基于光子计数CT的脑动静脉畸形低剂量四维CT血管成像方案的辐射剂量与图像质量评估OA
Low dose four-dimensional CT angiography imaging of brain arteriovenous malformation based on photon-counting CT:radiation dose and image quality evaluation
目的 探讨基于光子计数CT的四维CT血管成像(4D-CTA)方案在脑动静脉畸形(AVM)成像中降低辐射剂量的可行性,并评估低辐射剂量方案的图像质量.方法 前瞻性连续纳入2024年5月至2025年11月入住北京协和医院神经外科拟行介入栓塞术,需术前完善动态4D-CTA以进一步观察血管结构的脑AVM患者16例.收集患者的一般资料,包括性别、年龄及临床症状[癫痫发作、局灶性神经功能障碍(运动障碍、感觉障碍、失语等)、非特异症状(头痛、呕吐等)、无明显症状].术前DSA上的脑AVM血管结构影像学资料包括脑AVM位置(幕上、幕下)、最大径、供血动脉来源(前循环、后循环、前循环及后循环)、静脉引流类型(浅表引流、深静脉引流).所有患者均通过光子计数CT完成4D-CTA检查并重建脑血流量(CBF)、脑血容量(CBV)及平均通过时间(MTT)三组灌注参数图,其中前8例采用传统方案(光子计数CT系统预置的扫描方案),后8例采用低剂量方案(将能量谱控制功能中的图像质量目标设置为"血管优化"模式,动态扫描于对比剂注射后延迟4s启动,并将时间采样周期延长至1.5s,使总采集时间缩短至41.9s,动态时间点减少至21个,重点覆盖动脉期至静脉引流的关键时间窗口).由2名放射科医师独立评估两种方案的图像质量,包括4D-CTA及基于4D-CTA生成的灌注参数图(CBF、CBV、MTT)的信噪比及对比噪声比,并与DSA显示的脑AVM血管结构进行对比;采用4分量表对CBF、CBV、MTT灌注参数图的主观质量进行评价.采用组内相关系数(ICC)或Cohen's Kappa分析对2名放射科医师对图像质量的评估结果进行观察者间一致性检验.结果 (1)共纳入16例脑AVM患者,男9例,女7例,年龄9~65岁,平均(38±15)岁,其中传统方案组8例,低剂量方案组8例;传统方案组与低剂量方案组患者的性别、年龄、临床症状分布及脑AVM位置、最大径、供血动脉来源、静脉引流类型的差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05).(2)传统方案组的管电流为140~190 mA,中位管电流为168(156,173)mA,低剂量方案组管电流为7~48 mA,中位管电流为42(41,44)mA,组间差异有统计学意义(P=0.002).传统方案组的辐射剂量为4.8~9.2 mSv,中位辐射剂量为8.4(7.0,8.9)mSv,低剂量方案组的辐射剂量为0.3~1.8 mSv,中位辐射剂量为1.7(1.5,1.8)mSv,组间差异有统计学意义(P<0.01).(3)2名放射科医师基于4D-CTA对脑AVM位置、供血动脉来源及静脉引流类型的分类评估达到高度或几乎完全一致(观察者间一致比例分别为16/16、14/16、15/16,Kappa值分别为1.000、0.667、0.871),对AVM最大径的测量一致性极好(ICC=0.994);4D-CTA及各项基于4D-CTA的灌注参数(CBF、CBV、MTT)图的信噪比与对比噪声比的测量结果均具有良好或极好一致性(ICC为0.762~0.972);CBV与CBF灌注参数图主观质量评分分别为几乎完全一致和高度一致(Kappa值分别为0.828、0.700),MTT灌注参数图主观质量评分一致性中等(Kappa=0.478).(4)传统方案组与低剂量方案组4D-CTA图像及基于4D-CTA的CBF、CBV、MTT灌注参数图的信噪比、对比噪声比组间差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05).低剂量方案及传统方案4D-CTA图像均可清晰显示脑AVM的位置、最大径、供血动脉来源及静脉引流类型等结构特征,且与术前DSA结果一致.低剂量方案组脑AVM患者基于4D-CTA的MTT灌注参数图主观质量评分低于传统方案组[3.0(2.0,3.0)分比3.5(3.0,4.0)分,P=0.045].两组CBF和CBV灌注参数图主观质量评分差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05).结论 基于光子计数CT的低剂量4D-CTA成像方案可提供与传统方案质量相当的脑AVM血管结构信息与灌注参数图像.本研究结果仍需大样本研究验证.
Objective To investigate the feasibility of reducing radiation dose in brain arteriovenous malformation(AVM)imaging using a photon-counting CT based four-dimensional CT angiography(4D-CTA)protocol,and to evaluate the diagnostic image quality under the low-dose protocol.Methods A total of 16 patients with brain AVM admitted to the Department of Neurosurgery,Peking Union Medical College Hospital between May 2024 and November 2025 for planned interventional embolization,and required preoperative dynamic 4D-CTA for further observation of vascular structures,were prospectively and consecutively enrolled.General patient data were collected,including sex,age,and clinical symptoms(seizures,focal neurological deficits[motor impairment,sensory impairment,aphasia,etc.],non-specific symptoms[headache,vomiting,etc.],or no obvious symptoms).Imaging data of brain AVM vascular structures on preoperative DSA included the location of the AVM nidus(supratentorial or infratentorial),maximum diameter,source of feeding arteries(anterior circulation,posterior circulation,anterior and posterior circulation),and type of venous drainage(superficial or deep venous drainage).All patients underwent 4D-CTA examinations on a photon-counting CT,and three sets of perfusion parameter maps(cerebral blood flow[CBF],cerebral blood volume[CBV],and mean transit time[MTT])were reconstructed.The first 8 patients underwent the standard protocol(the preset scanning protocol of the photon-counting CT system),while the subsequent 8 patients underwent the low-dose protocol(the combined applications to reduce exposure[CARE]keV image quality target was set to the"vascular optimized"mode,dynamic scanning was initiated with a 4-second delay after contrast injection,and the temporal sampling interval was extended to 1.5 seconds,reducing the total acquisition time to 41.9 seconds and the number of dynamic time points to 21,primarily covering the critical time window from the arterial phase to venous drainage).Two radiologists independently evaluated the image quality of both protocols,including the signal-to-noise ratio(SNR)and contrast-to-noise ratio(CNR)of 4D-CTA and 4D-CTA-derived perfusion parameter maps(CBF,CBV,MTT),and compared them with the brain AVM vascular structures shown on DSA.A 4-point scale was used to assess the subjective image quality of the CBF,CBV,and MTT perfusion maps.Inter-observer agreement between the two radiologists for image quality assessment was tested using intraclass correlation coefficient(ICC)or Cohen's Kappa analysis.Results(1)A total of 16 patients with brain AVM were included(9 males,7 females;age range 9-65 years,mean age[38±15]years),with 8 in the standard protocol group and 8 in the low-dose protocol group.There were no statistically significant differences between the standard protocol and low-dose protocol groups in sex,age,clinical symptoms,AVM location,maximum diameter,source of feeding arteries,and type of venous drainage(all P>0.05).(2)The tube current in the standard protocol group ranged from 140 mA to 190mA,with a median of 168(156,173)mA,while that in the low-dose group ranged from 7 mA to 48 mA,with a median of 42(41,44)mA;the difference was statistically significant(P=0.002).The radiation dose in the standard protocol group ranged from 4.8 mSv to 9.2 mSv,with a median of 8.4(7.0,8.9)mSv,whereas that in the low-dose protocol group ranged from 0.3 mSv to 1.8 mSv,with a median of 1.7(1.5,1.8)mSv,showing a statistically significant difference(P<0.01).(3)The two radiologists reached substantial or almost perfect agreement in classifying AVM location,source of feeding arteries,and type of venous drainage(inter-observer agreement rates:16/16,14/16,and 15/16,respectively;Kappa values:1.000,0.667,and0.871,respectively),and showed excellent agreement in measuring the maximum diameter of AVM(ICC=0.994).The measurements of SNR and CNR for 4D-CTA and perfusion parameter maps(CBF,CBV,MTT)showed good or excellent agreement(ICC ranging from 0.762 to 0.972).The subjective image quality scores for CBV and CBF perfusion maps demonstrated almost perfect and substantial agreement,respectively(Kappa values:0.828 and 0.700),while the subjective scores for MTT perfusion maps showed moderate agreement(Kappa=0.478).(4)There were no statistically significant differences in the SNR and CNR of 4D-CTA images and CBF,CBV,and MTT perfusion maps between the standard and low-dose protocol groups(all P>0.05).The 4D-CTA images from both protocols clearly displayed structural features such as AVM location,maximum diameter,source of feeding arteries,and type of venous drainage,which were consistent with the DSA findings.The subjective image quality score of the 4D-CTA-based MTT perfusion maps in the low-dose protocol group was lower than that in the standard protocol group(3.0[2.0,3.0]vs.3.5[3.0,4.0]),with a statistically significant difference(P=0.045).There were no statistically significant differences in the subjective scores of CBF and CBV perfusion maps between the two groups(both P>0.05).Conclusions The photon-counting CT based low-dose 4D-CTA protocol can provide anatomical and perfusion parameter images of brain AVM with quality comparable to that of the standard protocol.The findings of this study warrant further validation in larger cohorts.
李沅蓁;范晓媛;李安琪;苑可欣;有慧;赵元立;冯逢
100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院放射科100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院放射科100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院神经外科100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院神经外科100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院放射科100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院神经外科100730 中国医学科学院北京协和医学院 北京协和医院放射科
颅内动静脉畸形计算机体层摄影血管造影辐射剂量灌注成像光子计数CT
Intracranial arteriovenous malformationComputed tomography angiographyRadiation dosagePerfusion imagingPhoton counting CT
《中国脑血管病杂志》 2026 (5)
299-310,12
国家自然科学基金(82371946)国家卫生健康委医药科技发展研究中心临床科研专项课题(WKZX20205CZ0301)国家资助博士后研究人员计划(GZC20240138)
评论