区位转移下企业经济升级促进社会升级的机制OA
Corporate Economic Upgrading Mechanism Leading to Social Upgrading in the Context of Relocation:A Case Study of a Furniture Manufacturing Firm
文章以深圳家具制造S企业为案例,通过深度访谈和参与式调查的方法,探究区位转移下企业经济升级驱动社会升级的过程和机制.结果发现:1)过程、产品、功能、链条与规模升级产生了差异化的社会升级结果,在提高薪资、增加岗位、培训机会和增强话语权的同时,亦带来岗位缩减、劳动强度增加及收入不均等社会降级效应.2)区位转移后的社会升级受地方产业政策等公共治理与企业薪酬激励等私营治理的共同调节.其中,公共治理通过制度供给构成社会升级的主要推动力量,而企业治理更多体现为对制度环境的嵌入式适应,结果在不同劳动群体间形成差异化的社会升级效应.
Against the backdrop of industrial relocation in China,enterprise migration is reshaping production organizations and labor structures,making the relationship between Economic Upgrading(EU)and Social Upgrading(SU)increasingly complex.Existing studies have paid limited attention to how the institutional changes triggered by regional relocation influence SU at the micro level.To address this gap,this study uses S Enterprise,a furniture manufacturing firm that relocated from Shenzhen to Anji in Zhejiang Province,as a case study.Based on in-depth interviews,participant observations,and internal enterprise materials,this study investigated the mechanisms through which the EU affected SU under regional relocation and examined the differentiated roles of public and private governance in this process.The findings showed that enterprises achieved multiple forms of EU during relocation,including process,product,functional,chain,and scale upgrades.However,the social consequences of these upgrading processes are characterized by the coexistence of social upgrading and downgrading.Automation,managerial optimization,and supply chain integration improve production efficiency and generate positive SU outcomes,including job creation,wage growth,expanded training opportunities,and broader career development channels.However,technological substitution reduces low-skilled positions,whereas product diversification and increasing orders intensify labor pressure and transform the original wage system,leading to a decrease in income among some experienced workers.Therefore,EU did not automatically translate into SU but instead involved an unequal distribution of upgrading benefits and costs.This study further demonstrated that regional relocation reshapes the institutional environment in which the enterprise is embedded,becoming a key condition for differentiated SU outcomes.In the destination region of Anji,relatively comprehensive public governance arrangements concerning wage standards,industrial support,talent recruitment,and living conditions provide institutional support for improving workers' employment quality and living standards.For example,the enterprise maintained Shenzhen-level wage standards after relocation,enabling formal workers to earn wages above local market levels.However,such institutional benefits were unevenly distributed across labor groups.Temporary workers,largely controlled by third-party labor agencies,lack stable protection and promotion opportunities and become particularly vulnerable during industrial fluctuations,facing a higher risk of social downgrading.Compared to public governance,private governance primarily reflects adaptive responses to the new institutional environment rather than proactive social responsibility initiatives.Although the enterprise improved wages,performance bonuses,and dormitory conditions for some workers,efficiency-oriented strategies such as dual-track employment systems,extended working hours,and intensified performance management further widened the disparities between permanent and temporary migrant and local workers.Overall,the primary driving force behind SU during the early stage of relocation stemmed from institutional provisions within the public governance system,whereas corporate governance amplified the differentiated outcomes among labor groups.This study reveals the"asymmetry between the benefits and costs of upgrading"during the process through which EU influences SU,demonstrating that SU is not an automatic outcome of EU but is jointly shaped by spatial restructuring,institutional environments,and governance arrangements.By incorporating spatial restructuring and governance differentiation into EU and SU analysis,this study provides micro-level evidence for understanding labor transformation and industrial relocation in contemporary China.
赵甜颖;黄耿志;薛德升
中山大学地理科学与规划学院,广州 510006中山大学地理科学与规划学院,广州 510006中山大学地理科学与规划学院,广州 510006
管理科学
经济升级社会升级产业升级区位转移治理家具制造企业
economic upgradingsocial upgradingindustrial upgradingindustrial relocationgovernancefurniture manufacturing firm
《热带地理》 2026 (6)
1071-1083,13
广东省基础与应用基础研究基金项目(2024A1515010939)国家自然科学基金项目(42471228)
评论