中西医结合情境下最佳循证实践指南临床实施框架的开发与应用OA
Development of a clinical implementation framework for evidence-based practice guidelines in settings featuring integrative Chinese-Western medicine
目的 该研究构建适用于中国临床情境的最佳实践指南(Best Practice Guidelines,BPGs)临床应用框架,并初步应用评估其可行性,为该模型的完善和循证护理改革与实践提供参考依据.方法 于2024年10-12月,基于知识转化模型、系统文献综述及北京中医药大学东直门医院10年最佳实践组织(Best Practice Spotlight Organization®,BPSO®)实施经验构建初步框架,并通过对12名多学科专家的质性访谈形成初步框架.2025年1-4月,选取15名多学科专家,采用内容效度指数(Content Validity Index,CVI)对初步框架进行内容效度评价,随后通过13名专家参与的焦点小组讨论修订完善最终框架.2025年4月将框架应用于北京中医药大学东直门医院骨伤科,以疼痛管理为临床场景开展初步应用,并对参与实施的12名专家进行访谈,评估其临床适用性与可行性.结果 该框架具有良好的内容效度,总体CVI为0.88.最终形成包含3个同心环结构的BPG临床实施框架:内环为3种中西医结合证据整合成果,即循证护理方案、本土化患者指南、患者决策辅助工具;中环为7步全周期实施路径,涵盖问题识别、证据本土化、障碍/促进因素评估、干预选择/调适/实施、过程监测、效果评价、可持续性维护;外环为9项针对性干预功能,包括教育、说服、激励、强制、培训、限制、环境重构、建模、赋能.在骨伤科疼痛管理的初步应用中,通过质性访谈揭示了3个主题:3个同心环结构提供了清晰的指导;内环证据产品选择标准需进一步明确;外环干预功能需要更具针对性的实施指导.结论 构建的实施框架在中西医结合情境下的BPG转化中具备良好的科学性与可行性,同时兼顾循证标准与中医特色,可为医疗机构与研究者高效适配国际指南提供理论与实践参考.
Objective:This study aimed to develop a systematic framework for the clinical transformation and application of Best Practice Guidelines(BPGs)in Chinese healthcare contexts,thus providing a reference for the implementation of evidence-based nursing reform and practice. Methods:From October to December 2024,a preliminary framework was developed based on a knowledge translation model,a systematic literature review,and 10 years of implementation experi-ence as a Best Practice Spotlight Organization®(BPSO®)at Dongzhimen Hospital,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine.The preliminary framework was then refined through qualitative interviews with 12 multidisciplinary experts.Subsequently,from January to April 2025,the content validity of the pre-liminary framework was evaluated by 15 multidisciplinary experts using the Content Validity Index(CVI).Following this,the framework was revised and finalized through a focus group discussion involving 13 experts.In April 2025,this framework was implemented in the Department of Orthopedics at Dongzhimen Hospital,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,taking pain management as the clinical application scenario.A total of 12 participants,including clinical physicians,nursing staff and meth-odological experts,were recruited to evaluate its clinical applicability and implementation feasibility. Results:The expert consultation results indicated good content validity of the framework,with an overall CVI of 0.88.The final framework comprises three concentric rings.The inner ring comprises three types of products derived from integrating Chinese and Western medical evidence—namely,evidence-based nursing protocols,locally adapted patient guidelines,and patient decision aids.The middle ring represents a seven-step,full-cycle implementation pathway that covers problem identifi-cation,evidence localization,barrier/facilitator assessment,intervention selection/adaptation/imple-mentation,process monitoring,outcome evaluation,and sustainability maintenance.The outer ring comprises nine targeted intervention functions,including education,persuasion,incentivization,coer-cion,training,restriction,environmental restructuring,modeling,and enablement.In the preliminary application to orthopedic pain management,qualitative interviews revealed three themes:the three-ring structure provided clear guidance;the selection criteria for evidence products in the inner ring need further clarification;the intervention functions of the outer ring require more targeted practical guidance for implementation. Conclusion:The framework developed in this study demonstrates strong scientific rigor and practical feasibility for BPG transformation in settings featuring integrative medicine,while preserving both evidence-based standards and the characteristics of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM).This frame-work can serve as both a theoretical and practical reference for healthcare institutions and researchers seeking to efficiently adapt international guidelines and promote standardized,evidence-based nursing practice.
田润溪;郑莉萍;高宁;杨丹;王芳;王蒙;刘红鑫;郭海玲
医药卫生
中医学:循证实践证据合成整合医学护理
Chinese traditional medicineEvidence-based practiceEvidence synthesisIntegrative medicineNursing
《国际护理科学(英文)》 2026 (3)
245-254,10
This study was supported by the Clinical Research and Achievement Transformation Capacity Improvement Pilot Project of Dongzhimen Hospital,Beijing University of Chinese Medicine(Grant No.DZMG-HLZX-24003).
评论