"辨于礼义,待以仁礼,群居和一"OA
Discerning Propriety and Righteousness,Treating Others with Benevolence and Propriety,and Living Together in Harmony and Unity:Xunzi's Perspective on Animals and His Ethical Wisdom
荀子哲学思想中的动物观,蕴含着丰富而辩证的动物伦理智慧.以"辨于礼义,待以仁礼,群居和一"为核心纲领,可以对荀子动物观进行一种体系化的理论建构.这一经过重构的思想体系,为应对当代动物伦理困境提供了一套根植于儒家传统又极具特色的中国方案.第一,它以"礼义"秩序明晰人与动物的区别,确立人之为人的类本质,为人的伦理主体性提供明确的辩护;第二,它提供了一种对待动物的情感与理性相结合的合理方式,即在不放弃基于仁爱的道德关怀的前提下,以基于礼义的理性规范调节人对动物的情感,以及合理有度地利用动物,为人类服务;第三,它提供了一种人与动物的应然相处之道,即"群居和一"式的和谐共生,建构了一种理想的动物生态伦理秩序.荀子动物观以体系化、独到新颖的动物伦理观念,对于解决当代动物伦理观念中的价值冲突与现实难题,具有深刻的启示.
Xunzi's philosophy contains a rich and dialectical wisdom of animal ethics within his perspective on animals.Taking"discerning propriety and righteousness,treating others with benevolence and propriety,and living together in harmony and unity"as the core guiding principle,we can construct a systematic theoretical framework for Xunzi's perspective on animals.This reconstructed ideological system provides a unique Chinese solution rooted in the Confucian tradition to address contemporary animal ethical dilemmas.First,it clarifies the difference between humans and animals through the order of"propriety and righteousness",establishes the essential nature of being human,and provides a clear defense for human ethical subjectivity.Second,it provides a reasonable way to combine emotions and rationality towards animals,that is,to regulate human emotions towards animals with rational norms based on propriety and righteousness,while not giving up moral care based on benevolence,and to utilize animals reasonably and moderately to serve humanity.Third,it provides a natural way of coexistence between humans and animals,namely the harmonious coexistence of"living together in harmony and unity",and constructs an ideal ecological and ethical order for animals.Xunzi's relatively systematic and original perspective of animal ethics holds profound implications for resolving the value conflicts and practical dilemmas in contemporary animal ethics.
邹海贵;陈光仁
南华大学马克思主义学院南华大学马克思主义学院
荀子动物观辨于礼义待以仁礼群居和一
Xunziperspective on animalsdiscerning propriety and righteousnesstreating others with benevolence and proprietyliving together in harmony and unity
《南京林业大学学报(人文社会科学版)》 2026 (2)
35-46,12
评论