"专精"抑或"博涉":研究领域跨度对博士生学术发表的影响OACHSSCD
Specialization or Extensiveness:The Influence of the Span of Research Fields on the Academic Publications of Doctoral Students
基于2015-2024年中国41所高校6 175名教育学科博士生的中国知网论文发表大数据,实证分析研究领域跨度对学术发表数量与质量的影响,结果发现:研究领域跨度与学术发表数量呈现显著正向关联,但对发表质量呈现显著负向影响;异质性分析表明,短期内研究领域分散对发表质量负面影响显著,长期影响则逐渐减弱;在个体科研能力强、院校层次高、学科优势明显等条件下,研究领域分散对发表质量的负面效应显著衰减.同时,跨学科在领域跨度对发表质量的影响中呈现显著调节效应:若领域跨度源于跨学科融合,其对发表质量的负面影响降低,甚至可能提升质量.基于此,建议博士生在学术成长初期注重领域深耕以夯实基础,后期通过跨学科融合拓展创新;高校等各方需优化跨学科资源支持与评价体系,平衡好"专精"与"博涉"在教育学研究及其博士培养过程中的辩证关系.
Based on the China National Knowledge Infrastructure(CNKI)dissertation publication data of 6,175 doctoral students in education from 41 universities in China from 2015 to 2024,an empirical analysis was made on the impact of research field span on the quantity and quality of academic publications,revealing that:there is a significant positive correlation between research field span and the quantity of academic publications,but it has a significant negative impact on the quality of publications;heterogeneity analysis shows that the negative effect of research field dispersion on quality is significant in the short term,but gradually diminishes in the long term;under the conditions of strong individual scientific research ability,high level of institution,and obvious disciplinary advantages,the negative effect of research field dispersion on the quality of publication is significantly attenuated.Meanwhile,interdisciplinarity has a significant moderating effect on the impact of field span on publication quality:if field span originates from interdisciplinary fusion,its negative impact on publication quality decreases and may even improve the quality.Based on this,it is suggested that doctoral students should focus on deep cultivation of their fields in the early stage of their academic growth in order to consolidate their foundation,and expand their innovation through interdisciplinary integration in the later stage;colleges and universities and other parties should optimize the interdisciplinary resource support and evaluation system,so as to balance the dialectic between"specialization"and"crossover"in the process of pedagogical research and doctoral training.
唐骏瑶;王敬尧;田浩然
中国人民大学 教育学院,北京 100872中国人民大学 教育学院,北京 100872中国人民大学 教育学院,北京 100872
社会科学
研究领域跨学科教育学科学术发表博士生
research fieldinterdisciplinarityeducation disciplineacademic publicationdoctoral students
《重庆高教研究》 2026 (4)
94-107,14
重庆市社会科学规划项目"组织社会化视角下博士生学术角色的生成机制研究"(2023BS088)
评论