高校"人工智能+"教育生态成熟度模型:指标体系与评估实践OA
Maturity Model of the"AI+"Education Ecosystem in Higher Education:Indicator System and Evaluation Practice
构建科学有效的评估指标体系是推动高校"人工智能+"建设实现高质量发展的重要基础.现有研究多聚焦技术应用、师生素养或伦理治理等局部议题,缺乏兼具系统性与可操作性的评估框架.本文以生态系统理论为基础,结合高校教育治理与教学实践特征,构建了由组织生态、技术生态、教师应用生态、学生应用生态与发展生态构成的高校"人工智能+"教育生态框架.随后,综合运用文献分析、德尔菲专家咨询与层次分析法,形成包含5个一级指标、13个二级指标和42个三级指标的评估指标体系,并确定各级指标权重.在此基础上,设计基础级、应用级、发展级、融合级和引领级五级成熟度模型,并引入针对最低维度的约束机制,以增强评估结果的系统性与均衡性.最后,以S高校为例开展评估实践,呈现成熟度模型的应用过程与诊断结果.研究可为高校开展人工智能与教育融合的生态评价、过程诊断和持续改进提供方法支持与实践参考.
Developing a valid and operational indicator system is essential for advancing the high-quality development of the"AI+"construction in higher education.Existing studies have mainly examined specific aspects such as technology application,teach-ers' and students' AI literacy,and ethical governance,but have paid insufficient attention to systematic and applicable evaluation frameworks.Drawn upon ecosystem theory and considering the characteristics of higher education governance as well as instructional practice,this study proposes an"AI+"education ecosystem framework in higher education,consisting of organizational ecology,tech-nological ecology,teacher application ecology,student application ecology,and developmental ecology.Guided by this framework,this study employs literature analysis,Delphi expert consultation,and the analytic hierarchy process to develop an evaluation indicator system and determine the relative weights of indicators.The final indicator system includes 5 first-level indicators,13 second-level indicators,and 42 third-level indicators.Based on that,this study designs a five-level maturity model,namely the basic,application,development,integration,and leading levels.A constraint mechanism for under-performing dimensions is introduced to improve the comprehensiveness and balance of the evaluation results.Finally,University S is used as a case to demonstrate the application process and diagnostic results of the maturity model.This study provides a methodological basis and practical reference for evaluation,diag-nosis,and continued improvement in the integration of AI and education in higher education.
吴欣怡;张青林;宋芊菲;江丰光
上海交通大学教育学院(上海200240)上海交通大学教育学院(上海200240)上海交通大学教务处(上海200240)上海交通大学教育学院(上海200240)
社会科学
"人工智能+"教育生态成熟度模型指标体系生态系统理论高等教育
"AI+"education ecosystemMaturity modelIndicator systemEcosystem theoryHigher education
《远程教育杂志》 2026 (3)
59-71,13
上海高等教育人才培养改革专项"AI(人工智能)+HI(人类智慧)赋能人才培养"(项目编号:ZXWH7602101)、上海交通大学教务处数智课程建设专项"人工智能高校教育生态评估指标体系构建"(项目编号:WH620160202/065).
评论