional Chinese and western medicineguidelineAGREEⅡRIGHTquality assessment
《Guideline and Standard in Chinese Medicine》 2026 (1)
P.16-28,13
National Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine Collaborative Chronic Disease Management Research Project(CXZH2024154)Traditional Chinese Medicine Inheritance and Innovation"Hundreds,Thousands,and Tens of Thousands"Talent Project(Qihuang Project)—National Leading Talent Support Program in Traditional Chinese Medicine[State TCM Personnel and Education Document(2022)No.6]Scientifc Research Project of Shanxi Provincial Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine(2024ZYY2C132)
评论