首页|期刊导航|热带地理|老旧小区改造优先级评估机制与决策支持研究

老旧小区改造优先级评估机制与决策支持研究OA

Priority Assessment and Decision Support Research for Old Residential Community Renovation:A Case Study of Hangzhou

中文摘要英文摘要

科学确定改造优先级是提升城镇老旧小区改造效能的关键.针对当前决策中存在的公众感知量化难、全域视角缺失等问题,文章以杭州市为例,提出一种数据驱动的优先级评估框架.该框架融合多源数据,结合图神经网络与大语言模型,分别实现小区建成年代识别与公众情绪量化,进而构建"问题紧迫性、实施可行性、潜在效益性"三维评估体系,并运用XGBoost模型进行综合优先级评估.结果表明:1)杭州市老旧小区改造优先级呈现显著的空间分异与尺度依赖特征,高优先级小区单元在主城区集中,但外围县域部分小区整体优先级更为突出;2)基于K-means空间聚类老旧小区及行政区的优先级类型,多维度剖析优先级空间分异格局,可为差异化改造政策制定提供参考;3)老旧小区改造需建立"分类改造、分区统筹"的协同治理机制,并注重环境品质与公众主观感受,从而实现空间公平与更新效能的动态平衡.通过构建"数据驱动、模型支撑、政策适配"的技术路径,既可通过定量方法保障老旧小区改造决策的科学性,又能以政策适配性提升方案落地的实操性.

In the context of China's urban transition from large-scale expansion to intensive regeneration,the establishment of a scientific priority assessment mechanism for the renovation of old residential communities has become a critical yet challenging task in urban governance.This study aimed to address the prevailing challenges in contemporary decision-making processes,including the complexity of quantifying public needs and the absence of a comprehensive city-wide perspective.To this end,a novel data-driven priority evaluation framework was proposed using an empirical case study of Hangzhou.Methodologically,this study introduces key innovations.First,a Graph Neural Network(GNN)model incorporating spatial semantics was developed in order to identify the construction era of residential communities,achieving a high-precision recognition rate of 97.6%and effectively overcoming the limitations of traditional image classification.Second,a Large Language Model(LLM)is employed to perform a fine-grained sentiment analysis of geotagged social media texts,and a geographically weighted approach is applied to spatially quantify public sentiment at the neighborhood scale.Third,moving beyond conventional facility-oriented evaluation,an integrated three-dimensional indicator system was constructed,covering problem urgency,implementation feasibility,and potential benefits.Priority assessment was conducted using an XGBoost model,and its robustness was strengthened through Monte Carlo simulation and full-gradient sensitivity analysis,ensuring reliable and stable ranking outcomes across all 2 188 old residential communities under study.The main findings are as follows:(1)a distinct scale-dependent spatial heterogeneity in renovation priorities.While high-priority communities are clustered in central urban districts,the average priority score is notably higher in certain peripheral counties—an"inversion"phenomenon that reflects the underlying tension between spatial equity and renewal efficiency,shaped by historical investment gaps,diminishing marginal returns,and regional economic disparities.(2)A dual-scale spatial clustering analysis conducted at both the community and administrative district levels identified four renovation archetypes and four corresponding policy zones,offering a refined understanding of priority differentiation and enabling a targeted governance approach characterized by categorized renovation and zonal coordination.(3)Building on these spatial patterns,this study has proposed a synergistic governance paradigm that integrates differentiated renovation strategies with macro-level resource allocation,thereby enhancing the precision and effectiveness of policy implementation.By establishing a"data-driven,model-supported,policy-adaptive"technical pathway,this research contributes to shifting urban renewal practices from experience-based judgment to evidence-based decision-making.The framework not only provides a scientific basis for optimizing renovation sequencing and resource distribution but also translates complex spatial diagnostics into operable policy tools,supporting more equitable,efficient,and sustainable urban regeneration in high-density cities.

马涛;马爽;龙骅娟;王艺霏;李伟国;王雄

浙江大学工程师学院,杭州 310015浙江大学建筑工程学院,杭州 310058中国市政工程中南设计研究总院有限公司,武汉 430010浙江大学建筑工程学院,杭州 310058中国市政工程中南设计研究总院有限公司,武汉 430010中国市政工程中南设计研究总院有限公司,武汉 430010

建筑与水利

优先级评估小区年代公众情绪空间异质性多尺度治理杭州市

priority assessmentbuilding age identificationpublic sentimentspatial heterogeneitymulti-scale governanceHangzhou City

《热带地理》 2026 (8)

1453-1466,14

10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.20250484

评论