不同轮作模式下玉米产量及养分利用效率对化肥与有机物料配施模式的响应OA
Response of maize yield and nutrient use efficiency to combined application of chemical fertilizer and organic amendments under different rotation systems
[目的]油菜-玉米(oilseed rape-maize,OM)和小麦-玉米(wheat-maize,WM)轮作是长江流域典型的玉米轮作模式,研究化肥和有机物料投入对 OM 和 WM 轮作体系玉米产量和养分利用的影响及其差异,以期为玉米高产栽培养分管理提供依据.[方法]2020-2021 年在湖北省沙洋县开展田间试验,在 OM 和 WM 轮作模式下,分别设置不施肥(CK)、化肥(NPK)、化肥+秸秆(NPK+S)和化肥+秸秆+有机肥(NPK+S+M)4 个施肥处理,调查了玉米产量、地上部生物量、养分利用效率和养分表观平衡.[结果]两年试验的平均结果表明,两个轮作模式下,4 个处理间玉米产量相差显著,由高到低均为 NPK+S+M>NPK+S>NPK>CK(P<0.05);在 CK 和NPK 处理下,OM 和 WM 的玉米产量差异显著,而在 NPK+S 和 NPK+S+M 处理下,两个轮作体系玉米产量差异不显著.两个轮作模式下,4 个处理间玉米地上部养分积累量差异显著,氮、磷、钾积累量由高到低均为NPK+S+M>NPK+S>NPK>CK(P<0.05);4 个处理下,OM 玉米地上部养分积累量显著高于 WM,氮、磷、钾积累量分别高出 9.6%~52.7%、9.9%~28.7%和 9.2%~36.2%.两个轮作模式下,有机物料的投入降低了玉米养分利用效率,与 NPK 处理相比,NPK+S 和 NPK+S+M 处理的玉米氮磷钾生理利用率分别降低 12.7%~25.4%和 9.1%~28.3%;在 CK 和 NPK 处理下,OM 的玉米养分收获指数和养分生理利用率高于 WM,而在NPK+S 和 NPK+S+M 处理下则低于 WM.两个轮作模式下,4 个处理间养分表观盈余相差显著,氮、磷表观盈余由高到低均为 NPK+S+M>NPK>NPK+S>CK,钾表观盈余由高到低表现为 NPK+S+M>NPK+S>NPK>CK;4 个处理下,氮磷钾表观盈余均表现为 WM>OM.[结论]单施化肥油玉轮作的玉米产量和养分积累量显著高于麦玉轮作,而化肥配合秸秆还田和有机肥可显著提高玉米产量和养分积累量,麦玉轮作下玉米产量和养分积累量可增加到与油玉轮作相当的水平,并提高养分表观盈余量.在麦玉轮作体系中,提倡同时施用化肥和有机肥并结合秸秆还田,以充分满足玉米高产对养分的需求,而在油玉轮作模式下,可考虑油菜作为有机肥的效应,推荐化肥配合秸秆还田来保证玉米产量和养分利用效率,从而实现粮油兼丰.
[Objectives]Oilseed rape-maize(OM)and wheat-maize(WM)are typical rotation patterns in the Yangtze River Basin in China.This study investigated the effects of combined application of chemical fertilizers and organic materials on maize yield and nutrient use under OM and WM rotation systems,aiming to provide a scientific basis for nutrient management in high-yielding maize production.[Methods]Field experiments were conducted in Shayang County,Hubei Province in 2020 and 2021.Four fertilization treatments were set up under the OM and WM rotations:no fertilization(CK),chemical fertilizers(NPK),chemical fertilizers+straw return(NPK+S),chemical fertilizers+straw return+manure(NPK+S+M).Maize yield,aboveground biomass,nutrient utilization efficiency and nutrient apparent balance were analyzed.[Results]The average results of the two-year experiment showed that there was a significant difference in maize yield among four treatments under two rotation patterns,and the order from high to low was NPK+S+M>NPK+S>NPK>CK(P<0.05).The maize yield of OM was significantly higher than that of WM under CK and NPK treatments,but not significantly different from that of WM under NPK+S and NPK+S+M treatments.The N,P and K nutrient accumulation of maize shoots were significantly different among the four treatments in both the rotation patterns,showing an order of NPK+S+M>NPK+S>NPK>CK(P<0.05),and the N,P,and K nutrient accumulation of OM maize were 9.6%-52.7%,9.9%-28.7%and 9.2%-36.2%higher than those of WM,respectively.The input of organic materials reduced the nutrient use efficiency of maize in the four treatments.Compared with NPK treatment,the physiological utilization rates of N,P and K in NPK+S and NPK+S+M treatments decreased by 12.7%-25.4%and 9.1%-28.3%,respectively.Under CK and NPK treatments,the nutrient harvest index and nutrient physiological utilization rate of OM were higher than those of WM,but lower than those of WM under NPK+S and NPK+S+M treatments.Under the two rotation patterns,the apparent surplus of nutrients among the four treatments was significantly different.The apparent surplus of N and P from high to low was NPK+S+M>NPK>NPK+S>CK,and the apparent surplus of K was in order of NPK+S+M>NPK+S>NPK>CK.Under the four treatments,the apparent surplus of N,P and K was WM>OM.[Conclusions]Applying chemical fertilizer alone resulted in significantly higher maize yield and nutrient accumulation under the oilseed rape-maize rotation pattern than under the wheat-maize rotation.However,the combined application of chemical fertilizer with straw return or organic fertilizer significantly increased maize yield and nutrient accumulation.In the wheat-maize rotation system,maize yield and nutrient accumulation could be raised to levels comparable to those in the oilseed rape-maize rotation,and the apparent nutrient surplus was also improved.In the wheat-maize rotation system,it is recommended to apply both chemical and organic fertilizers combined with straw return to fully meet the nutrient demands for high maize yields.In contrast,in the oilseed rape-maize rotation system,considering the organic fertilizer effect of oilseed rape itself,the combined application of chemical fertilizer with straw return is recommended to ensure maize yield and nutrient use efficiency,thereby achieving high and stable yields of both grain and oil crops.
李涛;鲁剑巍;方娅婷;杜思垚;盛倩男;赵剑;李凯旭;徐维明;朱俊;任涛
华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070沙洋县农业技术推广中心,湖北 荆门 448000沙洋县农业技术推广中心,湖北 荆门 448000华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070
轮作化肥秸秆有机肥玉米产量养分利用效率
rotationchemical fertilizerstraworganic fertilizermaize yieldnutrient utilization
《植物营养与肥料学报》 2026 (5)
1019-1029,11
国家油菜产业技术体系项目(CARS-12)中央高校基本科研业务费(2662024PY017).
评论