城乡生源医学生对农村卫生工作能力需求的差异研究OA
Urban-rural differences in medical students'perceived needs for rural health work competencies
目的 比较城乡不同生源地医学生对农村卫生工作核心能力需求的差异,基于社会认知职业理论探讨生源地背景影响能力需求认知的内在机制,为高职医学院校实施差异化人才培养策略提供实证依据.方法 采用横断面调查设计,通过方便抽样法对某医卫类高职院校996名学生进行问卷调查,按生源地分为城市生源组(n=285)和农村生源组(n=711).采用MANOVA检验整体差异,独立样本t检验比较各能力维度差异,Cohen's d评估效应量.结果 MANO-VA分析显示,城乡生源在12项能力评分上存在整体显著差异(Wilks'λ=0.974,F=2.17,P=0.011).独立样本t检验显示,农村生源在6项能力重要性评分上均显著高于城市生源(P<0.01),其中人文关怀与沟通能力差异最大(d=0.32,P<0.001),综合管理能力(d=0.28,P<0.001)、应急处理能力(d=0.28,P<0.001)差异也较为明显.充分度评分方面,农村生源在公共卫生(d=0.15,P=0.035)、综合管理(d=0.16,P=0.026)、信息技术(d=0.15,P=0.031)、人文沟通(d=0.18,P=0.009)4项能力上显著高于城市生源.结论 农村生源医学生对农村卫生工作能力的需求认知显著高于城市生源,且对培养充分度的评价也更为积极.这一差异可从社会认知职业理论的"背景经验—自我效能—结果预期"路径加以解释,提示高职院校在农村卫生人才培养中应重视生源地背景的调节作用,构建差异化培养体系.
Objective To compare differences between medical students from urban versus rural backgrounds in perceived needs for core competencies required for rural health work,and—grounded in Social Cognitive Career Theory(SCCT)—to explore the underlying mech-anism through which students'place-of-origin background shapes competency-need perceptions,thereby providing empirical evidence for implementing differentiated training strategies in higher vocational medical colleges.Methods A cross-sectional survey design was em-ployed.Using convenience sampling,a questionnaire survey was administered to 996 students from a health-related higher vocational col-lege.Participants were categorized by place of origin into an urban-origin group(n=285)and a rural-origin group(n=711).Multivariate analysis of variance(MANOVA)was used to test overall group differences;independent-samples t tests were conducted to compare differ-ences across competency dimensions;and Cohen's d was calculated to estimate effect sizes.Results MANOVA indicated a statistically sig-nificant overall difference between urban-and rural-origin students across the 12 competency ratings(Wilks'λ=0.974,F=2.17,P=0.011).Independent-samples t tests showed that rural-origin students rated the importance of six competencies significantly higher than did ur-ban-origin students(P<0.01).The largest difference was observed for humanistic care and communication(d=0.32,P<0.001),with nota-ble differences also found for comprehensive management(d=0.28,P<0.001)and emergency response(d=0.28,P<0.001).Regarding per-ceived training adequacy,rural-origin students reported significantly higher adequacy scores than urban-origin students in four competen-cies:public health(d=0.15,P=0.035),comprehensive management(d=0.16,P=0.026),information technology(d=0.15,P=0.031),and hu-manistic communication(d=0.18,P=0.009).Conclusion Medical students from rural backgrounds reported significantly greater perceived needs for competencies required in rural health work than those from urban backgrounds and also provided more positive evaluations of training adequacy.This disparity can be interpreted through the SCCT pathway of"background experiences-self-efficacy-outcome ex-pectations,"suggesting that higher vocational institutions should attend to the moderating role of students'place-of-origin background in rural health workforce training and develop a differentiated competency-based training system accordingly.
李华英;郭凌志
湘潭医卫职业技术学院,湖南 湘潭 411104湘潭医卫职业技术学院,湖南 湘潭 411104
社会科学
城乡差异生源地农村卫生人才能力需求医学教育
urban-Rural disparitygeographicoriginrural health workforcecompetency needsmedical education
《继续医学教育》 2026 (3)
79-85,7
湖南省教育厅科学研究项目(23C0974)
评论