双重加工视角下的人机协同认知:基于大语言模型的动态认知分工OA
Human-Machine Collaborative Cognition under a Dual-Process Perspective:Dynamic Cognitive Division of Labor Based on Large Language Models
本文以双重加工理论为分析视角,探讨推理增强型大语言模型进入教育情境后支持人机协同认知的实现路径.借助测试时计算、强化学习、思维链等机制,大语言模型在教育情境中同时呈现快速生成与分步推理并存的"类系统1/类系统2"加工倾向,进而冲击了"人工智能提供信息—人类承担思考"的既有认知责任分工,以及由此产生的认知外包、能力替代与协同冗余等新挑战.本文通过阐明两类加工倾向的功能映射及其教育含义,从协同原则、目标、机制与保障四个维度,构建适配教育情境的人机协同认知模型.该模型以任务结构、学习阶段与认知负荷为依据,对"快答/深推"进行条件化触发、强度约束与阶段性回收,并在交互层面引入元认知机制,支持学习者对人工智能推理过程进行监控、质疑与再加工.在此基础上,本文结合高结构化STEM问题解决、论证性写作、探究式学习与课堂即时诊断等典型教学场景,阐明大语言模型应由答案生成工具转向可解释、可控制、可回收的认知支架.结论表明,人工智能时代的人机协同学习设计,应以促进学习者系统2能力发展为核心目标,在提升任务效率的同时,维护学习者的独立思考、论证反思与迁移应用能力.
Drawing on dual-process theory,this paper examines how reasoning-enhanced large language models(LLMs)can support human-machine collaborative cognition in educational contexts.Supported by mechanisms such as test-time computation,re-inforcement learning,and chain-of-thought reasoning,LLMs are able to combine rapid response generation with stepwise reasoning,thereby displaying processing tendencies analogous to System 1 and System 2.This dual tendency challenges the conventional division of cognitive responsibility,in which AI is expected to provide information while humans engage in higher-order thinking,and gives rise to emerging concerns such as cognitive outsourcing,capability substitution,and collaborative redundancy.By clarifying the func-tional correspondence between these two processing tendencies and their educational implications,this paper develops a human-ma-chine collaborative cognitive model tailored to educational contexts.The model is organized around four dimensions:collaborative principles,learning goals,interaction mechanisms,and safeguards.Based on task structure,learning phase,and cognitive load,the model proposes the conditional activation,intensity regulation,and gradual fading of"fast-answer"and"deep-reasoning"modes.At the interaction level,it incorporates metacognitive mechanisms that enable learners to monitor,question,and reprocess AI-generated reasoning.Building on this framework,the paper discusses its application in representative instructional scenarios,including struc-tured STEM problem solving,argumentative writing,inquiry-based learning,and real-time classroom diagnosis.It argues that LLMs should not only serve as answer-generation tools,but should function as explainable,controllable,and gradually fading cognitive scaf-folds.The study concludes that the design of human-machine collaborative learning in the AI era should prioritize the development of learners' System 2 capacities,while enhancing task efficiency and sustaining learners' independent thinking,argumentative reflection,and transfer of learning.
陈向东;刘城烨
华东师范大学教育信息技术学系(上海200062)华东师范大学教育信息技术学系(上海200062)
社会科学
大语言模型双重加工理论人机协同系统1/系统2人机协同认知模型共享心智模型
Large language modelsDual-process theoryHuman-machine collaborationSystem 1/System 2Human-machine collaborative cognitive modelShared mental models
《远程教育杂志》 2026 (3)
37-47,93,12
2023年度全国教育科学规划一般项目"基于大语言模型的青少年人工智能教育研究"(项目编号:BCA230276).
评论