麻类作物的土壤碳效应:基于Meta与SWiM方法的定量研究OA
Effects of Bast Fiber Crops on Soil Carbon:A Meta-analysis and SWiM-based Synthesis
麻类作物抗逆性强、生物产量高,被认为是潜在的生态工程植物和高碳汇植物.然而,现有关于麻类作物土壤固碳效应的研究存在高度异质性,且部分土壤生态指标缺乏足够的数据进行标准化合并,限制了对其生态功能的全面评估.该研究基于已发表核心试验数据,采用随机效应 Meta 分析与无 Meta 分析合成(SWiM)的混合数据分析方法,系统量化了麻类作物对土壤有机碳(SOC)及相关理化性质的影响.结果显示,与常规非麻类作物或休耕裸地相比,麻类作物对SOC 总体呈正向效应(lnRR=0.38),且具有极强的情景依赖性,即其碳效应依赖于对土地利用类型、管理强度及土壤背景条件的综合响应.亚组分析表明,不同种类麻类作物固碳能力差异显著,其中多年生麻类作物(罗布麻、苎麻)的固碳潜力远高于一年生麻类作物(黄麻、亚麻和工业大麻等).麻类作物种植的土壤碳效应存在"生物量输入-农艺扰动"之间的权衡机制:在边际土地或多年生系统中(如主要用于盐碱地等生态修复的罗布麻),低干扰管理促进了根源碳的稳定积累,而在黄麻轮作等常规耕作的一年生系统中,频繁的机械扰动将抵消生物量输入的固碳效益.SWiM分析表明,SOC 的增加并非总是伴随着土壤容重的降低或微生物生物量的增加,说明土壤物理结构与生物过程响应的非同步性.研究认为,麻类作物有较强的固碳潜力,其土壤碳效应受到农艺措施等的综合调控,在制订基于麻类作物的固碳与土壤修复策略时,需要重点考虑作物管理强度.
Bast fiber crops exhibit strong stress tolerance and high biomass productivity,and are thus recognized as promising ecological pioneer plants and high-potential carbon sequestration species.Never-theless,current studies on the soil carbon sequestration effects of bast fiber crops are highly heterogene-ous.Moreover,available data are insufficient for standardized integration of several key soil ecological in-dicators,which constrains a comprehensive evaluation of their ecological functions.Based on a global dataset of core experimental observations,this study employed a hybrid analytical approach combining random-effects Meta-analysis and Synthesis without Meta-analysis(SWiM)to quantify the impacts of fi-ber crop cultivation on soil organic carbon(SOC)and associated soil physicochemical properties.The re-sults showed that,compared to conventional non-fiber crops or bare fallow land,bast fiber crops exerted a significant overall positive effect on SOC(lnRR=0.38),yet this effect was highly context-dependent,relying on a comprehensive response to land use type,management intensity,and initial soil background conditions.Subgroup analysis indicated significant differences in carbon sequestration capacity among dif-ferent types of bast fiber crops,with perennial crops(such as ramie and Apocynum venetum)showing considerably higher potential than annual crops(such as jute,flax,and industrial hemp).Furthermore,a trade-off mechanism between biomass input and agronomic disturbance was observed in the soil carbon effects of bast fiber crops:in marginal lands or perennial systems(such as Apocynum venetum primarily used for ecological restoration of saline-alkali soils),low-disturbance management facilitated the stable accumulation of root-derived carbon;by contrast,in annual systems under conventional tillage(e.g.,jute rotation),frequent mechanical disturbance offset the carbon sequestration benefits derived from bio-mass input.SWiM analysis indicated that elevated SOC was not consistently accompanied by reduced soil bulk density or enhanced microbial biomass,demonstrating the asynchronous responses between soil physical structure and biological processes.Our findings suggest that bast fiber crops possess considerable carbon sequestration potential,and their soil carbon effects are comprehensively modulated by agronomic practices.Accordingly,crop management intensity should be prioritized when formulating bast fiber crop-based strategies for carbon sequestration and soil remediation.
兰小明;陶宇峰;颜世伟;高钢;赵信林;朱爱国;陈继康
中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221中国农业科学院麻类研究所/国家麻类作物育种中心,湖南 长沙 410221
农业科技
麻类作物土壤碳效应土壤有机碳Meta分析SWiM方法土壤生态指标
bast fiber cropssoil carbon effectssoil organic carbon(SOC)Meta-analysisSyn-thesis Without Meta-analysis(SWiM)soil ecological indicators
《中国麻业科学》 2026 (2)
105-116,12
国家重点研发计划项目"西部特色沙生作物提质增效关键共性技术研发与集成应用"(2024YFD1600800)财政部和农业农村部:国家麻类产业技术体系建设专项(CARS-16)
评论