首页|期刊导航|信息资源管理学报|知识流动视角下的突破性成果早期识别研究

知识流动视角下的突破性成果早期识别研究OACHSSCD

Research on the Early Identification Method of Breakthrough Achievements from the Perspective of Knowledge Flow

中文摘要英文摘要

突破性研究能够极大推动科学技术的进步、拓展人类认知的边界,其成果的早期精准识别对于基础研究前瞻性布局、科研资源优化配置及国家创新战略制定具有重要意义.针对现有突破性成果识别研究多从单一维度入手、缺乏系统理论框架且难以揭示早期形成机制等问题,基于知识流动理论,构建涵盖"知识输入-知识生产-知识输出"全过程的分析框架,在此基础上,构建融合三个阶段多维特征(共计 15个指标)的早期识别指标体系,再通过不同机器学习算法构建识别模型进行对比试验,以优选出性能最佳的识别模型,最后,引入 SHAP 对识别模型进行解释,量化各个特征指标对突破性成果识别的重要性和贡献度.研究表明:①CatBoost 模型的识别效果最优;②识别突破性成果的三个早期关键信号分别是知识输出阶段的五年内被引次数和颠覆性指数,以及知识生产阶段的作者的最高学术成就;③识别模型在 APS 里程碑论文上展现出良好的泛化能力.本研究不仅为突破性成果的早期识别提供了兼具预测精度与解释深度的新范式,也为理解其早期形成机理提供了量化证据.

Breakthrough research drives greatly advances in science and technology,and expands the boundaries of human knowledge.The early identification of such achievements is essential for forward-looking basic research plan-ning,the efficient allocation of scientific resources,and the formulation of national innovation strategies.However,ex-isting studies on the identification of breakthrough achievements often focus on a single-dimension rather than an inte-grated theoretical framework,and few adequately explore the early formation mechanisms of breakthrough achieve-ments.To address these limitations,this study proposes a theoretical framework that grounded in knowledge flow theo-ry,encompassing the process of knowledge input,knowledge production,and knowledge output.Based on this frame-work,a multi-dimensional early identification index system comprising 15 indicators is constructed by integrating fea-tures across the three stages.Multiple machine learning algorithms are then employed to build identification models,from which the most effective model is selected.Finally,SHAP is applied to interpret the model and to quantify the relative importance and contributions of different features in the identification process.The results indicate that:① the CatBoost model demonstrates the best performance in early identification.② three key early signals are particularly in-fluential,which are citations within five years,disruption index within five years in the knowledge output stage,and the author's highest academic achievement in the knowledge production stage.③ the model exhibits strong generaliza-tion capability when it verified by APS milestone papers.Overall,this study proposes a novel paradigm that integrates predictive accuracy with interpretability for the early identification of breakthrough research,and provides evidence for understanding its early formation mechanisms.

叶青;王叶竹;谢云东;张朋

阜阳师范大学商学院,阜阳,236041||中国科学技术大学管理学院,合肥,230026中国科学技术大学图书馆,合肥,230026中国科学技术大学公共管理学院,合肥,230026阜阳师范大学商学院,阜阳,236041

社会科学

突破性成果知识流动理论早期识别机器学习SHAP

Breakthrough achievementsKnowledge flow theoryEarly identificationMachine learningSHAP

《信息资源管理学报》 2026 (2)

111-124,14

本文系国家自然科学基金青年科学基金项目"多源数据融合的颠覆性科研成果早期特征提取与识别模型构建"(72404261)、安徽省教育厅科学研究项目"多源融合视角下的学术不端行为关联网络及预测模型研究"(2025AHGXSK40135)和中国科学技术大学新文科基金项目"基于多模态时序语义增强的颠覆性科研成果动态预测及可解释性研究"(FSSF-A-260107)的研究成果之一.(This work is supported by the Youth Project funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China"Research on Early Feature Extraction and Iden-tification Model Construction of Disruptive Scientific Achievements Based on Multi-source Data Fusion"(72404261),the Scientific Research Project of the Education Department of Anhui Province,China"Research on the Associated Network and Prediction Model of Academic Mis-conduct from a Multi-Source Fusion Perspective"(2025AHGXSK40135),and the New Liberal Arts Fund of USTC"Dynamic Prediction and Ex-plainability of Disruptive Scientific Discoveries Based on Multimodal Temporal Semantic Enhancement"(FSSF-A-260107).)

10.13365/j.jirm.2026.02.111

评论