首页|期刊导航|中医杂志|解释学视域下中医辨证论治"证-治-效"内在逻辑探讨

解释学视域下中医辨证论治"证-治-效"内在逻辑探讨OA

On the Internal Logic of"Syndrome-Treatment-Effect"in Traditional Chinese Medicine Syndrome Differen-tiation and Treatment from the Perspective of Hermeneutics

中文摘要英文摘要

针对辨证论治常被误读为"经验任意"或被外在单一指标否定其可证性的问题,借助解释学关于"传统-理解-实践"相互生成的思想,梳理辨证论治在临床流程中所依据的对象层级、推理进路与效验校正方式.认为"证"并非病名或单一指标的替代,而是患者在特定情境下的证候结构与病势过程;四诊合参与医患问答构成互证取舍的理由链条,使离散征象得以被组织为可讨论的证候判断;治法方药将理解外化并在疗效反馈中返观再辨证,从而形成"证-治-效"往复参证的自我校正环.由此,辨证论治并非任意经验堆积,而是一种在经典成法、共同体训练与临床效验多重约束下运行的临床理性.

The concept of syndrome differentiation and treatment is often misunderstood as"arbitrary empiri-cism"or dismissed as unjustifiable when judged by a single external indicator.To address it,this paper draws on hermeneutics,especially the idea that"tradition,understanding,and practice"are mutually generative,to elucidate the object levels,inferential pathways,and efficacy-based validation and correction mechanisms underlying this approach in the clinical process.It is argued that"syndrome"is not a substitute for a disease label or an isolated indicator,but rather a structured configuration of manifestations and an evolving trajectory of illness situated in a specific clinical context.The correlation of all four examinations and physician-patient dialogue form a reasoned chain for the selection of diagnoses,through which discrete signs and symptoms are organized into a syndrome judgment that can be articulated and debated.Therapeutic principles and prescriptions externalize clinical understanding and,through feedback from therapeutic effects,reflexively prompt re-differentiation,thereby forming a cyclical,self-corrective dynamic loop of"syndrome,treatment and effect".Accordingly,syndrome differentiation and treatment should not be regarded as a contingent accumulation of experience,but as a form of clinical rationality under multiple constraints,including clas-sical methods,communal training,and clinical verification.

韩梓逸;张其成

北京中医药大学国学院,北京市朝阳区北三环东路11号,100029北京中医药大学国学院,北京市朝阳区北三环东路11号,100029

解释学辨证论治证候结构四诊合参疗效反馈

hermeneuticssyndrome differentiation and treatmentsyndrome structurecorrelation of all four exami-nationstherapeutic feedback

《中医杂志》 2026 (10)

1033-1037,5

国家社会科学基金重大项目(16ZDA234)北京中医药大学横向课题:中医文化促进中医药老字号品牌塑造与传播研究项目(BUCM-2025-JS-FW-160)中国人民大学横向课题:医易会通与中医理论自主知识体系研究项目(2026K20041)

10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2026.10.001

评论