不同代谢-体重分型下冠心病心绞痛患者的中医证候及体质特点分析OA
Analysis of traditional Chinese medicine syndromes and constitution characteristics in patients with angina pectoris of coronary heart disease across different metabolic-weight types
目的 探讨不同代谢状态下体重正常或超重/肥胖的冠心病心绞痛患者的中医证候、体质特点及其相关性.方法 对2024 年9 月—2025 年1 月就诊于天津中医药大学第一附属医院、天津市南开医院的冠心病心绞痛患者进行横断面调查,根据有无代谢综合征及体重指数将患者分为 4 个类型:代谢健康-体重正常(MH-NW)、代谢不健康-体重正常(MU-NW)、代谢健康-超重/肥胖(MH-OW/OB)及代谢不健康-超重/肥胖(MU-OW/OB).总结各类型证候及体质特征,使用 R 软件的 Apriori 算法分别对证素间及中医体质类型、代谢-体重分型、中医证候类型进行关联分析.结果 共纳入430 例冠心病心绞痛患者,MH-NW、MU-NW、MH-OW/OB 及MU-OW/OB 型占比依次为19.5%、18.1%、14.4%、47.9%.代谢不健康者(MU-NW、MU-OW/OB 型)合并高血压、2 型糖尿病及高脂血症的占比较代谢健康者(MH-NW、MH-OW/OB 型)高(P<0.05);MU-OW/OB 型三支病变占比较高(P<0.05).中医证候分布方面,冠心病心绞痛患者总体呈现本虚标实、虚实夹杂的病机特点,同时,不同分型患者证候特征存在差异:MH-NW 型气虚、阳虚、气滞较其他类型占比更高,气虚-痰浊-血瘀关联度较高,最常见的证候为气虚血瘀证(20.2%);MU-NW 型阴虚占比较高,阴虚-气虚、阴虚-血瘀关联度较高,气阴两虚兼血瘀证最多(16.7%);MH-OW/OB 型阴虚-气虚、气虚-痰浊-血瘀之间关联突出,以气虚痰瘀证为主(16.1%);MU-OW/OB 型血瘀、痰浊、热蕴占比较高且关联紧密,以痰热瘀结证(25.7%)为主.中医体质分布方面,代谢健康者(MH-NW、MH-OW/OB 型)平和质(20.2%、24.2%)和气虚质(19.0%、21.0%)占比较高,MU-NW 型阴虚质(19.2%)占比较高,MU-OW/OB 型则以湿热质(24.3%)、痰湿质(21.8%)、血瘀质(19.9%)及气虚质(19.4%)为主.关联分析结果提示,湿热质与 MU-OW/OB 型之间关联度最高,而 MU-OW/OB 型与痰热瘀结证之间关联度最高.结论 不同代谢-体重分型的冠心病心绞痛患者的中医证候及体质分布存在一定规律性差异.MU-OW/OB 型患者"痰、热、瘀"互结的实证特点尤为突出,湿热质与 MU-OW/OB 型患者存在一定关联.不同分型患者的中医证候与体质特征反映了气虚、阴虚、痰浊、瘀热等病理因素在疾病发生发展中的不同侧重.这可为基于不同代谢-体重分型的冠心病心绞痛中医个体化辨证诊疗提供参考.
Objective To explore the types of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM)syndromes and the constitution types of patients with coronary heart disease presenting angina pectoris symptoms under different types of metabolic-weight types(normal or overweight/obesity),and to conduct a correlation analysis.Methods A cross-sectional study was conducted in patients with coronary heart disease and symptoms of angina pectoris who were recruited from the First Teaching Hospital of Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Tianjin Nankai Hospital between September 2024 and January 2025.Participants were stratified into four types based on the presence or absence of metabolic syndrome and body mass index:metabolically healthy-normal weight(MH-NW),metabolically unhealthy-normal weight(MU-NW),metabolically healthy-overweight/obesity(MH-OW/OB),and metabolically unhealthy-overweight/obesity(MU-OW/OB).TCM syndrome and constitution profiles were obtained,and the Apriori algorithm in R was used to conduct association analyses among syndrome elements,as well as among TCM constitution types,metabolic status-weight types,and TCM syndrome types,respectively.Results A total of 430 patients with coronary heart disease and angina pectoris were enrolled.The distribution among the MH-NW,MU-NW,MH-OW/OB,and MU-OW/OB types was 19.5%,18.1%,14.4%,and 47.9%,respectively.The metabolically unhealthy patients(MU-NW and MU-OW/OB)had a greater prevalence of hypertension,type 2 diabetes,and hyperlipidemia than the metabolically healthy patients(MH-NW and MH-OW/OB),(P<0.05).Among the MU-OW/OB type,the proportion of three-vessel disease was higher(P<0.05).Overall,the distribution of TCM syndrome elements in these patients reflected a pathogenesis characterized by a combination of root deficiency and excess manifestations.Syndrome characteristics varied among the different metabolic-weight types:The MH-NW type showed a higher prevalence of qi deficiency,yang deficiency,and qi stagnation.Strong associations were observed among qi deficiency,phlegm turbidity,and blood stasis.The most common syndrome was qi deficiency and blood stasis(20.2%).The MU-NW type had a higher proportion of yin deficiency,with notable associations between yin deficiency and qi deficiency,and between yin deficiency and blood stasis.The most frequent syndrome was deficiency of both qi and yin with blood stasis(16.7%).In the MH-OW/OB type,the associations between yin deficiency and qi deficiency,and among qi deficiency,phlegm turbidity,and blood stasis were more prominent.The syndrome of qi deficiency,phlegm and blood stasis(16.1%)was common.The MU-OW/OB type exhibited higher proportions and strong interconnections of blood stasis,phlegm turbidity,and heat accumulation,with the primary syndrome being phlegm-heat and blood stasis(25.7%).Regarding TCM constitution,the metabolically healthy patients(MH-NW and MH-OW/OB types)showed relatively higher proportions of balanced constitution(20.2%/24.2%)and qi-deficiency constitution(19.0%/21.0%).The MU-NW type had a higher proportion of yin-deficiency constitution(19.2%).In the MU-OW/OB type,the proportions of dampness-heat constitution(24.3%),phlegm-dampness constitution(21.8%),blood-stasis constitution(19.9%),and qi-deficiency constitution(19.4%)were relatively higher.Correlation analysis indicated the strongest association was between the dampness-heat constitution and the MU-OW/OB type,and between the MU-OW/OB type and syndrome of phlegm-heat and blood stasis.Conclusion Chinese medicine syndromes and constitution distributions in patients with angina pectoris of coronary heart disease differed across metabolic-body weight types.Patients with the MU-OW/OB type were characterized predominantly by excess syndromes involving the intermingling of phlegm,heat and blood stasis,and showed a certain association with damp-heat constitution.The syndrome and constitution characteristics of different types reflected varying contributions of pathological factors,including qi deficiency,yin deficiency,phlegm-turbidity,blood stasis and heat,during disease development and progression.These findings may provide a reference for individualized syndrome differentiation of coronary heart disease angina pectoris based on different metabolic-body weight types.
李梦茹;李雯;孙艺菲;田亚南;毕颖斐
天津中医药大学第一附属医院 天津 300381||中医国家临床医学研究中心||天津中医药大学天津中医药大学第一附属医院 天津 300381||中医国家临床医学研究中心||天津中医药大学天津中医药大学第一附属医院 天津 300381||中医国家临床医学研究中心||天津中医药大学天津中医药大学第一附属医院 天津 300381||中医国家临床医学研究中心天津中医药大学第一附属医院 天津 300381||中医国家临床医学研究中心
医药卫生
冠心病心绞痛代谢综合征肥胖中医证候中医体质
coronary heart diseaseangina pectorismetabolic syndromeobesitytraditional Chinese medicine syndrometraditional Chinese medicine constitution
《北京中医药大学学报》 2026 (6)
811-821,11
天津市第二批卫生健康行业高层次人才选拔培养工程项目(No.TJSQNYXXR-D2-083-1)天津市卫生健康委员会中医药重点领域科技项目(No.2022009)中华中医药学会求实项目(No.2024-QNQS-013) Tianjin Municipality,Second Batch of the Selection and Training Program for High-Level Talents in the Health Industry(No.TJSQNYXXR-D2-083-1)
评论